Review by Booklist Review
Shy Cecil is used to his friends in Florida, who all accept him for loving drawing and being who he is. But once his family moves to Massachusetts, Cecil has to learn how to make friends in an entirely new context--a bigger, majority-white public school. His older sister, Leah, warns him not to hang out too much with the white kids or else people will call him an "Oreo." Cecil struggles to find a way to stand up for himself to his dad and his peers, and he plays out scenarios in the comics he draws (which his dad says he spends too much time on). Debut graphic novelist Todd delicately portrays Cecil's journey grappling with identity and friendship in a semi-autobiographical narrative resonating with his retro art style and '80s callbacks, sure to appeal to a middle-school audience. Deftly exploring themes of self-discovery and the pursuit of dreams amid adversity, this offers a heartfelt portrayal of resilience and finding one's place in the world. A natural fit for fans of Jerry Craft or Raina Telgemeier.
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Debut creator Todd reminisces about growing up in the 1980s through the eyes of people-pleasing middle schooler Cecil Hall in this upbeat, semi-autobiographical tale. After moving from Florida to Massachusetts to accommodate his father's new job, aspiring cartoonist Cecil flounders under the weight of having to start all over again. His college-bound sister criticizes the lack of Black characters in his comics and advises him to befriend other Black kids at school to not be seen as an "Oreo." Simultaneously, his overworked father wants him to develop other interests besides his art and to "toughen up" and stand up for himself. To appease his father, Cecil takes an architecture class and hopes that his art will help him befriend classmates. But he finds it difficult to penetrate the predetermined social circles. Anxiety threatens to overwhelm him until he meets trickster Chris, a white student who uses his talents to make a profit-- and often gets Cecil in trouble. Todd's bold inks and vibrant, moody palette capture the nostalgia and inner dialogue of old-school comic strips, resulting in a refreshing take on classic newspaper illustrations that paints a lively graphic novel portrait of Cecil's trial-and-error approach to building authentic friendships and navigating pre-teen growing pains. Ages 8--12. (Apr.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review
Gr 4 Up--Todd's semi-autobiographical graphic novel depicts a quintessential and universal middle school experience. Drawing and comics are Cecil's passions as he enters the seventh grade at a new middle school in Boston after his family moved from Florida. His father and sister are very forthright about what they think Cecil should be focusing on as a 12-year-old Black boy. His father believes Cecil, who is not into sports or athletics, should be tough and ready to stand up for himself, and his sister believes Cecil should focus making Black friends at his new school. Cecil quickly realizes the cafeteria is the diciest part of being a new kid as he navigates social groups and searches for the right table to join. On a field trip, Cecil makes friends with a Black boy named Sean. Together, they collaborate to submit a comic to a local contest, winning second place. Even though Cecil struggles socially, he remains true to his dream to be a cartoonist and receives positive reinforcement from his peers and adults throughout the novel. It is easy to interpret the emotions of the characters in Todd's illustrations, which are straightforward and emotive. Middle grade readers will identify with Cecil's uncertainty about who he is, what he stands for, and who he wants to be. The ending may leave some wanting to know what happens next or hoping for a sequel. VERDICT A must-have for all middle grade collections, Timid is sure to fit right in next to other popular contemporary graphic novels such as Jerry Craft's New Kid, Allergic by Megan Wagner Lloyd, and Guts by Raina Telgemeier.--Kim Gardner
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
An aspiring cartoonist details his struggles with fitting into a new environment. Cecil, a 12-year-old Black boy who's only known life in Florida, learns that his family will be moving to Boston for his father's new job. Before his older sister embarks on her own college adventure, she gives him plenty of advice. Most importantly, she says, "Don't be no Oreo!" Cecil feels pressure to meet and impress the Black kids at his new, mostly white, school and to not be so timid; according to his father, he draws too much and needs to toughen up. But what Cecil truly cares about is drawing and finding people who share his interests. Before long, word begins to spread among his classmates that Cecil is a great artist, and they ask him to draw all kinds of things. Despite the effort it takes, Cecil hopes he'll become popular for his talents. He experiences racial microaggressions and betrayal, however, and realizes that these supposed friends don't truly value him. Cecil pushes himself to make new friends, and along the way, he learns how to advocate for himself as he makes strides in becoming a great cartoonist. The warm, nostalgic color palette complements the thick, fluid black lines. This well-paced story will appeal to readers who are struggling to claim their places in a world that tells them where they should fit in. An inspiring coming-of-age story. (additional comic, author's note) (Graphic fiction. 8-12) Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
