Review by Booklist Review
Here, readers are asked to wonder if they experience the colors of the world in the same ways as other people in different circumstances, and while the colors themselves are literally the same, the contexts in which they appear are quite different. Helakoski's narrative is elegant and poetic, simple yet sophisticated, rendering this work suitable as a concept book for younger readers or as a mentor text on writing and inquiry for older ones. Readers of all ages will be amazed by Sheffield's illustrations, whose essential interplay with the text dances a line between whimsical and philosophical. Multimedia collages feature a racially diverse array of people around the globe young and old, urban and rural, and everything in between all connected through shared experience, represented by color. The shades are vibrant, the compositions detailed yet impressionistic, and while the message can be pinned down to being about beauty, room is made for readers to decide for themselves.--Amina Chaudhri Copyright 2020 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Introspection goes global in this inquisitive lullaby. Helakoski's gently rhyming lyrics accompany readers on an exploration of hues that contemplates the perspectives of children around the world: "Do you splash in a puddle/ when the world is washed clean?/ Are the leaves fresh and bright?/ Is your green.../ ...like my green?" The text emphasizes building empathy and suggests that all children, differences aside, view their surroundings with a universal curiosity. Though the tiny text can be difficult to read, page turns invite pondering. Dynamic and generously textured collage illustrations by Sheffield lend the hued romp friendliness and warmth, with a softness that amplifies the childlike narrator's questions. An inclusive cast of children is depicted going about their everyday lives--engaging in activities such as playing soccer, picking apples, and baking cookies. The vivid, active spreads soon quiet into black and white, stirring somnolence, and text matches the mood: "Is the night sweet and sleepy?" A moonlit bed and starry snowscapes further the tranquility in this dreamy exploration of color and perspective. Ages 4--7. Author's agent: Rosemary Stimola, Stimola Literary Studio. Illustrator's agent: Laura Rennert, Andrea Brown Literary Agency. (Jan.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review
PreS-Gr 1--Children are asked to consider how people experience color across the world in this culturally diverse concept book. In a patterned text, readers learn about how children see and experience a variety of colors, including blue, gold, brown, green, yellow, red, pink, black, and white. For example, "Do you splash in a puddle/when the world is washed clean?/Are the leaves fresh and bright?/ Is your green…/…like my green?" A child in boots and a raincoat walking in a spring rain appears on the verso, while a girl peeks through a lush tropical rain forest on the recto. Neither locale is identified. The book concludes by asking readers if everyone sees the same thing, emphasizing what people have in common, with the last illustration showing two children sitting together and looking up at the same star. Helakoski's rhymes are lyrical and flowing, ready to be read aloud, and the style, which is question-heavy, encourages discussion. Sheffield's illustrations are bright, colorful, and eye-catching, making the title appropriate for group sharing. Although the diversity of places and people depicted, as well as the sentiment of the book, is admirable, there are some flaws in the execution. The tiny font often gets lost on the colorful pages and some colors inexplicably receive four pages rather than one-to-two pages. VERDICT Despite the flaws, this is a worthy addition to any children's collection and a unique take on a concept book for colors. Recommended.--Laura J. Giunta, Garden City Public Library, NY
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
No matter how different our lives are, some things are the same.A child's world is full of colorand, if they look closely, full of wonder. Most double-page spreads of this picture book feature rhyming verse set on the left-hand page that describes in developmentally appropriate language how a child narrator sees a color. Gold, for example, is "warm" and "full of sparkle," whereas blue is "deep, wide, and open." Each stanza ends with versions of the same question, which concludes across the gutter or after a page turn: "Is your gold / like my gold?" creating a repetitive pattern that will delight young readers. The text is accompanied by rich illustrations of diverse children from all around the world, including South Asia, Latin America, East Asia, and Western settings. The final page features a black child and a white child sitting arm and arm on a hilltop, looking at the same star, driving home the message that our similarities bring us together and our differences make us more beautiful. The best feature of the book is the highly textured, collage-style illustrations, many of which contain soft strokes of color that give the images a pleasantly dreamlike quality. Unfortunately, the print is small, and the single lines that begin with "like my" often get swallowed up in the pictures and are difficult to find. Design flaws aside, the book's timely message of universality among diversity is a highly relevant one. (Picture book. 2-5) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
