Review by Booklist Review
Kornblatt's (The Reason for Wings) first novel in twenty years is a slim, episodic meditation on the meaning of home and the stories we tell in contribution to the making of a life. Nella has grown up in Australia with her loving yet secretive mother, Eve. When Eve is diagnosed with terminal cancer, she leaves Nella a letter telling her that she was a nurse in Pittsburgh and stole Nella from the hospital when she was days old. Feeling betrayed, Nella is left questioning everything: the insular world Eve created, now knowing it was out of fear of discovery; her connection with her husband, wondering if they were drawn to one another subconsciously, as he was also stolen--from his unwed teenage mother, by the Catholic Church. She also considers how Eve's only given reason for taking Nella was that she felt compelled. While the premise seems like it would lead to a sensational, ripped-from-the-headlines story, this is in every way a thoughtful, forceful, and beautifully written novel about family and identity.
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Kornblatt (The Reason for Wings) marks a 20-year comeback with a perfectly crafted novel featuring a middle-aged woman who discovers she was kidnapped as an infant. Nella Pine, a writer and teacher, tells the reader how she's learned at 45 that Ruth, the woman she thought was her mother for her whole life, stole her from a Pittsburgh hospital nursery. Ruth then fled to Australia, where she gave Nella a good life. In flashbacks, the reader sees how Nella and Ruth share a home with an affectionate, childless widow who treats the two strangers like family. After Ruth is diagnosed with terminal cancer, she writes a confession to Nella about her crime, revealing the facts about Nella's birth family. Nella finds the letter after Ruth's death and, after recovering from the shock, finally makes sense of the constant state of subterfuge that shadowed their lives in Australia. As Nella reclaims her birth name, Naomi, she reflects on her deceased husband, who was separated from his unwed birth mother as an infant by the Catholic Church, and considers how loss tied them together. Kornblatt imbues her narrator's pursuit of self-identity with carefully measured prose: "I came upon the facts of my existence as one who returns to her home in the midst of a burglary: here is the shattered glass, the rifled drawers, the thief with the booty still cradled in her guilty arms." This author's worthy return is full of grace and substance. (Sept.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved