The renegade reporters

Elissa Brent Weissman

Book - 2021

Sixth-graders Ashley and her best friend Maya were banished from the live "News at Nine" broadcast at John Dos Passos Elementary in Baltimore after an embarrassing incident in the previous year; at loose ends the pair, together with their classmate Brielle, decide to become investigative reporters with their own online broadcast: "The Underground News"--and soon they stumble upon a major story about an educational software company that is illegally tracking and selling student data.

Saved in:

Children's Room Show me where

jFICTION/Weissman Elissa
1 / 1 copies available
Location Call Number   Status
Children's Room jFICTION/Weissman Elissa Checked In
Contents unavailable.
Review by Booklist Review

After an embarrassing video of a teacher goes viral, aspiring news reporter Ash and her best friend and camerawomany, Maya, are kicked off the school news team. The girls, along with their friend and film editor Brielle, decide to start their own online news show reporting on neighborhood stories. What starts as a fun after-school project turns into something more when the girls uncover that the media company that sponsors the school news and other educational media products has been collecting and selling students' information. Weissman uses a diverse cast to tackle the issue of data privacy in a way that will be accessible and understandable for a tween audience. Although some of the plot turns out to be a bit too coincidental, middle-grade readers may feel empowered to become activists themselves. The timely topic and author's note on privacy offer opportunities for further discussion, making this a solid choice for libraries and social-justice book clubs.

From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review

Alternately comedic and dense, this story of sixth-grade muckrakers serves up lessons on internet privacy that are both practical and heavy-handed. Before the book begins, Baltimore City best friends Ashley Simon-Hockheimer, who is Jewish, and Maya Joshi-Zachariah, who has implied South Asian heritage, lose their prized positions as school news lead anchor and videographer, respectively, after they film a gym teacher without her consent and the clip goes viral. The advisor replaces them with inexperienced students--including Harry E. Levin, who is half-Chinese and "the only other Jewish sixth grader at John Dos Passos Elementary." Calling themselves "underground" reporters due to their home basement studio, Ash and Maya compete with Harry for scoops, reporting on a stolen bike and doggie-doo malfeasance. Things turn serious, however, when the girls suspect that their school's educational software provider is selling student data, and their investigation serves as pretext for weighty lessons on personal security. Weissman develops the rivalry and lunchroom shenanigans well against a Baltimore backdrop with recognizable local details. If a few sensational plot twists require some suspension of disbelief, the triumphant conclusion makes a solid case for kids' digital literacy. Back matter features an author's note. Ages 8--12. (Aug.)

(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review

Gr 4--6--Ashley (Ash), Maya, and Brielle consider themselves the school news channel dream team. They have been working with the school station since second grade, and sixth grade should be their time to shine as lead anchor, camera person, and editor. That was before Ash and Maya created a viral video of the gym teacher lip-synching in just her sports bra and shorts when she didn't know she was being recorded. Now they have to spend their final year of elementary school as support crew with little to no responsibility and watch Ash's rival, Harry, and his friends fumble through the productions. Not happy with their punishment, the girls enlist the help of Brielle to start their own YouTube news channel, The Underground News, and dub themselves the Renegade Reporters. Soon they find themselves investigating not only dog poo and stolen bicycles, but also whether the number one ad-free educational software platform, Van Ness Media, is tracking and selling student data without their knowledge. Can the Renegade Reporters get the real scoop before their show gets shut down for good? Weissman takes on a lot in this novel, and unfortunately, is only partially successful. We live in a digital world and it's important that kids are aware of privacy, permission, citing sources, cybersecurity, digital footprints, and marketing tactics; but by taking on so much, readers barely scratch the surface of these issues. The cover shows three girls of various ethnicities, but there are no physical descriptions in the text. Ash has two dads and her family is Jewish, but those are the only details that set her character apart from Maya and Brielle. This could be used in a school setting to discuss digital footprints and information freedom/literacy. VERDICT Additional purchase if a teacher or librarian will use it in a discussion of relevant topics.--Heather Webb, Worthington Libs., OH

