The invisible kingdom Reimagining chronic illness

Meghan O'Rourke

Book - 2022

"A landmark exploration of one of the most consequential and mysterious issues of our time: the rise of chronic illness and autoimmune diseases. A silent epidemic of chronic illnesses afflicts tens of millions of Americans: these are diseases that are poorly understood, frequently marginalized, and can go undiagnosed and unrecognized altogether. Renowned writer Meghan O'Rourke delivers a revelatory investigation into this elusive category of "invisible" illness that encompasses autoimmune diseases, post-treatment Lyme disease syndrome, and now long COVID. Drawing on her own medical experiences as well as a decade of interviews with doctors, patients, researchers, and public health experts, O'Rourke traces the histor...y of Western definitions of illness, and reveals how inherited ideas of cause, diagnosis, and treatment have led us to ignore a host of hard-to-understand medical conditions, ones that resist easy description or simple cures. And as America faces this health crisis of extraordinary proportions, the populations most likely to be neglected by our institutions include women, the working class, and people of color. Blending lyricism and erudition, candor and empathy, O'Rourke brings together her deep and disparate talents and roles as critic, journalist, poet, teacher, and patient, synthesizing the personal and universal into one monumental project arguing for a seismic shift in our approach to disease. The Invisible Kingdom offers hope for the sick, solace and insight for their loved ones, and a radical new understanding of our bodies and our health"--

Saved in:

2nd Floor Show me where

616.044/O'Rourke
3 / 3 copies available
Location Call Number   Status
2nd Floor 616.044/O'Rourke Checked In
2nd Floor 616.044/O'Rourke Checked In
2nd Floor 616.044/O'Rourke Checked In
Subjects
Genres
Self-help publications
Published
New York : Riverhead Books [2022]
Language
English
Main Author
Meghan O'Rourke (author)
Physical Description
324 pages ; 24 cm
Bibliography
Includes bibliographical references (pages 275-314) and index.
ISBN
9781594633799
9780593541456
Contents unavailable.
Review by Booklist Review

What does it mean to have a disease doctors can't diagnose? In her pensive inquiry into chronic illness, O'Rourke chronicles lots of tests and expense, frustration and anger, continued suffering and grief, uncertainty and lack of control, and skepticism from health care professionals and friends. Admitting to feeling "intermittently unwell" since college graduation and slowly worsening, she recounts an assortment of symptoms, including fatigue, aches, rash, fever, and brain fog. At one point, O'Rourke had nine doctors. While receiving conventional therapies (thyroid medication, antibiotics), she also sought alternative and complementary treatments. She perused internet forums where information, advice, and support were readily available. A definitive, unifying diagnosis remained elusive. O'Rourke was told she suffered from autoimmune thyroiditis, postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome, genetic hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, and chronic Lyme disease. Lessons learned: Anxiety, loneliness, and depression can accompany chronic disease. A trusting doctor-patient relationship is vital. Empathy is essential. Citing chronic fatigue syndrome, fibromyalgia, and chronic Lyme disease as examples,O'Rourke notes that many chronic conditions are poorly understood or controversial, which leads to marginalizing or delegitimizing patients' suffering. O'Rourke warns, "The less we understand about a disease or a symptom, the more we psychologize, and often stigmatize, it." An affecting portrayal of how we view disease, experience illness, and search for healing.

From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review

With a poet's sensibility, journalist's rigor, and patient's personal investment, O'Rourke (The Long Goodbye) sheds light on the physical and mental toll of having a mysterious chronic illness. "I got sick the way Hemingway says you go broke: 'gradually and then suddenly,' " she writes before delving into the decades-long game of cat and mouse she played with symptoms ranging from rashes to exhaustion starting in the late 1990s. As she reflects on the labyrinthine system she had to navigate before eventually being diagnosed with late-stage Lyme disease, O'Rourke traces the history of Western medicine--from the "dramatic clarity" of germ theory to its murky treatment and dismissal of patients it can't diagnose. As she writes, "It is a truth universally acknowledged among the chronically ill that a young woman in possession of vague symptoms... will be in search of a doctor who believes she is actually sick." Wary of "late-capitalist" illness narratives that demand either wellness or wisdom from sick people, O'Rourke shirks a tidy recovery story and instead mines her abjection, astonishment, and vulnerability--and the radical illness writings of Alphonse Daudet, Alice James, and Audre Lorde--to offer a stunningly raw account of living with the existential complexities of a sickness that "never fully resolves." Readers will be left in awe. (Mar.)

