Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
As a descendant of the infamous Frankenstein family, young Shelley feels compelled to follow in her ancestors' mad scientist footsteps. Accompanied by her younger brother Iggy, she aims to craft a creature frightening enough to terrorize their classmates. But the siblings' lifeless homemade monsters--comprising an assortment of plush toys--turn out more cuddly than scary. With countless experiments foiled, the duo is ready to give up, until their dog, Viktor, leads them to the Frankenstein family graveyard. It's there, Shelley realizes, that Viktor has been burying household odds and ends, such as their mother's beloved tea set. What's more, all of these objects have inexplicably come to life. Shelley seizes the opportunity to infuse her latest creation, CowPiggy, with a true spark of terror, but when CowPiggy begins running amok through town, Shelley fears that her initially harmless experiments might be getting out of hand. Textured hues set against simple backdrops highlight Shelley's ghoulish creations while conveying an appropriately eerie atmosphere without tipping into too-scary territory. In this delightfully creepy graphic novel series opener, Madden (A Christmas Too Big) strikes an easy balance between charm and chills. Ages 9--12. (Aug.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review
Gr 4 Up--Shelley Frankenstein wants to bring terrifying creatures to life like her famous ancestor, but unfortunately, her blood-curdling ideas tend to backfire. Her toy creature combinations should be frightening, but instead, every one of them turns out to be adorable. When Shelley and her brother Iggy combine a toy cow with a toy pig and bring it to life in the Frankenstein family graveyard, Shelley is determined to make this latest creature behave like a monster really should. She pushes past its natural instincts to say "MOINK" and give lots of hugs, and teaches it to be a creature that frightens children instead of delighting them. But this plan turns out to be Shelley's biggest mistake of all. This story is filled with plenty of dark and light humor, and it features a protagonist who learns over time that not everyone enjoys being scared, and not every creature wants to be scary. Readers will enjoy watching Shelley in her destructive mode, but they will also enjoy seeing her evolve into a girl who learns important lessons about whether getting scared is really fun. The cute and colorful artwork is simply charming, with plenty of visual humor that will keep kids (and adults) entertained. VERDICT For older kids who enjoy scary stories with a funny twist!--Andrea Lipinski
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.