(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review

After Ashley filmed Coach Kelly dancing in her sports bra and it went viral, she was relieved of her role as reporter for the school news program. Together with her best friend, cameraperson Maya, and their video editor friend, Brielle, she forms the Renegade Reporters. The sixth graders decide to start a YouTube show about news events in Baltimore. Ashley discovers that Van Ness, the media company sponsoring the school news and creator of the software students use, has selected her classmate Harry, the lead anchor, as a young creative to feature on their website. Ash wants to interview company founder Maria Van Ness because she feels it's unethical for them to promote Harry without disclosing their sponsorship. When she and Maya show up at the company headquarters, they accidentally discover that Van Ness is collecting personal data from their young users. The novel then becomes a lesson on journalistic investigation and cybersecurity, with the team researching, interviewing experts, and zeroing in on their target. Whether middle-grade readers will be concerned about this important issue is questionable, but the unfolding of the investigation is skillfully handled, and kids will cheer for the perspicacious young reporters. Jewish Ash has two dads; Maya is cued as South Asian Indian, and the cover shows Brielle as Black but nothing in the text corroborates this. A solid mystery that discusses data privacy and journalistic integrity. (author's note) (Fiction. 9-12) Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.

Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.

Chapter 1 This Just In: More Fallout from Dancing Gym Teacher Incident For Ash, watching The News at Nine from inside the control booth was like watching her little sister try to tie her shoes; Ash could do it so much better if she were only allowed to help. Once the broadcast went live, she wanted so desperately to jump in and take over that she had to press her feet together to keep them from carrying her into the studio. "Good morning, John Dos Passos Elementary," said the lead anchor, Harry. He was staring straight into the camera with a smile so tight, he had to speak through stretched lips, like an amateur ventriloquist. "Today is Tuesday, September tenth. The cold lunch is turkey sandwich. The hot lunch is spiral rotini with tomato and sauce broccoli." Ash raised her eyebrows. Harry's co--anchor, Damion, nudged Harry with his elbow and whispered something. Harry squinted at the cue cards, his forced smile still set. "Today's hot lunch is spiral rotini with tomato and broccoli sauce." Damion looked at Harry and shook his head. The cue card holder took a step closer, which meant her back now blocked the camera. "Tomato sauce and broccoli!" Harry said triumphantly, though viewers could see nothing but the cue card holder's hair. "Camera one, you're blocked," Brielle, the director, said into her headset. If Ash's best friend, Maya, had been operating camera one, she'd have known just what to do. "Pan right slowly," Maya whispered, as if to prove the point. But no one could hear her, because she was in the control booth with Ash. Khalil was lead cameraman now, and he didn't pan right slowly. Instead, he said "Yo," and pulled on one of the cue card holder's braids. She whipped her head around and glared at him---and at the whole school, since the camera was now capturing a close--up of her face. Maya covered her eyes. Ash closed hers. She could hear laughs from classrooms down the hall. The News at Nine was broadcast live, which meant the whole school was witnessing this disaster. "Ready camera two," said Brielle, cool as always. "Birthdays in three . . . two . . . one . . ." The second camera operator was ready, but the birthday reporter wasn't. Now the broadcast showed him pulling at a thread on the bottom of his uniform shirt. It was one of those threads that just kept going and going, which meant he could have pulled it all morning if Damion hadn't shouted "Over to birthdays!" The birthday reporter looked up, startled. "Birthdays," he said. "That's me." He dropped the thread and blinked at the camera. "Wait. Did you already do the Pledge of Allegiance?" Ash shook her head. They'd skipped the Pledge of Allegiance. Sure, this was the first episode of the new school year, but this was basic stuff. Director Brielle said, "Pledge of Allegiance in three . . . two . . ." Right on cue, the editor in the booth cut to the video of a waving flag. But the birthday reporter, unaware, had decided he was finally ready to report the birthdays. "Happy birthday to kindergartener Curtis Thompson and third grader Madison---oh? We're doing the Pledge of Allegiance? Okay." Damion said, "Please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance," but the editor in the booth now swapped the pledge screen for camera two, where the birthday reporter had resumed pulling the thread on his shirt. The laughter from down the hall got louder, and Ash pressed her palms into her face. This broadcast was going off the rails. She was glad that she and Maya weren't part of it. Then again, if they could be part of it---more than having written the environmental report that Harry was surely going to butcher---Ash never would have messed up the lunch