Review by School Library Journal Review
PreS-Gr 1--A small glimpse into the everyday lives and possibilities of life as a "brotha" are shown in this book. Mance highlights the mundane "brothas wait for the bus" to the far out "brothas float…and fly." With each experience, a sense of unity comes to life and an excellent mirror is provided for those students who might not see themselves in the everyday classroom read-aloud. The text and vocabulary are all daily things students know or excellent sight words, standing clearly against the page while describing the picture. The illustrations Mance has created are also eye-catching, with colors and activities flowing from one page to the next. These provide excellent context clues for some words that describe less simple activities, or the same word in different ways. For example, "play" is shown as playing an instrument, playing basketball, and playing video games in separate pictures. Altogether, Mance has created a resonant reflection of everyday life for those learners who are discovering the possibilities of the world around them, but who also want to see their brothas in a book. VERDICT A great read-aloud to show a vibrant community, whether in a mirror or a window.--Margaret Kennelly
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Black men living their everyday lives. Drawing on language patterns and speech traditions commonly used within the African American community, Mance refers to Black men as brothas in this picture book that poses the question, "What do Brothas do all day?" The question is fully answered in spreads of bold illustrations that feature Black men of varying sizes, shapes, and skin tones. Simple text lets readers know that brothas spend their days engaged in a variety of activities: "Brothas drive. Brothas ride. Brothas wait for the bus." Brothas "cook…and eat. Brothas float…and fly." "Brothas march." "Brothas listen." And, of course, brothas love. Mace's distinctive artistic style will be familiar to readers of her 1001 Black Men Sketchbook series. The illustrations, which show a deft use of collage, drawing, and other elements, capture the characters' positive energy and camaraderie. The use of specific cultural details, such as brothas preparing black-eyed peas and visiting the barbershop, makes for a depiction that rings true. Mance's linework brilliantly conveys dynamic physical movement as Black men take part in everything from jumping rope and skateboarding to dancing and playing basketball. Readers young and old will delight in exploring the ways that brothas live their wonderful lives. A welcome recognition of Black men and the joyous ways they show up for their families, their communities, and each other. (Picture book. 3-8) Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.