Review by Kirkus Book Review
Oral history of a unique indie-rock collective. One of the pillars of the Elephant 6 collective was Neutral Milk Hotel, whose album In the Aeroplane Over the Sea (1998) is a rarity in the modern age of cult classics, one that remains (mostly) shrouded in mystery and allows new fans to discover it on their own terms. This loving, in-depth book won't change that much, but longtime fans should find enough to satisfy. Journalist Clair worked on this book for more than 13 years, interviewing many of those responsible for that album as well as dozens more who were part of the Elephant 6. He did not, however, interview Neutral Milk Hotel's frontman, Jeff Mangum, whose distinctive vocals drove the project and whose memorable performances have achieved mythical status in certain circles. Mangum's hiatus from performing--as well as interviews--just as his band was building a following confused some at first. Now, more than two decades later, it's a part of the band and album's legend. "There's no answer key in the pages that follow, no glossary to explain what Jeff or anybody else meant by this or that lyric or setlist or recording decision," Clair explains in his introduction. Instead, he offers a "mixtape of the story of the Elephant 6," letting various players speak for themselves in their own styles at their own pace. The result is uneven. The author offers intense, remarkably precise explanations of other bands' album creations and lengthy descriptions of the food at the famous Elephant 6 potluck dinners. However, there are few new revelations from Mangum about the masterwork at the center of all this attention. Though Clair generally uses the oral history format of lengthy quotes from numerous people, when he synthesizes material and explains things in his own voice, he is more effective and entertaining. A fascinating yet flawed look at an enduring indie rock mystery that shines a light on the power of community and creativity. Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