menu, and Maya never would have screwed up the camerawork, which meant The News at Nine never would have gotten off track in the first place. Ms. Sullivan was probably rethinking Ash and Maya's punishment this very moment, for the good of the show and the school's reputation. Ash glanced over, and sure enough, Ms. Sullivan was biting her fingernails so intensely she could draw blood. It made Ash think of a word her babysitter had taught her: Schadenfreude. It was German, and it meant "taking pleasure in someone else's pain." Ash knew it wasn't nice to want the show to fail, but it was still sort of gratifying to see just how badly it was going without her and Maya. "Brielle," Ms. Sullivan said. "Let's end the show early today. Cut to the closing credits." "Ending the show early," Brielle said into her headset. "Closing credits in three . . . two . . ." "I'm Damion Skinner," Damion said. "And I'm Harry E. Levin," said Harry. "This has been The News at Nine , sponsored by Baltimore--based Van Ness Media." The editor cut to the show's logo, a blocky number 9 with the words The News at Nine inside. "Well," Ms. Sullivan said as the crew gathered in the newsroom. "New year, new crew, lots to learn. But we'll get there." Ash raised her hand. "Maybe we'd get there quicker if some of the old crew---I mean, some of the people with more experience---had bigger roles." " I'm lead anchor, Ash," said Harry E. Levin. "Get over it." "I was just speaking generally," Ash said. "Yeah, right," said Damion with a snort. Ms. Sullivan put out her hands like a referee. Then she took a long sip of her coffee, like she was going to need it if she was going to get through this day. If Ash drank coffee, she'd have done the same thing. "Go ahead and get to class, everyone," Ms. Sullivan said. "Ashley, please stay and speak with me." Maya shot her a worried look, but Ash shrugged. She was hopeful. Ms. Sullivan had seen how terrible the show was today without Ash in front of the camera or Maya behind it. She probably wanted to figure out a way to revoke their punishment and make Ash lead anchor without upsetting Harry. Ash planned to be very mature about it. Maybe she'd offer to share the role with Harry, alternating days or weeks. That would make Ms. Sullivan respect her even more, which might make her insist that Ash take over the role full--time. Sure enough, once everyone had cleared out and Ms. Sullivan had gotten rid of Harry, who was zipping his backpack very slowly in an obvious attempt to eavesdrop, Ms. Sullivan leaned against a desk and smiled. "I know it's hard for you to watch The News at Nine from the booth, Ashley," she said. "You've been a dedicated member of the crew since--" "Second grade," Ash finished for her. Ms. Sullivan smiled again. "It must be difficult for you to watch Harry sit at the anchor desk instead of you." Ash nodded. Here comes the offer, she thought. "However," Ms. Sullivan said, "I'm not going to change my mind about your punishment." Ash felt her face morph from hopeful anticipation to genuine shock. What? "No matter how the show runs without you, we cannot have you back on--screen after what happened last year. And we can't have Maya operating a camera." "I'm really sorry," Ash said for what must have been the five millionth time. Besides, it wasn't even their fault. Well, not entirely. She and Maya had been roving reporters, walking to the gym to give a live status update on the new basketball hoop being installed. They'd heard a noise coming from the gym teacher's office and decided to investigate. Wasn't that what a good news reporter was supposed to do? How were they supposed to know that Coach Kelly would be in there wearing nothing but shorts and a sports bra? How were they supposed to know that she wouldn't hear them coming because she'd also be wearing headphones, dancing and lip--synching in the mirror while applying her makeup? Okay, so Ash shouldn't have looked into the camera and said, "Breaking news: Coach Kelly's got moves!" She regretted that part of it (even though it was a compliment), and her first thousand or so apologies had been sincere. And maybe Maya could have shut off the camera quicker, but she had stopped recording the moment Coach Kelly turned around and screamed. That meant the 300 students and staff at John Dos Passos Elementary only saw about 5.4 seconds of the dancing gym teacher before The News at Nine cut to the sixth--grade anchors in the main studio. It definitely wasn't Ash's fault that the lead anchor was staring at the camera like a stunned raccoon, or that the co--anchor was laughing so hard, a rubber band on his braces snapped. It wasn't Maya's fault that this made the lead videographer crack up and let his camera slip, which made it capture, sideways, the shock and hilarity that had engulfed the newsroom while a red--faced Ms. Sullivan frantically searched for the camera's off--button before the screen cut to black. It wasn't Ash's or Maya's fault that The News at Nine was available to anyone with the password to the school's online portal. So, it also wasn't their fault that a former News at Nine reporter, now in high school, happened to watch this episode later that day, or that he'd decided to post the clip online for a wider audience. And it certainly wasn't Ash's or Maya's fault that the video racked up over