Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
It's the first night of Hanukkah in this rhythmic fable by Kimmel, and three anthropomorphic latkes--one red with a trucker cap; one yellow with a fedora, bow tie, and walking stick; and one gold with a sweatband and first place medal--are arguing over which of them tastes best. Each claims that it is the most delicious based upon the type of potato it's made of (which gives the latkes their respective colors) and what it's fried in: "I am fried in schmaltz--chicken fat. That's why I taste so good," says Yellow Latke. An impartial judge is needed, and the latkes choose "the clever cat," who pairs each potato pancake with its suggested topping--applesauce, sour cream, and strawberry jam, respectively--and then resolves the argument by eating all three, leaving the question unanswered. Straightforward visual framings by Parker-Thomas, which feature crayon and pencil textures, keep the mood light even with the peremptory ending. Back matter features a recipe for the "Very Best Latkes." Ages 4--8. (Oct.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Horn Book Review
Optimal latke preparation and dipping sauce are often the subject of friendly debate. Here, the debaters are the latkes themselves, shown in the cheerful colored-pencil illustrations with simple faces, limbs, and even accessories. Are red, yellow, or gold potatoes best? What's the superior frying substance? (Yellow Potato's answer, chicken schmaltz, combined with its dunk into the sour cream might raise questions for kosher-keeping readers about mixing meat and dairy.) The cat is a qualified judge, and luckily (for the feline!) the latkes seem unbothered by being test subjects. An appealingly silly holiday side dish -- just don't get too attached to the potato-based protagonists. A latke recipe with lots of options is appended, but it doesn't settle the debate, either. Shoshana Flax November/December 2021 p.23(c) Copyright 2021. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Three potato pancakes each boast that he is the tastiest--to a hungry cat. The table is set for the first night of Hanukkah as three stylish latkes engage in a bragfest. Made in turn from red potato, yellow potato, and gold potato, each claims first place in deliciousness. Red Latke states that vegetable oil gives him a "beautiful color." Yellow Latke proclaims that frying in schmaltz gives the best taste. Gold Latke smugly asserts that "peanut oil is the healthiest." Who will settle this dispute? A very observant cat will, and she is no fickle culinary feline. Adding applesauce to Red Latke, she gobbles him up. Dipping Yellow Latke in sour cream makes him a tasty treat. A "smear" of strawberry jam helps the cat devour Gold Latke. And her verdict? Readers will have to follow the appended recipe and come to their own tasty conclusions. With the concatenation of threes, Kimmel follows a traditional European storytelling pattern in this entertaining holiday tale for young readers. Parker-Thomas gives each latke his own unique identity in addition to the type of potato and frying medium. Red Latke sports a baseball cap, Yellow Latke a fedora and bow tie, and the healthy Gold Latke a sweatband and gold medal. Shredded and fried, they look a lot like fuzzballs with eyes, mouths, and pipestem limbs. The cat is suitably expressive. Fry up a batch and relish every morsel. (Picture book. 3-6) Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
