Review by Booklist Review
After their grandmother's death, sisters Emma and Agathe return for one last visit to the house that provided a refuge during a turbulent and chaotic childhood. Raised by an emotionally and physically abusive mother, both women bear the psychological wounds of this tumultuous time, and while they were very close as girls, they have grown distant in adulthood. The week they are spending at their grandmother's seaside home is an opportunity to reconnect as well as say goodbye to the woman who provided stability in their lives. Diary entries shed light on the complicated dynamics at play in the sisters' relationship and the ways they supported and failed each other throughout the years. Grimaldi is a best-selling author in France, and her bittersweet English-language debut is sure to tug at the heartstrings of readers who appreciate moving novels which explore the complexities of sisterly love and mental illness, such as All My Puny Sorrows (2014), by Miriam Toews, or Everything Here is Beautiful (2018), by Mira T. Lee.
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Library Journal Review
Best-selling French writer Grimaldi's U.S. debut is luminously performed by Liz Fodor, who offers an affecting narration of sisters Emma and Agathe as children and middle-aged adults. The sisters, once close but now estranged, return to their grandmother's home in Spain after her death. The story alternates between the past (1985 through 2017) and the present day to illustrate how the family and the sisters fell apart. This is a story of the power of family and love, along with shared childhood trauma, mental illness, and grief. Grimaldi provides a sensitive depiction of mental illness, including the impact on caregivers, while still maintaining a hopeful tone. Fodor expertly narrates the sisters as children, creating an empathetic portrait that deepens as they come of age. She seamlessly incorporates the French words and phrases that are sprinkled throughout. Listeners will be swept up in the theme of what makes a good life, alongside the revelations of how the sisters' difficult childhood experiences impacted their present-day lives. VERDICT Recommended for listeners who enjoy literary family stories and translated works. An excellent choice for book clubs.--Taylor Skorski
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Two sisters. One week. A lifetime to understand. Popular French author Grimaldi's American debut charts the course of an emotional one-week reunion between two estranged sisters who retreat to their beloved grandmother's Basque home before it's sold to new owners. Older sister Emma (who sought out the meeting) and "little sister" Agathe--both now middle-aged--were close during a childhood marked by the death of their father and the increasing violence and drunkenness of their mother. The one constant source of security and affection during their formative years was their warm and caring paternal grandmother, Mima. After a five-year period of distance and alienation, the women fall back into old behaviors but relish the opportunity to be together, and in a place they both love. Telling the story through the women's alternating voices and spanning the decades of their lives, Grimaldi deftly illustrates the emotional damage visited on them by both their unstable upbringing and the fragile nature of their renewed relationship. Emma, who assumed a caretaking role toward Agathe in the face of their mother's abuse, has dealt with Agathe's fragile mental health throughout their lives (until the point where the relationship ruptured). Her motivation for repairing their fractured relationship is slowly and subtly revealed--and is responsible for a classic tear-jerker ending. Agathe's struggles with mental illness are sensitively handled, and Grimaldi respectfully reveals the stress this placed on Emma as well. The idyllic Basque setting sits in contrast to the sisters' recalled heartaches but serves as a balm to their sentimental souls as they recall the nurturing affection Mima provided. Translated from French by Serle, Grimaldi's account of two sisters taking stock of what's brought them this far is affecting but smile producing as well. A bittersweet slice of life. Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
