Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
In intricate b&w spreads, Cole (Adventure Awaits) traces the life of a single oak from sprouting acorn to mature tree, detailing its relationship with the changing world around it. Short, documentary-style sentences describe the tree's growth and the complex ecosystem it sustains across approximately two centuries ("The oak tree's leaves and branches provide camouflage for the nest, as well as a good supply of insects for food"). As time passes, Indigenous people are pictured resting in the subject's shade. Later, a pale-skinned naturalist makes notes about the tree, a hole in a branch hosts myriad creatures, and human-built structures appear, as nearby trees are felled and vintage autos of different eras populate the pages. At last, the oak towers over a small town and shelters the stands of a festival the same way it shelters wildlife: "The tree is home." Meticulous spreads drawn entirely with fine pen combine the accuracy of scientific illustration with the dense patterning of tapestry. It's easy to imagine touching the oak's bark and feeling its crisp leaves in this study of an organism living among others. Back matter includes notes on building an ecosystem. Ages 4--8. (Feb.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Horn Book Review
The life of an oak tree is beautifully depicted in this engaging informational picture book. It begins with a simple yet profound concept: "A blue jay drops an acorn, and a tree's life begins." The narrative follows the acorn as it grows into a sapling, matures into a towering tree, and becomes a vital part of a forest ecosystem -- providing shelter, food, and resources to birds, insects, and mammals for more than two centuries. It produces acorns, but the text details reasons they don't necessarily grow into new oak trees. It also effectively depicts the effects of changes over time in the tree's environment, and of human development, as the forest gives way to a town. Cole's detailed, fine-lined pen-and-ink illustrations bring depth and life to the natural elements on each spread. With intricate layers, and endless details to pore over (find the camouflaged creatures!), the black-and-white art complements the minimal text, allowing readers to immerse themselves in the beauty of nature. The text strikes a balance between storytelling and information, educating readers about the oak tree's role in its ecosystem. The back matter provides helpful resources, such as steps to create an ecosystem and a diagram of forest habitat layers. Kirsten CaldwellMarch/April 2025 p.94 (c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Stately illustrations track an oak from seedling to majestic maturity. Cole doesn't cover the tree's entire life cycle in his finely textured, minutely detailed black-and-white drawings, but he does turn out a grand tale. It all begins with a blue jay that, pursued by a hawk, drops an acorn over a forest meadow. As seasons pass, the seedling grows into a sapling and then, over several centuries, into a spreading, thickly branched giant. Along the way, exactly drawn moths, migrating songbirds, and many other wild creatures flit through its dense sprays of leaves. In time, a single hole in a branch becomes home to nuthatches, flying squirrels, and wood ducks in succession, while small, generic human figures, including Indigenous people, sit in the shade below. The appearance of a simple cabin is followed by ever more and larger structures, until a town grows all around; in an expansive final scene, a crowd of modern residents gathers around the huge trunk in celebration. In closing comments amid vignettes of forest stories and subsurface biota, the author makes his theme explicit by describing how a tree such as this is a habitat that becomes an ecosystem of interdependent living things. So rich are the illustrations that viewers paging back are sure to spot more of those temporary and permanent residents each time. A few figures in the climactic crowd scene are dark-skinned. A thought-provoking book with lavish artwork that rewards close, and closer, looks.(Informational picture book. 6-8) Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
