Review by Choice Review
What makes for genius? Why do individuals in marginal communities make tremendous contributions to majority cultures? Lebrecht seeks to answer these questions by examining the lives of noted Jewish individuals between the 19th and 20th centuries, a time when modernity challenged traditional norms. He provides captivating profiles of familiar and unfamiliar figures with Jewish backgrounds, eschewing genetics as a factor and arguing that Talmudic learning, which promotes argument and the inclusion of differing perspectives, enabled individuals to confront modernity with creativity. Lebrecht links this discussion to the anxiety produced by tensions between majority and minority cultures. While this argument befits well-known figures Sigmund Freud, Albert Einstein, and Franz Kafka, it falls short for others. Additionally, criteria for defining who is a genius is unclear. An expert in music, Lebrecht includes many musical and cultural figures, but his emphasis on Western European and Ashkenazi Jews tends to marginalize the Sephardic and Eastern European communities. Hannah Arendt, Isaac Bashevis Singer, and Rosa Luxemburg get brief mentions; Jan Bloch, Isaiah Berlin, Jakob Bronowski, Raphael Lemkin and Hersch Lauterpacht, whose accomplishments deserve greater attention, are ignored. A deeper exploration of this topic is warranted. Summing Up: Optional. General readers and lower-division undergraduates. --Romuald K. Byczkiewicz, Central Connecticut State University
Copyright American Library Association, used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Music commentator Lebrecht (Why Mahler?) catalogues a century of important Jewish lives in this idiosyncratic and frantic cultural history. Each chapter centers on a single, pivotal year, allowing Lebrecht to weave together a collection of anecdotes and pared down biographical details of its subjects. He opens and closes his analysis outside the stated historical boundaries, beginning with Karl Marx's 1843 publication of "On the Jewish Question" and ending with the events leading up to the establishment of Israel in 1948, focusing throughout on Jews in Europe and the United States. Chapters are sometimes thematic, such as one devoted to Jewish developments in the study of sexuality, or another on early-20th-century music, while others are a strange melange of unrelated ideas, such as one that jumps among the filming of Casablanca, a trial convicting God in Auschwitz, a litany of suicides within Nazi-occupied territories, and the invention of birth control pills. Most of the figures are well-known and male, though there are some less familiar names, such as Eliza Davis, who influenced Charles Dickens's view of the Jews, or British rabbi Solomon Schonfeld, who vigorously worked to expatriate Jews just before WWII. Lebrecht can tell an enjoyable story with verve, though the lack of clear trajectory or organization dilutes his points. While readers interested in 19th- and 20th-century Judaism might enjoy dipping in and out of these snippets from important people's lives, this overfilled work founders as a whole. (Dec.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Library Journal Review
In Lebrecht's (The Song of Name) Jewish world, genius goes hand in hand with anxiety, and peril is never far from the frenetic inhabitants. Largely focused on German and French intellectuals, artists, and scientists, this work traces a line from Felix and Fanny Mendelssohn to figures such as Rosalind Franklin, with side trips to the Jewish quarters of Shanghai and Mumbai. Judaism for many of these people is a liability, either denied or shed, but often providing a vernacular for their achievements without being monolithic. All of this has a breathless feel, as stories spill over each other, told as though they are all happening at once, and many ending in unspeakable tragedy. As a longstanding music commentator and journalist, Lebrecht weaves in his own stories and anecdotes; for example, a somewhat improbable sounding conversation between Isaac Bashevis Singer and Manachem Begin was told to Lebrecht by Singer himself. VERDICT A unique perspective on the role of Jews in European intellectual life, this will be of interest to music and art history readers, as well as those interested in Jewish history.--Margaret Heller, Loyola Univ. Chicago Libs.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
How adversity shaped a century of Jewish creativity and invention."A Jew is like a man with a short arm," said the composer Gustav Mahler. "He has to swim harder to reach the shore." In this beautifully crafted work, music historian and novelist Lebrecht (Why Mahler?: How One Man and Ten Symphonies Changed the World, 2010, etc.) argues convincingly that "existential angst"a dread of losing their rights to citizenship and free speech amid widespread persecutionfreed many Jews to pursue unusual accomplishments with abandon. Not expecting acceptance, "free to think the unthinkable," Freud, Proust, Einstein, and others worked brilliantly in such fields as science, art, and music, not because of any genetic advantage but out of opportunity made possible by "marginality." With anxiety as a "primary motivating factor, the engine of fresh thinking," they began in the mid-19th century, and especially in the decade after the Dreyfus Affair, to engage in acts of genius. Such individuals as Marx and Disraeli set the tone for "a century of Jewish invention," unafraid of criticism from those in power. They paved the way for diverse successors, as well, including Trotsky, Sarah Bernhardt, Jonas Salk, and through to Larry Page, Sergey Brin, and Mark Zuckerberg. Taking us into many spheres of endeavor, Lebrecht offers revealing portraits of and stories about these Jews, practicing and not, as they crossed artistic boundaries, advanced science, and reshaped myriad aspects of Western society in the period through the 1947 founding of Israel. He provides nuanced explorations of individuals from Einstein, "a religious man of no religion, a perfect Jewish paradox," to Kafka, who knows "something terrible is about to happen and there is nothing anyone can do about it." Written with passion and authority, this book shows how these great minds always took a different point of viewand changed how we see the world. Lebrecht also includes a helpful glossary of Jewish terms.An absorbing, well-told story of Jewish achievement that is a pleasure to read. Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
