Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Noah and his family live in New York City; his cousin Nora and her family live in Aotearoa, New Zealand. In frequent phone calls, the two pale-skinned kids compare seasonal differences between their respective hemispheres; as they do, they love arguing about "which one of them was upside down," Weissman writes. Hanukkah ups the ante on their friendly rivalry: is the holiday better in the winter or the summer? As they engage in activities (hot chocolate and snowballs vs. hot chips and cannonballs) and post photos to a shared album, Hoffman's jaunty, editorial-style cartoons show two kids who brim with individual confidence and who come to realize, through the nightly Hanukkah rituals, how much they share. This includes gratitude for "great miracles, then and now and all around," and a faith and traditions that transcend time zones and geography, making the world feel "right side up" no matter where they stand. Ages 4--8. (Sept.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review
PreS-Gr 2--This clever offering tells the story of two cousins on opposite sides of the world celebrating Hanukkah together and apart. Noah lives in New York, his cousin Nora lives in New Zealand, and they love to argue about which of them is upside down. They decide to have a photo contest about which Hanukkah is better. The story follows them as they do parallel but opposite things, yet celebrate the nights of Hanukkah in similar ways. Finally, each receives a present from the other: a shirt with "World's Best Cousin" printed upside down. The text and pictures weave together neatly. Using spot art, they each do something location appropriate (Noah has hot chocolate, Nora has hot chips), and then, integrated into the same spread, the same Hanukkah-related thing (eating sufganiyot). Appealing and accessible text is clear and deft, with nary a wasted word. The art is wonderful. Characters have shaggy hair and a Quentin Blake feel to them. The protagonists have light skin; Nora's father's has brown skin. Hoffmann fills the pages with movement, masterfully depicting the scenes with Noah and Nora doing the same thing by simply splitting pages in half so that they merge into each other, while using a cool palette for New York and a warm one for New Zealand. While the Hanukkah story is not explained, all the traditions are included. VERDICT Any library looking for Hanukkah books will want to add this unique international tale to their collection.--Amy Lilien-Harper
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Horn Book Review
Cousins Noah and Nora live on "opposite sides of the world," with Noah in New York and Nora in Aotearoa New Zealand. During Hanukkah, they compete to determine whose celebration is better: "Hanukkah's awesome in winter." "Maybe...but it's awesomer in summer." Over the course of the eight nights, readers learn some details about the holiday's rituals and about each of the settings. "Noah slid on his skates. Nora surfed to the shore. But on the seventh night of Hanukkah, they both spun sevivon -- and won gelt for gimel!" Digitally assembled pencil, charcoal, and brush and ink illustrations play up the humor (e.g., in the example above, both cousins have wiped out) and the friendly -- and futile -- competition. Elissa GershowitzNovember/December 2023 p.20 (c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Two Jewish children on opposite sides of the globe celebrate Hanukkah. Noah's a New Yorker; cousin Nora's a New Zealander. On phone chats, they compare time differences: When Noah eats Saturday dinner, Nora eats Sunday lunch; while Noah's school is closed for winter break, Nora's school is gearing up for summer. What's alike? Hanukkah's coming; each child has mailed the other a present. They hold a competition: "Winter vs. Summer! Who can have the world's best Hanukkah?" As usual, lifestyles contrast. Apparel and activities diverge because of seasonal dissimilarities, yet traditions are comparable: menorahs, savories, prayers, dreidels. The cartoony illustrations--created with pencil, charcoal, and brush and ink and then assembled digitally--are lively, and the tale is energetic. Some readers might wish the book had included a map displaying the vast geographic distance between the United States and New Zealand or a discussion of the earth's hemispheres. Still, it's an original and fun take on Hanukkah. The book also lacks a glossary and pronunciation guide. Occasionally, undefined words in Hebrew and Maori appear, though most are comprehensible contextually; additionally, a Hebrew prayer is incorporated into an illustration but goes untranslated. Noah, Nora, and their families are light-skinned; background characters are diverse. A reminder that holiday celebrations are fun, no matter when, no matter where. (Picture book. 4-8) Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
