Review by Booklist Review
Areli loves the mountains and sun of her Mexico home, her abuela and her cousins, and school friends. The only part of her life that is missing is her parents, who are in New York and will soon send for her and her brother. When Areli's turn arrives to make the journey to America, she is forced to leave all that she loves behind to travel to a new, faraway home, where she faces a difficult language barrier and the uncertainty of not being here legally. This beautifully illustrated picture book presents hardships that many undocumented children face when making the journey to America, in a way that will allow children to understand what others are going through or to find solace in the fact that they are not alone. Young readers will witness the complex and difficult emotions kids have to deal with when faced with such circumstances--including separation from their family--at such a young age, but they will also find comfort in a future bright with possibility. Uribe's warm artwork conveys the many important aspects of Areli's life, providing readers with an illuminating look into the life of a child making such an important life journey. Highly recommended for all collections.
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by School Library Journal Review
Gr 1--3--DACA (Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals) recipient Morales's book is based on her journey from Pueblo, Mexico, to New York as an undocumented immigrant at the age of six. The story starts with Areli at her grandmother's house in Mexico, where she enjoys the company of her cousins and the delicious food. Every Sunday, she and her brother, Alex, expect a call from their parents who are already in the United States. Alex, who was born in the United States, will be joining his parents soon. Areli, however, will rely on a family friend she does not know to take her into the country. In New York, everything is bigger and faster and unfortunately, things are not better at school, where she does not know English and is humiliated by boys calling her "illegal" and "backward." The first-person primary-grade-friendly narrative style moves effortlessly including Spanish language terms interspersed with English, the main language of the book. The one-to-five line paragraphs are set in small black font accompanying the pastel illustrations. This book could be used in a social science class highlighting Areli's capacity to adapt and thrive as she navigates her new environment. It contains an author's note addressing the fragility of the DACA program and back matter with a glossary defining the Spanish language terms in the story. VERDICT A moving biographical picture book that would be a sensitive addition to the shelves of libraries, accompanying A Journey Toward Hope by Victor Hinojosa and Coert Voorhees.--Kathia Ibacache, Univ. of Colorado Boulder
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Horn Book Review
After an introductory author's note, Morales, a DACA recipient, tells her story in this third-person narrative that begins in Mexico where Areli lives with her older brother and their abuela. They miss their parents, who live in New York and who promise that they'll all be together some day. Uribe's warm illustrations convey a strong sense of place and clearly communicate six-year-old Areli's state of mind: carefree in Mexico, grieving as she leaves home, and struggling in a new country. Time, hard work, and a school field trip to Ellis Island help Areli feel that she belongs. A glossary translates the Spanish words and phrases incorporated in the text. Concurrently published in Spanish. (c) Copyright 2023. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
In her debut children's book, a Dreamer recalls her journey from Mexico to New York and the subsequent reality of living as an undocumented immigrant. Areli's tale begins at Abuela's house, where days brim "with family and sunshine," delicious "mounds of tortillas and pollo con frijoles for supper," and calls from Mamá and Papá from America. It's an idyllic life, but it's undercut when Areli's big brother, Alex, born in America, returns to Nueva York, leaving Areli behind. Though Mamá and Papá work hard for "a better life," the days pass--Areli's birthday, Día de los Muertos, Navidad--with Areli separated from her family. Then one day Areli must leave Mexico and head to New York with a family friend. It's a time of difficult goodbyes for Areli, and in the span of a few wordless pages, Areli's in the midst of the "bigger and faster and noisier" bustle of New York, reunited with her family. In scene after scene of Areli's life, Uribe's colorful yet muted artwork depicts the young Dreamer's voyage from Abuela's house to America with a lovely sense of restrained appreciation. Morales, a DACA recipient, spins an admirable third-person memoir that deeply resonates thanks to keen details that conjure moods with a few choice words. Although Areli's tale packs years of experiences in a tight 40-page picture book, the author maintains command of her readers' attention by translating a life-disrupting migration into a confident, heartfelt story. Key highlights include Areli's adjustment to life in America and an eye-opening trip to Ellis Island in the latter half of the book. Powerful in its cleareyed optimism. (author's note, glossary) (Picture book/memoir. 4-8) Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.