Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
In her commanding latest, Rekdal (Nightingale) incorporates various languages, historical documents, photographs, and other primary source texts. It reevaluates American history, linking the completion of the transcontinental railroad to the establishment of the Chinese Exclusion Act, which remained in effect from 1882 to 1943. Inspired by a poem carved into the Angel Island Immigration Station near San Francisco by an anonymous Chinese detainee, Rekdal "translates" the text character by character into a series of poems that reveal the hypocrisies and contradictions still prevalent in what it means to be "American" today. The collection opens with a poem following Abraham Lincoln's body on a funeral train in 1865 as it travels across seven states, asking: "Can you still believe in the promise of this union?" A later poem reimagines questions asked by immigration officials, reframing the humanity of Chinese immigrants: "What diseases of the heart/ do you carry? What country do you see/ when you think of your children?" Through these poems, readers are asked to wrestle with the complex, layered histories of race, creed, class, and gender that are all too often overlooked in monolithic presentations of America's past and present. Elegiac and shot through with righteous anger, this essential collection demands a national reckoning. (May)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Library Journal Review
The author of nonfiction (Appropriate: A Provocation) as well as verse (Nightingale), former Utah poet laureate Rekdal was commissioned in 2018 to write a poem commemorating the 150th anniversary of completion of the U.S. transcontinental railroad. What results is a captivating, extensively researched book blending poetry and essays, told from the perspective of the railroad workers while focusing on the lives and treatment of Chinese migrants and the devastation to the environment during the building process. In particular, the collection links the railroad's completion to the Chinese Exclusion Act (1882--1943) while probing an anonymous elegy carved into the walls of the Angel Island Immigration Station that honored a detainee who died by suicide. The collection is accompanied by a thorough notes section at once lyrical, informative, and autobiographical as Rekdal, whose mother is Chinese American, explores her own family history. In the end, the railroad is emblematic of both possibility and oppression; expanding her work to explore the Great Migration, Rekdal comments, "What is freedom/but the power to choose/ where you won't die?/ What is a train/ but the self once yoked to terror loosed/ inside a force that glides/ on heat and steam?" VERDICT A remarkable collection offering history not typically told in textbooks; an accompanying website (westtrain.org) with video poems and historical images adds context.--Sarah Michaelis
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.