Review by Booklist Review
It's bedtime in a cabin in the woods, but young Roger isn't sleepy. As a storm approaches, he's full of bravado, but Rachel reassures him. After the rain stops, they walk to the beach, where he stomps and shouts until Rachel quietly calls him. They turn off their flashlights, close their eyes, and listen to the sea. Opening his eyes, Roger is captivated: the sea is "alive with luminous light." He finds a wet, struggling firefly, which they rescue, carry back to woods, and release. Tucking Roger in bed, Rachel calls him a boy who loves and protects creatures. Miyares' richly atmospheric ink paintings use light and shadow effectively. The gracefully told story was inspired by Rachel Carson's published writings and a personal letter in which she describes discovering a firefly in distress beside an ocean lit by bioluminescent organisms. Roger represents her great-nephew, whom she adopted. By relating one child's encounters with awesome natural wonders, this quiet picture book lets others feel his satisfaction in saving a firefly and becoming a protector of nature.
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Loosely based on two anecdotes from the ecologist and writer Rachel Carson's life (1907--1964), Wiles's fictional tale focuses on the emotional world of Roger, a small child who pivots from fear in a power outage to stomping waves to delicately rescuing a waterlogged firefly "as carefully as the most gentle monster" in the company of his caregiver, Carson. Descriptions of nature are especially poignant: "they released the firefly... watched it flit and circle and wink away." Miyares's dreamlike illustrations complement the lengthy poetic text, using light and dark to evoke Roger's sense of confidence, comfort, fear, and wonder while conjuring the magic of a flashlight-lit walk to a bioluminescent ocean on a thundery night. Some readers may find the title misleading, however, as historical information about Carson's significant life and legacy appear only as back matter. Ages 4--8. (Sept.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Horn Book Review
A boy shouts, stomps, and plays monsters to hide his fear of a storm and the power outage it brings, while his mother offers comfort. After the storm fades the pair walks through the dark woods to the ocean, noticing natural wonders they encounter on their way -- an owl calling, raindrops on ferns, bioluminescence on the waves. A reader who skips the subtitle may not ever notice that the patient mother who encourages her child's imaginative play and curiosity here is scientist and author Rachel Carson (1907-1964). But while readers may not come away with a greater biographical knowledge of Carson per se, Wiles's story itself embodies a Carson quote that opens the back matter: "It is not half so important to know as to feel." Carson in the book shows tender attention and care both to her son's feelings and to the natural world, that care exemplified when together they scoop a sinking firefly up out of the waves. Miyares's illustrations match the gentle tone of the story, with muted ink washes in blues and grays surrounding pops of yellow light from the lanterns and flashlights that illuminate every spread. Back matter describes the two separate incidents from Carson's life that Wiles combined to create this story, as well as a brief description of Carson's importance and the science behind bioluminescence. Laura Koenig September/October 2020 p.121(c) Copyright 2020. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
In a simple tale based on Rachel Carson's writings, the naturalist takes her great-nephew on a walk that reinforces the better parts of his emerging selfhood. The story begins by stating that it is bedtime in Rachel's cabin in the woods and a thunderstorm is brewing. On the next double-page spread, a little boy named Roger, dressed in Godzilla PJs, plays monster with a woman named Rachel whose relationship to him is explained only in the backmatter. Roger is scared when the lights go out--although he will not admit it--and he is rude to Rachel when she tries to comfort him. Throughout the book, Roger's all-too-human, childish behavior swings rapidly through phases of obstreperousness, fright, and tenderness while Rachel's attitude and speech unwaveringly resemble the wise woman of fairy tales. Her didacticism works for any age of reader when she is discussing luminescent ocean life but not so well when she reminds Roger he loves and protects the wilderness. After the storm, Rachel and Roger walk through woods to the sea. Here the text is lovely and lyrical. The climax comes when Roger discovers a struggling firefly in the seafoam and Rachel helps him rescue it. The tale is slightly long for a bedtime read-aloud, making it apt for slightly older preschoolers. When illustrating natural phenomena, the art--like the text--is magical. The human depictions are sometimes awkward. Doesn't quite jell but worthwhile reading nevertheless. (biographical note, science note, further reading) (Picture book. 3-5) Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