(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Library Journal Review

In this personal and deeply moving exploration of life with chronic illness, O'Rourke (The Long Goodbye) focuses on her own illness and weaves in the history of Western medicine and interviews with medical practitioners and researchers, for an overview of how Westerners regard autoimmune disease and chronic illness. O'Rourke details that the conflict isn't necessarily between a sick person and their disease but between a sick person and symptom-based Western medicine and health care. Chronic illness, in particular autoimmune diseases, manifest as painful acute symptoms and also vague periods of "unwellness" but different and changing over time and seemingly unrelated, the author explains. Without persistent self-advocacy, a support network, and a wealth of resources (and as O'Rourke illustrates so poignantly, even with these things), diagnoses may take years or never happen. O'Rourke acknowledges the white privilege and relative wealth that color her experience and reminds readers that health outcomes and diagnoses depend on race, class, and gender identity and expression. VERDICT This work may serve as an affirmation that people living with chronic illness are not alone. For those close to one with chronic illness or who would like to learn more, this firsthand account is both moving and educational.--Rachel M. Minkin

(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review

Tormented for years by enervating symptoms, the author spent most of her 30s dealing with--and trying to understand--chronic illness. "To become chronically ill is not only to have a disease that you have to manage," writes poet and Yale Review editor O'Rourke, "but to have a new story about yourself, a story that many people refuse to hear--because it is deeply unsatisfying, full of fits and starts, anger, resentment, chasms of unruly need. My own illness story has no destination." Here, the author constructs that story from building blocks of personal narrative and science journalism, with deep dives into the technicalities of the immune system and the microbiome. The personal sections are engaging and well written--"What I had wasn't just an illness now; it was an identity, a membership in a peculiarly demanding sect. I had joined the First Assembly of the Diffusely Unwell. The Church of Fatigue, Itching, and Random Neuralgia. Temple Beth Ill"--as O'Rourke ably documents her myriad appointments with both Western and alternative practitioners, toting thick stacks of medical records, exploring various autoimmune diagnoses and treatment plans. Some are bizarre and/or dubious, others disgusting but legit (fecal microbiota transplant). Just when the author felt totally lost in the labyrinth of Lyme disease, prescribed the very antibiotics she believed had damaged her body in the first place, she finally found the beginning of a road to health. Though O'Rourke roundly rejects the notion that illness and suffering are somehow balanced by spiritual benefits, her conclusion offers hope. "Today, as a new paradigm for disease is emerging--pushed into full view by the coronavirus pandemic and the epidemic of long COVID--we must amend the simple 'germ causes disease, body overcomes disease' model….A holistic, individualized approach to medicine may matter more than was once thought." Emotionally compelling and intellectually rich, particularly for those with a personal connection to the issue. Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.

Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.

