Review by Booklist Review
Though it's been several years since her father went missing while fighting overseas during WWII, fifth-grader Glory Bea still believes he'll come home to Gladiola, Texas, where she lives with her mother and grandparents. Then, Randall Horton, who served with her father, unexpectedly visits, which Glory Bea decides means her father's returning, too. As Gladiola plans for a visit from the "Merci Train"--a French-sponsored thank-you to America for wartime support--Glory Bea tries to deter the developing relationship between her mother and Mr. Horton, while secretly preparing for what she's sure is her father's impending arrival. Eventually, Glory Bea must face and accept difficult truths, bringing sorrow but also understanding about compassion and adapting to change. Glory Bea's first-person narrative, interwoven with historical details, offers an intimate account of grief and longing, tempered somewhat by lighter moments like her attempts to fix up a friend and a neighbor, and by the inclusion of interspersed newspaper gossip columns. Readers will find Glory Bea, and her process of moving forward through loss, sympathetically drawn. An endnote provides background information and a bibliography.
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
More than three years after WWII, fifth grader Glory Bea's father is still MIA. Everyone assumes he's dead except Glory Bea, who refuses to give up hope of a miracle: "he's going to find us." When her father's soldier buddy Randall Horton comes for a visit, she isn't pleased with the attention her mother pays him, especially after Randall becomes a permanent resident of their small Texas town. As the adults' relationship grows romantic, resentful Glory Bea strives to drive Randall away. She eagerly awaits the arrival of the Merci Train, delivering, as thanks for wartime help, boxcars full of gifts from France and, she believes, her father ("Why else would it stop in Gladiola?"). Bustard (Anywhere but Paradise) captures a patriotic spirit in post-WWII America in this novel inspired by the real-life Merci Train. Although the book's outcome is fairly predictable, it offers well-researched details about the era and themes relatable to a modern audience. A subplot regarding Glory Bea's playing matchmaker for her two best friends adds humor and interest, highlighting the protagonist's determined attitude. Ages 8--12. Agent: Emily Mitchell, Wernick & Pratt Agency. (Mar.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review
Gr 3--6--A post--World War II story about a spirited small-town girl and her pursuit to welcome her father home. Glory Bea believes she is called to be a matchmaker. Grams already has 39 miracle matches to her name, so why shouldn't Glory Bea strive for the same? If things go as planned, the happy-ever-after between her best friend Ruby Jane and neighbor Ben will be miracle number 40. But Glory Bea also has a secret miracle in the works: bringing Daddy home from the front. They say he was lost in action at Omaha Beach, but Glory Bea doesn't believe it. After all, Daddy promised that he would return. When it's announced that the Merci Train--a train filled with gifts from the people of France--will roll through Gladiola, TX, Glory Bea is convinced it's a sign. Now all she must do is prepare for Daddy's homecoming, kindle romance between her two friends, and keep Mama from falling in love again. This is an endearing story that skillfully addresses loss, love, and hope. Weaving together small-town charm and friendly antics, Bustard cleverly integrates a history of the Merci Trains with a young girl's desperate desire to see her father again. Despite the emphasis that three years have passed since the end of the war, readers should watch for a few anachronisms that might challenge the image of the 1940s that most textbooks underscore. VERDICT This snapshot of a unique time in American history will inspire young readers and convince them that dreams are worth fighting for.--Rebecca Redinger, Lincoln Park Branch, Chicago Public Library
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Eleven-year-old Glory Bea believes in miracles.She's convinced that her beloved father, missing in action since D-Day, more than four years ago, is about to return home. Her small Texas town will play host to a Merci Train boxcar filled with gifts from those in France who were grateful for American help in the desperate period immediately after the war. Glory Bea's belief in her father's return is strengthened when his best friend arrives for a visit and then begins to court her mom. Even as she does whatever she can to thwart their very unwelcome growing relationship, she struggles to serve as matchmaker for her two best friends, ever loyal Ben and shy, slightly hapless Ruby Jane. Although her warm, loving grandparents, mother, and both friends support Glory Bea, it pushes credibility that she sustains such an implausible delusion so long after the loss of her father. The depiction of the flavor of a small town is nicely managed, but the only reminder of the Texas setting is the rare insertion of the contraction "Y'all," more jarring in its infrequent occurrences than convincingly evocative of dialect. Even if not fully believable, this effort still provides a heartening, feel-good ending.A tender story of grief and the gentle comfort of loved ones. (Historical fiction. 9-12) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.