Review by Booklist Review
This is the third picture book from Williams' featuring a ""what if they disappeared?"" theme (polar bears and sharks came first). Basic background information briefly addresses types of elephants, their habitats, and how they've become endangered. Using straightforward language that young readers will understand, the text explains how prodigious amounts of elephant poop spread undigested seeds throughout a jungle, sowing new crops of plants necessary to maintain biodiversity. Subsequent pages show the devastating events that would happen if elephants became extinct. The worst scenario would be the destruction of an ecosystem's biodiversity due to the loss of plants, which could lead all the way to a catastrophic trophic cascade. These sophisticated vocabulary terms are effectively integrated into a logical, aptly described sequence. The illustrations are rendered mostly in green, gray, and brown, except for a couple of young African guides wearing neon t-shirts, who pop against the earth-tone palette (especially as future possibilities become bleaker). Back matter includes a glossary and bibliography, additional information about tropical forests and elephants' endangered status, and reasonable suggestions for how kids can help. This appealing offering is quite suitable for inquiry projects on ecosystems or endangered species, and will attract animal lovers, too.--Kathleen McBroom Copyright 2010 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Horn Book Review
This latest entry in the accessible picture-book series (If Sharks Disappeared; If Polar Bears Disappeared) examines the projected impacts of removing a single prominent, vulnerable species-the African forest elephant-from an ecosystem. Williams explains that in the Congo Basin, elephants are a keystone species, as the distances they travel-and the poop they produce-help spread plant seeds throughout the forests. From "dung, to plants, to animals, to people," the relationships are complex, and breaking them could cascade the planet into environmental destruction. The richly colored, cartoony illustrations on each double-page spread creatively alternate perspectives: on one spread, the face and splayed ears of an elephant fill the entire scene, while others take a long view on the region, from the treetops with birds passing below, or even a satellite-style view of African ecosystems. Periodically the perspective reorients itself to human scale, as two (brown-skinned) children and an adult trail the elephants making their way through the forest. The story ends on a positive note, with illustrations of an elephant family splashing in a river and the humans in a schoolroom making posters to advocate for conservation. Additional notes in the closing pages provide more details on the threats to all elephant species, as well as steps readers can take to help; a glossary, an author's note, and a brief bibliography are also appended. Danielle J. Ford November/December 2019 p.121(c) Copyright 2019. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
The latest installment in Williams' series shows how elephants' survival affects the whole world.African forest elephants are a "keystone species," defined here as one whose "actionsfrom walking, to eating, to pooping, to sleepingshape their environment." The interaction between elephants and the complex ecosystem that makes up the tropical forest is explored, from how elephants shape their environment to how that environment would change without elephants, ending with how readers can help ensure they don't disappear. As elephants walk thousands of miles through the forest, eating hundreds of pounds of plants each day and spreading their dung throughout the area, the undigested seeds in their dung are moved around, diversifying the ecosystem. But "poachers are killing elephants faster than they can reproduce." If their dung disappeared, plant biodiversity would decrease, which would affect the animals and the forest soileven the forest's ability to survive. Standing in for readers, two black children in jeans and T-shirts enter the forest with a black adult, appear throughout the story, and, at the end, draw a "save the elephants" poster. The structure of Williams' text keeps readers' interest in this fascinating subject piqued, and she does a fine job explaining the science in lay terms. The artwork uses a palette of deep greens and browns to illustrate how these changes would alter the world.Uniquely thought-provoking and important. (Informational picture book. 7-12) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
