Review by School Library Journal Review
Gr 1--4--From the creators of Girl Dad, this title has a rhyming narrative running under scenes of a variety of Black fathers and their sons engaged in domestic activities (such as house-painting), having adventures in the wilderness (like fishing), on the football field, or at the head of the table where there are elders present. The fathers are diversely depicted sporting crew cuts, locs, faded 'fros, even wearing do-rags to maintain their waves at bedtime. This works as well as the previous book and is wonderful for sharing in units on family. The dynamic illustrations are vibrant, expressing warmth between family members, engagement, and a broad range of settings to make all children feel seen and included. VERDICT A picture book that depicts beautiful fathers in a nuanced way that is great for sharing one-on-one or in the classroom.--Ruth Guerrier-Pierre
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Following up Girl Dad (2022), Williams and Davis present an affectionate tribute to the bond between fathers and sons. As Williams describes how "boy dads" love and support their sons, images show Black fathers and sons fishing, watching movies, flying kites, playing football, and more. Davis' illustrations are full of color and movement. The rhyming text has a cadence that matches the upbeat visuals and will appeal to emerging readers. While some moments hew closely to traditional ideas of masculinity and chivalry (the verse "It's no easy task teaching a boy just how to be a man. / But boy dads raise fine gentlemen the very best they can" accompanies an image of a boy holding out a chair for a female-presenting child), the book also challenges stereotypes. In one scene, a boy and his father, clad in aprons, whip up a tasty concoction in the kitchen. In another, a father comforts his son, who's teary-eyed after spilling a dish of mac and cheese: "Boy dad knows to be brave and strong / means sometimes you have to cry." The love between fathers and sons shines through on each page; many men and boys of color will especially appreciate seeing their experiences reflected here. (This book was reviewed digitally.) Heartening examples of paternal love. (Picture book. 4-8) Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.