Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
In this picture book debut by Knight--part of the Storytelling Math series--Usha, a brown-skinned girl who is obsessed with trucks, yearns to learn how to turn a cartwheel. When her attempts land her outside, supine next to her older sister Aarti, Aarti shows Usha the asterism known in the U.S. as the Big Dipper. But Usha, laying in a different orientation from Aarti, sees the Big Digger instead. And when cousin Gloria comes over the next night and the trio lies in a circle, Gloria sees the Big Kite, continuing a gently imparted lesson on geometric and spatial concepts, including orientation, perspective, and rotation. Knight maintains playful energy through an onomatopoeic refrain describing Usha's failed cartwheels: "Flippety thump. Flippety thump--SPLAT!" Dynamic digital art by Prabhat, rendered in vibrant jewel tones, emphasizes Usha's determination in mastering cartwheels, as well as relatable family dynamics in this endearing portrait of one Indian American family learning to embrace differing perspectives. Back matter includes an author's note and an exploration of the math involved, with recommended activities. Ages 3--6. (Aug.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Usha loves two things: trucks and cartwheels (although she's still not quite sure how to do a cartwheel). When her big sister, Aarti, points out the Big Dipper while stargazing, Usha doesn't see a scoop at all; instead, she sees a truck. Usha confidently tells her sister that the constellation (or, more accurately, as Knight notes in the backmatter, the asterism) she's seeing isn't a big dipper--it's a big digger. Things get even more complicated when the girls' cousin Gloria comes over the next night. Gloria doesn't see the constellation as a scoop or a truck; she sees it as a kite! Through all of this, Usha practices her cartwheels. Each of the girls is convinced that the others are seeing the stars in the wrong way, until Usha flops on the ground after a failed cartwheel and realizes that the constellation is, in fact, a scoop, a truck, and a kite, depending on its orientation. This latest edition to the Storytelling Math series features stunning illustrations of dark-skinned South Asian protagonists, with Gloria apparently biracial (Black/South Asian). The book bursts with charming images of endearing kids, and the story's presentation of the girls' varying, equally valid perspectives is a valuable tool for promoting empathy. However, its success at demonstrating the principle of orientation via a constellation is imperfect; any of the concrete examples in the backmatter would have worked better. Read for the illustrations and the characters (but not the math). (Picture book. 3-6) Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.