one "Gradually and Then Suddenly" In the fall of 1997, after I graduated from college, I began experiencing what I called "electric shocks"-stabbing sensations that flickered over my legs and arms every morning, as if I were being stung by tiny bees. The shocks were so extreme that as I walked to work from my East Village basement apartment, I often had to stop and rub my legs against a parking meter; if I didn't, my muscles would twitch and my legs would jerk. My doctor couldn't figure out what was wrong-dry skin, he proposed-and eventually the shocks went away. A year later, they returned for a few months, only to go away again just when I felt I couldn't bear them any longer. In my twenties, the shocks and other strange symptoms-bouts of vertigo, fatigue, joint pain, memory problems, night sweats, tremors-came and went. For a year, every night around two a.m., I would wake up in a sweat to find hives covering my legs, leaving me itchy and wide awake, my pajamas and sheets so wet I had to change them. Doctors prescribed a daily dose of antihistamines until the hives went away. There was a test that suggested lupus, and then a follow-up that showed nothing was wrong; my lab work looked fine. "The tests were all negative. It's just one of those things that will go away," a specialist told me. I remember thinking, Don't you want to know why I have severe hives? In the way of women who have internalized disordered ideas about food and control, I associated my strange bouts of fatigue and discomfort with eating poorly (even though I ate a reasonably healthy diet). It was easy, in those years, to feel that a lack of dietary discipline played a role in my exhaustion, because I could tell, vaguely, that certain foods made me feel worse, leading me to assume responsibility for my own unwellness. I toggled between the conviction that something had to be wrong-I didn't feel OK-and the conviction that I was to blame, and if I just stopped eating sugar, or pizza, say, I'd be fine. One night, I woke up suddenly from a nightmare that a man in a dirty gray sweatshirt was stabbing me. My period had started, but in addition to the cramps I had a sharp pain in my lower right abdomen. The pain grew in magnitude until, heat flushing my body, I suddenly vomited. I thought perhaps I had appendicitis, but the pain went away an hour later, just as I was preparing to go to the ER. "Everyone feels cramps," my gynecologist told me when I asked about it. At the advice of a friend, I went to see her gynecologist. This doctor listened and nodded when I mentioned the stabbing pain; I felt relief at the recognition. She did an exam and ultrasound. "I think you might have endometriosis, an immune-modulated disease where tissue from the uterus gets out and coats the abdomen and other organs, causing pain," she said. "But it doesn't really matter unless you want to get pregnant: it can cause infertility. Later we might want to address it with surgery. For now, I'd just take ibuprofen during your period." She gave me some tissues and I wiped myself, dressed, and left, puzzled by the way my pain had been relegated to a sign that my fertility might be compromised, not a problem in its own right. When I was twenty-four, I started waking up with a feeling that a foggy miasma filled my brain. I would go for long runs before work to clear my head, lacing up my shoes, sweating off the sleep hangover. I thought everyone felt this way, that I was just fighting off a cold. But why was I so often on the verge of a cold-more than anyone else I knew? Periodically, I would start digging a little. In 2005, around the time of my twenty-ninth birthday, I was strangely enervated. I remember googling my symptoms and being struck by how much they matched those of several autoimmune diseases. I showed the results page to Jim; as the screen cast a blue light against his face, he nodded. "You are tired a lot for someone so young," he said. But then my doctors would reassure me that my lab work looked fine, and I'd return to trying to power through. My tendency to ignore my symptoms derived in part from the fact that I grew up in a family that was largely indifferent to matters of health. As a child in Brooklyn-my parents were teachers at the school I attended-I had been raised not to think too much about my body. My parents had moved to the city from New Jersey, where they had grown up in large Irish American Catholic families. They were pragmatic and rather stoical. Like many in their baby boomer generation, they saw doctors as unquestionable experts. You didn't go to them unless you had a high fever or a bad fall or a wound that needed stitching. In that case, you got a diagnosis, you took medicine or had surgery, and you got better, more or less in that order. But if the doctor told you nothing was wrong, nothing was wrong. My parents believed in the power of Western medicine, and therefore so did I. Ours was a family where health was not ever thought of as something to optimize or even talk about. So they took us to the doctor regularly and handed out Tylenol for fevers, but if the problem at hand was vague or seemingly minor, they tended to ignore it, telling us to buck up. As a kid, I had lots of "small things" wrong-bad allergies, muscle pain, poor digestion-which in retrospect I suspect were subtle clues about what was coming, but my parents did not pay much mind to them. I got used to being uncomfortable, in other words, and I internalized the idea that my mentioning my discomfort made me fussy-"The princess and the pea," my mother once said, in irritation, making it clear that I was demanding too much when I complained. Still, there were moments that suggested something was not right. In July 2008, I had an early dinner with my mother-who was then on her fourth round of chemotherapy for stage 4 colorectal cancer-and my father on their patio in Connecticut. It was ninety degrees, and the sun was still up. The patio smelled of mint and basil and the air was thickly humid. I was shivering so much I put on a sweater. "You look more uncomfortable than I do," said my mother, giving me a sharp glance, her dark eyes tightening with unusual concern. "Are you OK?" I wasn't sure. When I woke up the next morning, I was exhausted and foggy headed. My mother knocked on the door, wanting to take a walk on the beach. Her black eyes were bright with the eagerness to live, and I found myself thinking that it seemed like my mother, despite undergoing chemotherapy, had more energy than I did. All this was the backstory (not yet recognized as a story) to that moment in Vietnam when I found myself gazing at the angry red bumps on my wrist. This rash means something, I thought, trying to return