Review by Booklist Review
The creator of Funny Bones (2015) and Undocumented (2018) continues to shine a much-needed light on unrecognized Mexican American contributions to history. José de la Luz Sáenz strove to bring about racial equality, from the underfunded and segregated classrooms in his local community to the trenches of France during WWI. After fighting for his country in the Great War, Luz hoped that he and his fellow soldiers of Mexican descent would be accepted and celebrated, but that wasn't the case, and so he spent the rest of his life advocating for equal rights, cofounding LULAC, one of the oldest organizations that fights for Latinx rights. Using kid-friendly language that doesn't shy away from the ugliness of prejudice and war, Tonatiuh expertly crafts an informative and engaging picture-book biography supported by primary sources. If the straightforward text doesn't grab young readers, the arresting pre-Columbian-inspired art will. The illustrations are hand-drawn and digitally collaged, with the neutral, brown-tinged palette recalling WWI's uniforms and trenches. Direct quotes from the subject's diaries and correspondences are seamlessly incorporated into the narrative, and Tonatiuh makes use of Luz's actual handwriting, inserting the script as texture into several backgrounds. Thorough back matter includes two time lines, sources, a glossary, and more. This one's a must for all picture-book biography collections.--Shelley M. Diaz Copyright 2010 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Although he was an American citizen, José de la Luz Sáenz (1888--1953) was beaten up and denied access to local Texan businesses because his parents were of Mexican origin. He determined to fight back: "Luz knew that knowledge was a weapon that helped you defend yourself against those who were mean to you and ignored your rights." First a teacher, he joined the army and shipped out to Europe to fight in WWI. Quick to learn French, he was promoted to intelligence work, but he was never given a higher rank or more pay. His friendships with other Mexican-American soldiers led him to help form the League of United Latin American Citizens, an organization that advocated for equal rights for Latinx Americans. Characteristic illustrations by Tonatiuh (Danza!) use carved-stone faces and formal, ceremonial postures to represent the characters in this picture book. An inspiring introduction to an underrepresented figure who pursued his lifelong vision for equality and justice. Ages 6--8. (Sept.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review
Gr 1--3--José de la Luz Sáenz knew that many people who had roots in Mexico were hard workers, just like his father, and he did not understand why people were mistreated simply because of their heritage. Luz, who was born in Texas, experienced discrimination firsthand and made it his goal to help others of Mexican descent. After working as a teacher, Luz joined the army to fight in World War I in the hopes that others would realize that Mexican Americans were also willing to sacrifice for the United States. Although Luz faced discrimination, even from some of his fellow soldiers, he made close friends and spent his time studying French, which helped him earn a position in communications receiving, translating, and sending messages. Upon his return to the States, Luz was disappointed to learn that the discrimination faced by Mexican Americans had not changed. Together with other war veterans in Texas, Luz worked to improve the rights of Mexican Americans, ultimately forming the League of United Latin American Citizens (LULAC)--an organization that fought for democracy, justice, and equality. Tonatiuh's traditional hand-drawn and collage-style illustrations depict Luz and his fellow Mexican Americans' trials and victories, as well as the tragedies of the war. Clear, descriptive text traces Luz's life and provides insight into his thoughts, feelings, and determination. VERDICT A culturally and historically important work focusing on an inspirational Mexican American soldier who fought for America during the Great War, as well as for equal rights for his fellow Mexican Americans. An essential purchase for all children's nonfiction collections.--Selenia Paz, Harris County Public Library, Houston
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Horn Book Review
Growing up Mexican American in Texas at the turn of the twentieth century meant racism and discrimination to Jos de la Luz Senz: the first word in the book is Greaser! hurled at young Luz by another boy (whom Luz then tackles to the ground). Luz grows up, marries, has children, becomes a teacher, and goes off to fight in World War I, where his facility with languageshe was already fluent in Spanish, and has now also learned Frenchallows him to act as a translator. Despite his serving his country faithfully, injustice and inequality persist when he returns home, but Luz never stops fighting for whats right. He remains politically active in various organizations and helps create the influential League of United Latin American Citizens. In this informative and inspiring story, Tonatiuhs signature style is on full display: digitally manipulated colors and textures complement thin lines and flat shapes, inspired by the artistic style of Mexicos indigenous Mixtec people. Moreover, Tonatiuhs obvious pride in Latinx heritage, coupled with that heritages sociopolitical undertones, places his body of work in the broader tradition of Latinx political artand this fine picture-book biography is the latest iteration. An authors note, sources, timelines, a bibliography, an index, and a glossary are appended. Jonathan Hunt January/February 2020 p.111(c) Copyright 2020. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
In 1918, Jos de la Luz Senz left his teaching job and enlisted in the United States Army, where he joined thousands of other Mexican American soldiers."He wanted to demonstrate that Mexican Americans loved America and would give their lives fighting for it," writes Tonatiuh. Luz felt that the white people of Texas would start treating Tejanos (Texans of Mexican descent) fairly after seeing their sacrifice. Once in France, Luz taught himself French and was assigned to the intelligence office to translate communications, but he was not given credit or promotions for this vital work. After the war, he and other Tejano veterans found prejudice against them unchanged. They organized and became civil rights leaders. In 1929, 10 years after the end of World War I, they formed the League of United Latin American Citizens. Together they fought against school segregation, racism, prejudice, and "for the ideals of democracy and justice." The author's insightful use of Senz's war-diary entries boldly introduces this extraordinary American's triumphs and struggles. In Tonatiuh's now-trademark illustrations, Luz crouches with other stylized doughboys in French trenches as shells explode in no man's land and mourns a fallen fellow Mexican in a French cemetery. Extensive backmatter includes an author's note, war timeline, timeline of LULAC's successful civil rights lawsuits, glossary, and bibliography.An important contribution to this volatile chapter in U.S. and Mexican American history. (Picture book/biography. 6-8) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
