Review by Booklist Review
Based on an old Breton folktale, this graphic adaptation uses rich, warm hues and soft shapes to depict a haggard king; an enchanted, if sinister city; and the titular pair of sisters, who could not be more different. The day Dahut and Rozenn become aware of their father's corruption, they start on different paths, and the passing of time is artfully depicted in a series of extra-wide, wordless panels. As adults, Rozenn prefers dwelling outdoors, far away from the lavish parties in the city, while Dahut is deeply embroiled in the enchantment keeping the sea from swallowing Ys. When an act of betrayal brings the city to account, the true cost of maintaining the enchantment is revealed and devastation rushes in. Anderson adds compelling depth to the story with just a few details beyond the original tale, and Rioux's lush, dense artwork, full of dynamic figures, swirling lines, dramatic angles, and colors that seem to glow, cultivates a fantastic, magical folk-tale atmosphere. Water figures prominently, of course, and her deep teal waves and curly billows of foam roil menacingly across the pages. This is an old story, but Anderson and Rioux give it vivid new life, and fans of fairy tales will be utterly bewitched. Though this is not directly marketed to teens (likely thanks to some largely obscured nudity and sex), they're the ideal audience here.
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Drawing on Celtic folklore, this haunting graphic novel by Anderson (Feed) pays homage to an ancient Breton myth. Rozenn and Dahut, daughters of the fairy Queen Malgven, are left grieving with their father, King Gradlon, after their mother's death. The king falls into a deep depression, while the girls grow up following different paths: Rozenn avoids her responsibilities as heiress to the throne of the land of Ys, in favor of caring for wildlife (and a certain friendly commoner), whereas Dahut is tasked with keeping their kingdom prosperous through harnessing magic and--unbeknownst to others--the souls of royal suitors whom she lures into her bedroom. But when a mysterious merchant arrives and catches Dahut's eye, both she and Rozenn discover that magic always comes at a hefty price. Anderson's lyric version of the original lore marries different interpretations to focus on the complex relationship between the two sisters, and draws the reader into the eerie mystical world of Ys. Rioux's enchanting classical artwork employs rustic pencils in a romantic style that recalls Emily Carroll, and autumnal colors which harken back to Breton culture. Readers keen on Celtic mythology will appreciate this whimsical tale with a dark turn, with crossover for Anderson's teen fans likely. (Aug.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review
Gr 8 Up--Anderson and Rioux team up for this graphic novel retelling of an ancient Breton folktale. Lady Malgven, a sorceress and the wife of the Wizard Duke of Wened, grants Gradlon, the King of Kerne, a powerful kingdom and children if he kills her husband and marries her. He agrees, and years later, they have two daughters, Rozenn and Dahut. Malgven's sudden death leaves the two young girls reeling: How will they carry on her magical legacy and rule the shining seaside city of Ys? When they discover their father in flagrante delicto with two young maidens, the girls are even more wounded and set out on two different paths. Elder sister Rozenn chooses a simple life of caring for animals in the moors, while Dahut embraces her role as a magical princess and flourishes in the royal court. With Dahut's magic, the king has grown more powerful but also more wicked: capturing slaves and looting and destroying rival cities. But when Dahut's magical sacrifices endanger Rozenn's happiness, the girls must face the truth that the city of Ys is fortified by evil. Anderson and Rioux have woven a lush folktale filled with magic, lust, and feminine power. Rioux's pencil illustrations are melancholic, with dramatic shadows, glowing moonlight, and swirling seas. Her depiction of water is particularly dynamic. The cliffside scenes evoke Cézanne's airy landscapes. Some mild nudity and sexual scenarios make this more appropriate for slightly older readers. VERDICT A haunting rendering of an ancient folktale, packed with magic.--Anna Murphy, Berkeley Carroll School, Brooklyn
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Horn Book Review
In graphic novel form, Anderson (Yvain, rev. 3/17; The Assassination of Brangwain Spurge, rev. 9/18) and Rioux (The Golden Twine) tell the traditional Breton story of the enchanted underwater city of Ys. Sisters Rozenn and Dahut mourn their faerie mother, whose magic has fed their father's lust for wealth and created the famous undersea city. Now motherless, Rozenn pursues her love of the natural world and lives in the wild, while Dahut takes up her maternal heritage of magic, sustaining her father and his riches through shipwrecks and murder. When Dahut notices Rozenn's affection for a fisherman, she tests his loyalty and, inadvertently, her own, with disastrous consequences for the city of Ys. Rioux's graphics stress the magical effects and action elements of the folktale, with a shadowy, subdued palette and abundant, inventive sound effects. Both transport us to a world that seems beyond language itself, a dangerous confluence of nature's forces. At the same time, Anderson's dialogue contemporizes events, allowing the tale's psychological underpinnings to show through the weird, otherworldly drama. "What are we going to do without Mom?" mourns Dahut as the story begins. Final panels locate the story near Brittany's perilous shore of Finisterre. Deirdre F. Baker November/December 2020 p.93(c) Copyright 2020. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
An ancient Breton folktale finds new life as a graphic novel. King Gradlon won his wife's hand by murdering her first husband. Upon her mysterious death, their two daughters, Rozenn and Dahut, are sickened by their father's debauchery and consumed by grief. Several pages of wordless panels show the girls growing up and growing apart. Rozenn retreats to the countryside, meets Corentin, a "holy hermit," and falls in love with a fisherman. Dahut commits herself to learning her mother's magic, including seducing, murdering, and sacrificing a string of young men to protect the city. Dahut's ultimate betrayal of her sister brings about the deadly denouement. Anderson drew on multiple sources to retell this story of Ys, a "famed city of pleasures" stolen from the sea and doomed to destruction. Overtones of other tales, from the lost land of Lyonesse to the destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah, echo through the pages of this morality tale. Blood and betrayal permeate the plot while natural sounding dialogue and perfect pacing draw readers along smoothly. Rioux's art adds a suitably Celtic feel, with swirling patterns, medieval costumes, and a red-haired sorceress at its center. While nudity and sexual activity both occur, as do beheadings and drowning, neither the text nor the pictures are particularly explicit. Main characters are white; clothing and textual references indicate contact with Near and Far Eastern nations. Intriguing and accessible, this thought-provoking tale will be new to many. (source note) (Graphic fantasy. 16-adult) Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