to my book, as the wind whipped the palm trees and a large leaf clattered to the ground. All these little problems-they mean something. I stroked the bumps as if they could spell out a word that would unlock the mystery. At home in Brooklyn, three days after Jim and I returned from Vietnam, I developed a low fever. It was February 2012. Inside our prewar apartment the radiators hissed and clanked, sending heat through the rooms. Jim had to travel to a conference. I slept strange hours tangled in sweaty sheets. My limbs felt heavy, watery. For two more weeks, I drifted along in a flu-like malaise that I thought was protracted jet lag. At the time, to support my life as a writer and journalist, I taught in the graduate creative writing program at New York University. I had also taken a job as a visiting writer at Princeton. I was trying to start writing a new book, but it was going slowly. I couldn't seem to focus. The jet lag did not go away. Teaching, which I had once loved, now felt onerous. In my Monday afternoon seminar, I had trouble forming sentences. As I spoke, with my students' faces turned earnestly toward me, I felt the point of my sentences receding further and further away. I slipped out on a break for a double espresso, but the caffeine failed to clear the wooliness in my mind. I got headaches and felt dizzy when I ate; my throat was often sore. I kept reversing phrases-saying things like, "I'll meet you at the cooler water." One morning in March, I sat down at my desk in my sunny yellow study, only to start nodding off. My body felt like a vow that had been irrevocably broken. I wondered whether my symptoms were just the result of too much aimless internet surfing-dog videos, flash sales-and a general lack of willpower. I wondered whether I was depressed; I had experienced a mild bout of depression in college, but this was nothing like that. Open as I was to the idea, I didn't believe that I was suffering from any kind of mental illness, nor did my symptoms or recent life events seem suggestive of one. My life had come together after the challenging few years following my mother's death. I had just published a memoir about her, a book I was proud of, because I felt it might help others who had suffered with feeling (as I had) that their grief was too large, too unseemly. I had been accepted into a writing residency for that summer and was excited to embark on my next book project. During my mother's illness, Jim and I had gotten divorced, our relationship strained by the devastation I felt. But now we had gotten back together and were trying to have a child. I felt lucky. I wanted to work; the future beckoned. And yet I was so tired I could barely focus on my computer screen. I called my doctor, a new internist. (My insurance had changed.) He did some blood work and phoned a few days later. "You're fine, just a little anemic," he said. Of course he did-for years, doctors had been telling me I was a little anemic, or a bit vitamin D deficient. He suggested that my fatigue was probably due to menstruation. Having menstruated since the age of thirteen without feeling on the verge of death, I found this explanation implausible and said as much. I could almost hear him shrug. "Try some iron supplements." It's probably mono, a friend said. Maybe you're allergic to gluten, another suggested. That weekend, on a crisp winter evening, I went to see a movie in the West Village with a group of friends. Afterward, as we headed for a drink, I began to feel shivery and shaky. I begged off. "Are you all right?" my friend Katie emailed the next day. "You seem run-down." I was sitting at my desk, looking at a photograph of myself as a teenager on a tall beachside dune playing with the family dog, a handsome black husky mix. A strong wind had turned my hair into streamers. I couldn't remember when I had last felt that alive. I went to an integrative doctor a friend recommended. She found that I had active infections of Epstein-Barr virus, cytomegalovirus (CMV), and parvovirus. She suggested some supplements and rest and sent me home. But I didn't feel better, even after the viruses appeared to resolve a month later. At the suggestion of a colleague, I called a doctor who specialized in women's health and made an appointment. In her office, as I described my symptoms and answered her unusually extensive questions about my family history-which included cancer, but also rheumatoid arthritis, ulcerative colitis, and thyroid conditions-the doctor (I'll call her Dr. E) said, "I can tell you now, before I even see your labs, I highly suspect that you have some kind of autoimmune disease." The relief I experienced at hearing her say this was tremendous. Something was wrong: something, then, could be made right. A few days later, she called to say that I had antibodies to my thyroid, a butterfly-shaped gland in the neck that regulates metabolism and energy. This meant my own immune system was attacking my thyroid, a disease known as "autoimmune thyroiditis," though people refer to this form of it as "Hashimoto's." Thyroiditis often results in abnormally low amounts of thyroid hormone, which leaves people sluggish and foggy. I didn't worry about what the diagnosis meant; I was just happy to have one. Thyroid disease, I had read, is common and treatable. I knew people with it, and they were fine. The doctor told me to take a replacement thyroid hormone and check back in six weeks. By then, I would be feeling better. I sighed with relief. This was the way medicine worked in the modern world: tests told you what was wrong, and doctors told you how to fix it. But six weeks later, I didn't feel better. I felt worse. My blood pressure was alarmingly low. I got headaches whenever I ate, and one day when I got out of bed I fainted. On another day, a burning pain shot up my neck; it felt as if someone were holding a candle to my skin. My friend Gina and I went to get a juice one afternoon-like me, she worked largely from home-and I got so dizzy that she had to steady me until I could sit. She looked at me as if I were really sick and said, "You need to try to get better, whatever that takes." When I saw Dr. E again in late May, she didn't have much to say about my headaches and other symptoms, but she suggested raising my dosage of the hormone. I began to suspect that whatever was wrong with me wasn't going to be as clear-cut as a simple cold or a malfunctioning organ. Excerpted from The Invisible Kingdom: Reimagining Chronic Illness by Meghan O'Rourke All rights reserved by the original copyright owners. Excerpts are provided for display purposes only and may not be reproduced, reprinted or distributed without the written permission of the publisher.