Review by Booklist Review
Hamid's (Exit West, 2017) latest concise, powerful novel begins when Anders awakens one day to find that his previously white skin has inexplicably darkened and his body has become unrecognizable. Concealing his transformation from everyone except Oona, his casual romantic partner, Anders grapples with his changed appearance and fears facing the world as a stranger in his own life. Meanwhile, Oona, still reeling from the tragic death of a loved one and saddled with the care of her aging, vulnerable, and racist mother, is still figuring out what her relationship to Anders means while also learning to cope in a rapidly destabilizing world. As more and more people begin to change skin color, Anders and Oona navigate through their new world, contending with both societal and personal upheaval. Though the spare prose effectively conveys an underlying sense of doom and violence on the periphery for most of the novel, the story ultimately surprises. Hamid imaginatively takes on timely, universal topics, including identity, grief, community, family, race, and what it means to live through sudden and often violent change.
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
On the first page of Hamid's underwhelming latest (after Exit West), a white man named Anders wakes up to find he has mysteriously "turned a deep and undeniable brown." From this Kafkaesque beginning, Hamid spins a timely if unsatisfying racial allegory in which, one after another, the white inhabitants of an unnamed country become dark-skinned. Hamid mutes the power by harnessing his plot to the dishwater-dull Anders, who works at a gym, and his equally bland girlfriend, Oona, a yoga instructor. The lack of social context is also puzzling, with the story set in an unspecified time and place largely stripped of historical and cultural detail. Hamid employs a cool, spare prose style with little dialogue, leaving the reader to feel like the action of the novel is taking place behind a wall of soundproof glass. The glass briefly shatters when white militants come for Anders, though the author quickly turns back the threat. Later, when Oona's mother, who indulges in right-wing conspiracy theories, is sickened by the sight of her white daughter in bed with dark-skinned Anders, Hamid taps the rich potential of his premise. For the most part, though, this remains stubbornly inert. Agent: Jay Mandel, WME. (Aug.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Library Journal Review
At the beginning of Mohsin Hamid's (Exit West) dreamlike new novel, a white man named Anders wakes to discover that his skin "has turned a deep, undeniable brown." At first, Anders reveals the change only to his on-again, off-again lover Oona, but they soon discover that Anders is not the only white person to have changed. Anders and Oona grapple with their parents' and their own reactions to the change, as the town descends into chaos around them, with some of the remaining white men forming militias and peddling conspiracy theories online. The author reads the novel, which is light on dialogue and full of looping, peripatetic sentences that reflect the characters' inner thoughts and memories but leave the setting and specifics of the plot hazy. Hamid narrates with a measured tone that matches the sense of distance created by the prose. VERDICT Listeners looking for distinctive voices and high emotion may be disappointed, but fans of Hamid's allegorical storytelling will enjoy this thought-provoking novel, paired with Hamid's restrained performance.--Emily Calkins
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
A brilliantly realized allegory of racial transformation. Hamid's latest opens with a scenario worthy of Kafka: A young man named Anders awakens "to find he [has] turned a deep and undeniable brown." Faced with the shock of this metamorphosis, he punches the mirror that reveals the stranger who is he. He then calls in sick, at which his boss growls, "You don't work, you don't get paid." Meanwhile, his old girlfriend, Oona, returns to the unnamed town--perhaps somewhere in South Africa, although, this being a fairy tale of sorts, it's in an aoristic nowhere--and takes up with the new Anders even as Oona's mother sighs that "our people" are changing. It's true, for the whole town is slowly turning brown. Writes Hamid in a characteristically onrushing sentence, "The mood in town was changing, more rapidly than its complexion, for Anders could not as yet per-ceive any real shift in the number of dark people on the streets...but the mood, yes, the mood was changing, and the shelves of the stores were more bare, and at night the roads were more abandoned." Anders returns to work at a local gym, where he finds that the few remaining White people are looking at him with "quick, evasive stares," no longer trusting the man they called "doc" for his sore-muscle healing powers. When Anders' father--the last White man of Hamid's title--dies, there are no more of the "pale people who wandered like ghosts" in the town, and as time passes those who are left slowly lose their "memories of whiteness." Hamid's story is poignant and pointed, speaking to a more equitable future in which widespread change, though confusing and dislocating in the moment, can serve to erase the divisions of old as they fade away with the passing years. A provocative tale that raises questions of racial and social justice at every turn. Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
