I'd like to say sorry, but there's no one to say sorry to Stories

Mikołaj Grynberg

Book - 2021

"Mikolaj Grynberg is a psychologist and photographer who has spent years collecting and publishing oral histories of Polish Jews. In his first work of fiction--a book that has been widely praised by critics and was shortlisted for Poland's top literary prize--Grynberg recrafts those histories into little jewels, fictionalized short stories with the ring of truth. Both biting and knowing, I'd Like to Say Sorry, but There's No One to Say Sorry To takes the form of first-person vignettes, through which Grynberg explores the daily lives and tensions within Poland between Jews and gentiles haunted by the Holocaust and its continuing presence. In "Unnecessary Trouble," a grandmother discloses on her deathbed that she... is Jewish; she does not want to die without her family knowing. What is passed on to the family is fear and the struggle of what to do with this information. In "Cacophony," Jewish identity is explored through names, as Miron and his son Jurek demonstrate how heritage is both accepted and denied. In "My Five Jews," a non-Jewish narrator remembers five interactions with her Jewish countrymen, and her own anti-Semitism, ruefully noting that perhaps she was wrong and should apologize, but no one is left to say "I'm sorry" to. Each of the thirty-one stories is a dazzling and haunting mini-monologue that highlights a different facet of modern Poland's complex and difficult relationship with its Jewish past."--Provided by publisher.

Saved in:

1st Floor Show me where

FICTION/Grynberg Mikolaj
1 / 1 copies available
Location Call Number   Status
1st Floor FICTION/Grynberg Mikolaj Checked In
Subjects
Genres
Short stories
Published
New York : The New Press 2021.
Language
English
Polish
Main Author
Mikołaj Grynberg (author)
Other Authors
Sean Gasper Bye (translator)
Item Description
Originally published in Poland as Rejwach by Wydawnictwo Nisza in 2017.
Physical Description
viii, 136 pages ; 20 cm
ISBN
9781620976838
  • Unnecessary Trouble
  • Arkadia
  • Cacophony
  • An Elegant Purse
  • Bitter Chocolate
  • My Five Jews
  • An Empty Jewish Soul
  • The Old Story
  • The First Visit
  • The German Boy
  • Procession
  • Last Resort
  • Klementyna
  • Invisible Thoughts
  • Imaginary Friends
  • Chess
  • The End of Time
  • At Hitler's
  • With Mom
  • The Convent
  • Common Good
  • Sweet Dreams
  • On the Aryan Side
  • The Chair
  • Birthright
  • Horizon
  • A Jewish Barter
  • Bringing Families Together
  • Anatevka
  • A Joke for You
  • Stagnant Waters
  • Notes
  • Translator's Note.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review

The vital English-language debut from Grynberg, a photographer, psychologist, and oral historian, features 31 first-person vignettes narrated by Jews and gentiles in Poland who belong to the generation born after the Holocaust. Through these monologues, the speakers struggle with survivor's guilt as they come to terms with the horrors of the ghettos and the camps as experienced by their family and friends. Common themes among them are wanting to forget the past so as to belong to the living and feeling alienated in the present by both family and fellow countrymen. In "An Elegant Purse," the speaker is determined to find her grandparents' graves. As it dawns on her that her mother was Jewish, she has a new purpose: "I'm learning how to be a daughter all over again." "Procession" tells the story of a woman whose grandfather mistakenly believed the French would protect his family, but they were arrested and everyone, except the narrator's mother, died in Auschwitz. As a photographer, Grynberg knows the value of capturing a moment in time; through these narratives, the reader sees, as translator Bye notes, "something we might not have seen with our own eye." These views of a tragic past are brought sharply into focus. (Feb.)Correction: This review has been updated to better reflect the range of first-person accounts contained in the book. It has also been corrected; an earlier version misgendered one of the character.

(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Kirkus Book Review

A series of monologues describing Jewish life in contemporary--and not-so-contemporary--Poland. Grynberg, a photographer and psychologist as well as a writer, is known in his native Poland for his oral histories: collections of interviews with Polish Jews about their experiences. His first work of fiction--and his first work to appear in English--makes use of those interviews as a jumping-off point. The book takes the form of a collection of fictionalized monologues, each no longer than three or four pages. In several of them, the speakers are surprised to learn that they themselves are Jewish when older relatives reveal the truth that, for years, they'd been hiding. In one, a boy only learns he's Jewish after his grandmother sends him off to a Jewish summer camp. In another, three little girls pretend they're hiding through the war in a cellar, where their antisemitic father is surprised to find them. In a note at the end of the book, Grynberg's translator, Bye, describes the book as "not so much polyphonic as clamorous." It's an apt description; the collection, in which dozens of voices clamor to be heard, is a moving and often wryly funny portrait of Polish Jewishness. Grynberg has zeroed in on a particular generation--one that is once or twice removed from the Holocaust, the children or grandchildren of survivors. Taken as a whole, the collection traces the commonalities as well as the differences among all these experiences. And while the result can be grim, Grynberg's deft, light touch also provides a sense of levity, hope, and even laughter. At times witty, at others devastating, Grynberg's first foray into fiction is a major triumph. Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.

Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.