Review by Booklist Review
Pop culture fans love taking powerful characters from separate worlds and debating who would win in a fight, and the Battle Royale: Lethal Warriors series (8 new titles) walks hi/lo readers through this alluring game. Each title pairs two of "the deadliest and most feared warriors from different time periods, mythology, and legends," outlining their respective traits before simulating a fight between them. The results, however, are left up to the readers, calling upon them to utilize the information they've learned and exercise some imagination. A pair of huge, many-appendaged monsters clash in Kraken vs. Hydra. Reluctant readers will certainly be hooked by the concept--bolstered by sections of "Fun Facts," detailed descriptions of the subjects, and an inclusion of violence (in Bigfoot's case, "He twists the necks of his prey")--though the design and illustrations leave something to be desired. Loh-Hagan's unvarying use of simple sentences accommodates an early elementary reading level at the cost of awkward prose. Vocab words are highlighted, with definitions following in the text (as well as the glossary). Still, this foolproof concept will attract a range of readers, hi/lo and on-level.
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by School Library Journal Review
Gr 2 Up--This tersely written, dramatically illustrated series rewards readers who savor the idea of frightening creatures duking it out. Introductory pages explore opponents' characteristics, mythical or folkloric origins, powers, strengths, and weaknesses. The section "Choose Your Battleground" identifies three locations (sea, land, or mountains) and explains how fighters would fare in each; a "Weapons" sidebar is included. "Fight On!" follows, accompanied by a "Food for Battle" sidebar describing combatants' stealthy strategies. "And the Victor Is…" sums up the conflict. Highlights: "Top Champion" discusses similar beings in myths from various cultures. "Consider This!" includes a list of critical thinking questions. VERDICT Fearsome warriors (some female) have strong appeal, especially for striving readers. Nonessential but recommended where wanted for school and public library collections. In journalism or creative writing units, teachers and educators could have students conduct "ringside interviews" or "play-by-play announcing." Artistic students could create posters promoting the battles.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
