Review by Booklist Review
Willig's (The Summer Country, 2019) latest historical yarn opens in 1917 as a group of women who have come together to form the Smith College Relief Unit set sail for France, where they'll offer aid to locals near the front lines of the fighting in World War I. Three women are spotlighted among the large cast of characters: determined Kate Moran, who attended Smith on a scholarship and was befriended by wealthy Emmie Van Alden, the kindhearted daughter of a suffragette. It was Emmie who convinced Kate to join the relief unit. Rounding out the trio is the chilly Dr. Julia Pruyen, Emmie's cousin whom Kate has hated ever since she heard Julia refer to her as Emmie's "charity case." As they get set up in the small village of Grecourt and start to provide assistance to the imperiled citizens, the cracks in Kate and Emmie's friendship widen and Kate is surprised to find herself sympathizing with icy Julia. Willig injects plenty of drama and danger, along with a bit of romance, into this engaging tale of brave WWI women volunteers.
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Willig (The Summer Country) draws on the Smith College Relief Unit's experiences in France during WWI for this immersive novel. In 1917, Smith graduate Kate Moran joins fellow alumnus Emmie Van Alden to travel to France and help villagers whose lives have been upended by an earlier German occupation. The unit, composed of 17 women, resides in army barracks near an abandoned chateau in Grecourt, where they provide locals with food, medical care, and education. The villagers' lack of bare necessities is eye-opening for the Smith women, many of whom have led privileged lives. Kate, meanwhile, remains sensitive about her humble beginnings--she gained admission to Smith through a scholarship--and becomes upset when she discovers that Emmie paid for her trip to France. (Emmie had told her they were funded by donations from Smith alumnae). As the war rages on and the German army once again advances on Grecourt, Kate and Emmie's friendship grows stronger when they reveal their deepest insecurities to one another. Willig expertly uses historical details in her seamless, well-plotted tale. This will entice readers from the very first page. Agent: Alexandra Machinist, ICM Partners. (Mar.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Library Journal Review
While the individual characters in this novel are fictional, the events are based on the actual experiences of Smith College women during World War I. The Smith Unit, as it came to be known, was a group of 18 graduates of the women's college, who signed up to help with relief efforts in France. Their numbers included a director, two doctors, and an agriculturalist, among others. Armed with money, some supplies, and a can-do attitude, the unit arrived in France to learn that everything would be harder than they thought it would be. From trucks they had to assemble themselves, to arguments with officials over delivery of medical supplies, the Smith Unit was thwarted by bureaucratic red tape and overwhelmed by people in desperate need of aid. Many of the unit's members rose to the occasion and were able to provide food, medical care, comfort, and hope. Others returned home because of the dire and dangerous conditions. Readers will root for the women's success, especially for the lead characters, Kate and Emmy, who both find unexpected joys through their work, despite the hardships. Julia Whelan provides distinct voices for each of the members of the unit, which is especially evident in the women's letters home. Willig's note at the end explains how she stumbled upon this story and the way the letters written by the real-life unit members influenced her narrative. VERDICT Listening to the audiobook version and hearing the tension, anguish, and, at times, happiness, provides a deeper connection to the characters in an already outstanding story.--Courtney Pentland, Omaha, NE
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