two million views in just under five days. Besides, Ash thought now as she pleaded silently with Ms. Sullivan here in the studio, all of this had happened in May--- last year, before summer break---and Ms. Sullivan had taken them off the news crew for the rest of fifth grade. Surely that had been punishment enough. This was a new year, a fresh start. More importantly, this was sixth grade , Ash's last year at John Dos Passos Elementary and her only chance to be lead anchor for the morning news show. She'd been training for this opportunity since she was her little sister's age. Back then, her brown hair was still in long pigtails and her fingernails were unpainted and her top front teeth were just jagged lines poking unevenly through her gums. Now her hair was short and choppy, and her fingernails were purple and orange, and not only were her adult teeth fully in, but her face had finally grown enough to make them look the right size. In other words, Ashley Simon--Hockheimer had come a long way since she'd first joined the school news crew and had only been allowed to occasionally say "Who's there?" for the knock--knock joke of the week. She was a young woman now, an experienced journalist, and the most qualified person to be lead anchor, with her best friend, Maya Joshi--Zachariah, the undisputed choice for lead videographer. Together, they were an unstoppable team. An unstoppable team that was unfairly, devastatingly, permanently benched. Ms. Sullivan took another long sip of her coffee. "We've been through this before, Ashley. You violated Coach Kelly's privacy. She was so uncomfortable, she moved to a different school. There need to be consequences." Privacy, Ash thought, resisting the urge to roll her eyes, because what sort of privacy could you expect in a school full of kids? If Coach Kelly really cared about privacy, she shouldn't have been dancing around her office in a sports bra. "It won't happen again," Ash promised. "Trust me." But Ms. Sullivan shook her head. "It's not just me who has to trust you. It's the principal, and the teachers, and the people at Van Ness Media who pay for all our equipment and sponsor the show." "But won't the people at Van Ness Media be more embarrassed if the show is really bad?" Ash asked. "Just because you're not lead anchor, it doesn't mean the show is bad." "Today's show was really bad." "Excuse me?" Ms. Sullivan said sharply. "Nothing," Ash muttered. Ms. Sullivan gave Ash a hard stare for a full five seconds. Then she said, "You're a strong reporter with a lot of experience. I know you care about broadcast journalism. If you want to continue to write stories for the anchors to read, I'd love to have you be part of the crew. But you'll need to be a team player, which means you support the other members of the team no matter what. If you can't do that"---she crossed her arms---"I'm going to have to cut you from the crew entirely." She said it gently but firmly, in that way teachers do, and Ash felt a sharp pang of betrayal. It was Ms. Sullivan who'd gotten Ash into reporting to begin with. Five years ago, she had substituted for Ash's first--grade teacher and asked for a volunteer to tell her what they were working on. Ash had stood up and given a complete rundown on what they were learning in every subject. Ms. Sullivan had been impressed. "You should consider joining The News at Nine crew next year," she'd said. "We could use a clear and confident reporter like you." Ash still remembered how her six--year--old body had swelled with pride and possibility. She'd started watching The News at Nine closely every morning and dreaming about the day she'd be on the screen instead of watching it from her classroom. She'd signed up as soon as she was old enough, and she never looked back. It was Ms. Sullivan who taught Ash about the importance of a free press and the responsibilities that came along with reporting the news. It was The News at Nine that taught Ash to investigate stories thoroughly and fairly, and to be confident and capable on camera and off. It was Ms. Sullivan and The News at Nine that had brought Ash together with Maya, who was too shy to speak around adults but silently noticed the things Ash didn't because Ash was too busy talking. Ash and Maya had been dedicated to The News at Nine for four years. How could Ms. Sullivan, of all people, do this to them, after just one little mistake? Ash gulped, not wanting Ms. Sullivan to see her cry. It'd be hard to watch the show from her classroom, but as she knew from this first episode today, it'd be even harder to watch it from the control booth. She didn't think she could handle seeing Harry E. Levin read the things she'd researched and written, even if he did learn to do it without sounding like a robot. In fact, the better Harry delivered Ash's reports, the harder it'd be to watch. Ms. Sullivan was right. There was no way Ash could be a supportive team player when she was aching to be captain. It'd be torture. Ash swallowed, then squared her shoulders. "All right," she told Ms. Sullivan. "I quit." Excerpted from The Renegade Reporters by Elissa Brent Weissman All rights reserved by the original copyright owners. Excerpts are provided for display purposes only and may not be reproduced, reprinted or distributed without the written permission of the publisher.