Review by Booklist Review
A happy duck watches as her three eggs hatch. Soon the ducklings are following their mother down to the water for their first swim. She dives off a ledge, followed by the first two ducklings ( SPLISH! SPLISH! ), who swim, and the third one ( SPLASH ), who sinks. Wait. What? Let's try that again, says the narrator. So the intrepid little duckling tries again and sinks again twice. The duckling tries water wings (too big), scuba gear (too scary), a Jet Ski (way too scary), and other ingenious schemes before finding the perfect, pirate-themed solution. In the artwork, expressive black-and-white lines, along with shades of blue-green, yellow, and orange, create the characters and suggest the settings. Positioning words creatively within the illustrations and using rhyme when things are moving along smoothly, Harney's satisfying text reads aloud beautifully. Both the words and the digital illustrations create a jaunty tone while setting up viewers' expectations, only to surprise them yet again. Fun to share, this picture book will amuse kids and leave everyone smiling.--Carolyn Phelan Copyright 2019 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
What begins as a simple rhyming picture book by Harney (Underwear!) morphs into a humorous metafictional tale about a resolute duckling's dilemma. After "one happy duck sits down to rest./ Three tiny eggs. One twiggy nest," three eggs hatch, producing a trio of wee ducks (an onlooker, a pink worm, grins at their appearance). Two of the fledglings immediately take to swimming, but as the title implies, the last duckling experiences some difficulty. As soon as the third begins to sink, an omniscient narrator intrudes ("Huh... I didn't know ducks could sink. This is a problem. Ducks need to swim. AND all of this sinking is ruining the rhyme"), adding a meta layer to the narrative. With the gentle companionship of the worm, the duckling approaches her predicament from various angles (a running start, orange water wings, and lengthy stilts among them) before constructing a creative solution that allows the duck to float comfortably. Expressive digital illustrations, bright orange feet, and dramatic typography against a mellow aqua background mark this charming celebration of perseverance and problem-solving skills. Ages 3--5. Agent: Rachel Orr, Prospect Agency. (Jan.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review
PreS-Gr 1--Three tiny eggs crack open to the rhythmic "Quack" of three little ducks. "Three tiny ducks in one straight line. New, happy flock. All feeling fine." But all is not fine when the ducklings follow their Mama into the water; the last little one sinks (not swims) once…twice…again and again. "All of this sinking is ruining the rhyme." Not to worry--the determined little one begins a series of experiments to test for duckling flotation through a variety of possibilities: a running start, water wings, enlisting the help of other pond creatures, "state-of-the-art scuba gear," stilts, and even a rip-roaring, out-of-control Jet Ski. Digital cartoon art reveals the terrified onlookers, while enlarged font and onomatopoeia put readers in the middle of the action through each failed attempt--until Duckling #3 can find a solution with a clever bit of thinking (and still save the rhyme). VERDICT Children will come up with their own suggestions and solutions for a happy duckling ending in this suggested general purchase for all libraries.--Mary Elam, Learning Media Services, Plano ISD, TX
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Horn Book Review
Three eggs hatch. Crack! Crack! Crack! / Three tiny ducks. Quack! Quack! Quack! Following their mother to water, the three tiny ducks jump right in. Splish! Splish! Splash! / Swim. Swim... // Sink. Wait. What? says the offstage narrator, breaking the fourth wall. Lets try that again. But the third small duckling again becomes submerged (and ruins the rhyme). The narrator makes severalincreasingly ridiculoussuggestions, including a running start, a push from below (a.k.a. an assist from a turtle), gigantic water wings, and a jet ski. Just as all hope seems lost, a float-ing leaf gives the swim-challenged bird the clever idea to build a boat, which gets the rhyme back on track. That the little duck has constructed a pirate ship out of its eggshell is a twist sure to please young viewers. The primarily greenish-blue and yellow digital illustrations are full of expressive critters (including a friendly worm who appears on most spreads), with minimal backgrounds keeping the focus on the main action. The square trim size and thick glossy pages were clearly designed for little hands. And Harneys read-aloud-ready text is full of pleasing sound effects, simple words and rhymes, and plenty of meta silliness that will have its preschool audience repeating: Quack. Quack. ARRRRRRRR! Cynthia K. Ritter March/April 2020 p.57(c) Copyright 2020. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Three ducklings hatch and try to follow their mother, with a watchful worm observing."Three tiny ducks jump right in. / SPLISH! SPLISH! SPLASH!! / Swim. Swim // Sink." At that point the author/illustrator calls a do-over, understanding that the rhythm and logical story arc are off. The ducks try again, the third duck is again unsuccessful, and the worm comments with a quizzical look on its face: "Huh...I didn't know ducks could sink. This is a problem. Ducks need to swim." The narrator laments: "AND all of this sinking is ruining the rhyme." Following this, the sinking duck uses an array of humorous strategies to achieve its goal, winsomely depicted in the bold, firmly outlined illustrations, with their lovely aqueous blue water and white, yellow, and orange ducks. Some of the solutions are ingenious: "Stilts to stay high and dry?" "State-of-the-art scuba gear?" "A Jet Ski" motors the duck along in one of the more exciting pictures, full of froth shaking up fish in the wake left behind by the machine. But none of these ploys works until the worm and the duck create a pirate sailing ship out of the duckling's cracked eggshell. Maybe this will work for the youngest pirate fansbut as the narrator feared, it makes for a pretty flat arc.A duck turns into a pirate, but not much adventure happens. (Picture book. 3-5) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
