Review by Kirkus Book Review
In a story inspired by events from the author's life, a young Vietnamese refugee is welcomed to a new country with the unexpected gift of a doll. This sweet gesture becomes a formative experience that symbolizes the acceptance of her family in their new home. When she grows up, becoming a doctor, the young woman reflects upon the compassion she received and becomes inspired to help other refugees. Taking action, she greets a new refugee family in an airport and gives a young girl the same doll that welcomed her many years ago. While the story highlights the act of paying it forward, the text betrays the main character by seemingly attributing her success in life to the singular moment of receiving the doll: "All that you have, and all that you have become are because of an act of kindness." This troubling statement oversimplifies the refugee experience and robs the woman of resilience and agency. However, the overall message of the positive, rippling effect of generosity is not lost. Stamplike shading in dusky reds, browns, and blues evoke warmth and comfort in the illustrations. The refugees, both the original protagonist and those newly arrived, are depicted with dignity and quiet strength. The young woman and her family are Vietnamese, the refugee family she welcomes at the airport is cued as Middle Eastern. A touching, full-circle journey about the lasting impact of kindness. (author's note) (Picture book. 5-9) Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
