Review by Booklist Review
Many members of the animal kingdom are renowned for their amazing abilities, but what about the critters with slightly more sinister traits? This playful book presents 13 different animals as villains on a detective's "most wanted" list. Each creature comes with an illustrated mug shot and detailed rap sheet, listing particular attributes and whereabouts. "Slippery Slick" is wanted for assault, for example--the rascal turns out to be a spitting llama, and the rap sheet includes his alias (the scientific name), gang name (a herd), and sightings (geographical habitat). Batori's comical illustrations suit the humorous subject matter perfectly, and each page is laid out as if the reader is privy to the actual case file scattered on the detective's messy desk. The unusual--and occasionally gruesome--traits will fascinate, and the format is a clever method of imparting a lot of knowledge in a manageable, entertaining way. In addition to their previous felonies, the animal criminals may end up stealing readers' hearts!
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by School Library Journal Review
Gr 3--5--Detective X, a polar bear with a badge and a magnifying glass, is hunting criminals of the animal kingdom. Their crimes? Llamas are wanted for spitting, cuckoo birds for laying eggs in other birds' nests, and wood frogs for playing dead. In other words, the animals are wanted for exhibiting their natural survival behaviors. The book is structured as a series of criminal dossiers with mug shots and evidence paper-clipped to file folders. The commitment to this structure creates an immersive experience for readers. Batori's illustrations bring big personality to even the littlest of creatures, like red crabs and antlions. However, the book's interesting facts can get lost within the perplexing fictional structure. By the end of the book, all of the animals are in the slammer and a child is considered a menace to society for refusing to go to bed. VERDICT Even in the jokey, tongue-in-cheek fashion in which the book is presented, the criminalization and imprisonment of animals and children for their natural behaviors is a strange conceit that makes the book difficult to recommend.--Chance Lee Joyner, Wilton Public and Gregg Free Library, NH
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Mini-dossiers on 13 of the natural world's thieves, tricksters, and other felons.Tekavec's criminals are wanted for infractions that include dangling a light in dark waters to draw unwary prey (anglerfish, aka "Ms. Jagged Jaws"), shooting a prospective mate with "a dart full of love hormones" (Roman snail, aka "Lil' Cupid"), slipping an egg into another bird's nest (common cuckoo, aka "Big Bad Mama"), or bullying rivals into sterility (naked mole rat queen, aka "Queenie the Meanie"). These and other bad actors are profiled with an M.O., a cartoon mug shot, and a fact-filled rap sheet. The author may stretch the premise a bit by including the wood frog, whose only misfeasance is spending winters as a frozen "Frogsicle," and "Slippery Slick" the llama for leaving "spit-covered tourists at the ruins of Machu Picchu," but the comical grimaces or expressions of popeyed dismay on Batori's wild creatures give the whole rogues' gallery a lighthearted, all-in-fun air. Kids will love learning about such revolting behaviors as antlion larvae's pre-consumption digestion of their food. The author's closing tally of animal commandments ("#3 All mothers are responsible for their own eggs") serves as an artful recap/pop quiz to boot. Kids who find the likes of Jim Arnosky's Tooth Claw (2014) or Steve Jenkins' Apex Predators (2017) a bit too, um, toothy are well served here.A pleaser for younger naturalists. (Informational picture book. 6-9) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
