Review by Booklist Review
It took a year for Buck to build a 10-ton poplar flatboat and sail it two-thousand miles through massive barge traffic and the notoriously dangerous waters of the Mississippi to New Orleans. The author, who previously traveled the Oregon Trail in a covered wagon, convincingly makes the case that the explosion of inland-river travel in the early-nineteenth century set the stage for the westward expansion of settlers. In this inventive melding of history and travelogue, he manages to largely ignore the warnings that he'll die on the journey and learns to trust his instincts. Along the way, he deals with some unmanageable crew members and meets both generous and unsavory characters. Even while reveling in following in the wake of early flatboaters, Buck explores the darker impact of the push west on Indigenous people and the enslaved. After several months and some broken ribs, seesawing between exhaustion and elation, Buck finds that his travels free him from the myths of history to see the complex reality of both past and present life on the mighty Mississippi.
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Journalist Buck, who documented his travels by covered wagon in The Oregon Trail, returns with a captivating and occasionally cantankerous account of the 2,000-mile, four-month flatboat journey he made in 2016 down the Ohio and Mississippi rivers from Pittsburgh to New Orleans. Inspired by Pennsylvania farmer Jacob Yarder, whose 1782 expedition to Louisiana helped launch the flatboat era, and Harlan and Anna Hubbard, married artists who documented their own seven-year journey down the Ohio and Mississippi rivers in the 1944 book Shantytown: A River Way of Life, Buck built his own flatboat and assembled a politically and geographically diverse crew to help navigate it down some of the most treacherous waters in America. Throughout, he interweaves intriguing discussions of U.S. political, cultural, and economic history with sharp critiques of "traditional historians" who neglect "the hardscrabble, edgy lives of most 19th-century Americans," reveries on how the light reflects off riverine landscapes, and tense accounts of modern hazards, including extensive lock-and-dam systems and barge traffic. He also draws memorable sketches of local characters he meets along the way, and offers fascinating tidbits about Newburgh, Ind.; New Madrid, Mo.; and other river towns. Rough-edged, well informed, and honest about his own blind spots, Buck is a winning tour guide. American history buffs and armchair adventurers will relish the trip. (Aug.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Library Journal Review
This book tells the story of journalist Buck's (The Oregon Trail; Flight of Passage) quest to sail a flatboat 2000 miles down the Ohio and Mississippi Rivers from Pittsburgh to New Orleans with a varied crew and many helpers along the way. As the adventurous Buck writes, this four-month journey traced the inland water route often taken in the years between the American Revolution and Civil War. The narrative works as a memoir, a history treatise, and a travel adventure. The author comes to terms with his mother's death on this journey, but he also places his traveling adventures into a broader historical framework of how flatboats epitomized frontier resilience and ingenuity. Simultaneously, he also explores modern politics and culture, reflects on economic realities both past and present, and considers both ugly and uplifting aspects of American history. VERDICT The author's use of cited local history books in libraries along his journey gives the book a strong factual basis as a history text, and his incorporation of literary words from writers of the flatboat era infuse his own writing with humor and poetic charm. Highly recommended for all libraries.--Karen Bordonaro
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
An invigorating blend of history and journalism informs this journey down Old Man River. Buck walks the walk, or perhaps rows the row: As with his previous book on the Oregon Trail, he follows the path of preceding generations in the hope of seeing something of what they saw. That's not easy in the case of the Mississippi River, which, along with one of its principal tributaries, the Ohio, is "jointly managed by the U.S. Coast Guard and the Army Corps of Engineers exclusively for the benefit of commercial barge traffic." With those massive strings of barges, some as many as 25 containers long, clogging the river, traversing it by means of an old-fashioned wooden flatboat seems an invitation to disaster. Yet that's just what Buck did, building his own craft in the manner of the 19th-century pioneers who saw in the river system a means of knitting far-flung territories into a nation. Building the boat was a challenge, and the author "would shortly learn that the flatboat was indeed an ideal school for acquiring a knowledge of human nature." Buck populates his invigorating narrative with a memorable cast of characters, some people who traveled with him, some people he met along the way. The author was courtly to all of them, save a loudmouth Trumper who "considered it absolutely vital to explain to me that the ''nited states of 'merica' was being ruined by 'librals and buree-cats.' " Buck's adventures alternate between nearly being swamped by massive commercial vessels and dealing with more mundane disasters; as he noted to his first mate, "Clusterfuck is our new normal." Besides being a willing and intrepid traveler, Buck is also an able interpreter of history, and it's clear that he's devoured a library of Mississippiana. It all makes for an entertaining journey in the manner of William Least Heat-Moon, John McPhee, and other traveler-explainers. For armchair-travel aficionados and frontier-history buffs, it doesn't get much better. Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
