Review by Booklist Review
Seventeen-year-old Alter Rosen (a Jewish immigrant from Romania), moved to Chicago two years prior to the 1893 World's Columbian Exposition. He is saving up to move his mother and sisters to the U.S., but now that the fair is in town, Alter has noticed a pattern of young men disappearing from the tenements of Maxwell Street where he rents a room. When one of his roommates--his secret crush, Yakov--ends up dead, Alter is possessed by Yakov's dybbuk and tries to find the killer with the help of his friend Raizel (a Jewish girl who lives in his building) and Frankie, a Jewish immigrant from Russia who helped Alter survive Chicago when he first arrived. The world building is wonderfully thorough, incorporating Jewish folklore, antisemitism, and an overall immersive atmosphere that creates an unforgettable literary experience, complete with a well-paced plot and an adventurous and inquisitive cast of characters. Polydoros includes a glossary of Yiddish terminology and an author's note, ensuring readers are aware of the complexities of the narrative. The City Beautiful is a triumph, showcasing queer love, illuminating historical events, and guiding readers to an enthralling ending that will leave them satiated yet desirous to return to the world in which they have become immersed.
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Polydoros (the Assassin Fall series) seamlessly blends a murder mystery with Jewish folklore in this haunting historical fantasy. Alter Rosen, a 17-year-old Jewish immigrant to America, works as an apprentice typesetter, trying to scrape together enough money to bring his mother and sisters over from Romania. But Jewish teenage boys keep turning up dead while Chicago enjoys its grand World's Fair, and when Yakov, Alter's roommate and secret crush, becomes one of the victims, usually unassuming Alter must find a way to bring Yakov's spirit peace--or risk his dybbuk taking over. Alter's search for the killer reunites him with bold and charming Frankie, a fellow Jewish immigrant who's willing to steal and gamble for success and stability. Polydoros offers an unflinching depiction of anti-Semitism abroad and in Chicago while capturing Jewish intra-communal tensions with nuance. Readers looking for finely wrought historical fiction with fully realized characters and a thrilling pursuit of justice are sure to be satisfied by Alter's story. Ages 13--up. Agent: Thao Le, Sandra Dijkstra Literary. (Sept.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review
Gr 9 Up--It's 1893 in Chicago during the World's Fair and Jewish Romanian immigrant Alter Rosen, born sick and named to confuse the Angel of Death, finds himself in the middle of a murder mystery. Jewish boys all around the city have gone missing and been found murdered. Yakov, his close friend and roommate, is the most recent to be found dead. Strange things begin happening to Alter and he discovers that he's possessed by Yakov's dybbuk--a spirit that occupies a person's soul until they accomplish a goal. In this case, the goal is tracking down Yakov's killer, and Alter must do so before the dybbuk takes over entirely. Frankie, an alluring and dangerous boy from Alter's first arrival in Chicago reappears in his life. The two begin to hunt for the killer before they're targeted next and the dybbuk fully takes over. Polydoros doesn't hold back with this heavy, dark, and gritty story that explores the immigrant experience in a unique way. While firmly a historical fiction title, this genre-bending novel is also equal parts thriller and fantasy. Featuring a queer protagonist, it is deeply layered with Jewish myth, immigration, racism, and anti-Semitism. While scenes of violence, drowning, and slaughterhouses are incredibly vivid, some readers may find the descriptions too intense. Yiddish is woven throughout the dialogue and while context helps, a glossary would be beneficial. VERDICT A wild ride of a queer gothic fantasy that's a must-have for YA fantasy collections.--Alicia Kalan, The Northwest Sch., Seattle
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Young immigrant Alter Rosen lives in Chicago; it's 1893, and the World's Fair is in town. Seventeen-year-old Alter longs to enjoy everything the White City has to offer him, but as a Romanian refugee in the United States, he feels it is his responsibility to earn enough money to bring his mother and his sisters over from Europe. Jewish people in the Russian empire have long been the targets and victims of government-sanctioned violence, and while life in the U.S. is still not ideal for Jews, it's much safer. So, Alter tries his best to make an honest living and save his money. But when several Jewish boys from the tenements on Maxwell Street, where he has rented a room, end up missing or dead--including Alter's own roommate and secret crush, Yakov--Alter knows he has to find out the truth about their fates. A highly detailed historical landscape paired with the fantastical element of the dybbuk from ancient Jewish folklore, one of whom possesses Alter, provide a solid base for the book's leisurely paced and original narrative. Readers will become immersed in Alter's world, rooting for his survival, hoping for his reunion with his family, and wishing for him to find the love that he deserves. An author's note and glossary add valuable context. Main characters are White and Jewish. A slow-moving but compelling tale of a queer Jewish boy battling antisemitism and the supernatural. (Historical thriller. 13-18) Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.