Review by Booklist Review
It's 1799 and the French Revolution has ended, but poverty still runs rampant. Impoverished Odette, 14, and her mother, Anneline, are on the move again, after her mother accidentally kills her fifth husband. They arrive in Nevers, France, in a cheese cart and seek lodging. M. Gustave guides them to a dirty two-room guardhouse straddling the roadway. Odette sets about cleaning while her mother feigns exhaustion and falls onto the ancient straw mattress. Ever resourceful, Odette finds ways to earn a few sous, provide for the two of them, tend the garden, and make friends with Nicois, 13, next door. She thinks Nevers might be the place where they finally settle. This historical fantasy boasts a cast of eccentric, yet interconnected, human and animal characters, including donkey Anne, who speaks in Latin all night. The plot unfolds with mystery and hilarity, building momentum in a way that will keep readers engaged to the end. Recommend to fans of Adam Gidwitz's The Inquisitor's Tale (2016).--J. B. Petty Copyright 2019 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by School Library Journal Review
Gr 4--7--In 1799 France, young Odette has grown accustomed to caring for her mother, Anneline, who is prone to accidentally killing people. Moving to Nevers is no different; Odette finds them lodging and food and secures a job as a midwife's assistant while her mother worries about her past. Odette befriends the midwife's son Nicois, and together they uncover a mystery involving the strange inhabitants of the town and their connection to Odette. The citizens of Nevers include Anne the donkey, who brays in Latin every night; Mme. Genevive, the mysterious inventor; M. Gustave, the landlord who wishes to be a chicken; and M. Manis, who has a fascination with smelling hands. The story is told by an omniscient narrator, adding to the fairy-tale feel. Readers will enjoy the quirky characters and be pleasantly surprised by the twist ending. There are gay and intersex characters in the town of Nevers. It is also notable that Odette and Nicois form a close friendship that does not become romantic, but rather familial. While the pacing is quick, the story never feels rushed. VERDICT A worthy addition to middle grade collections; give this to fans of Adam Gidwitz's The Inquisitor's Tale.--Katharine Gatcomb, Portsmouth Public Library, NH
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
In the chaotic countryside of post-Revolutionary France, Odette and her flighty mother, always on the move, try to make a home in the town of Nevers.Fourteen-year-old Odette's always had to care for her mother, Anneline, who is gorgeous, selfish, and accident prone. When people in Anneline's vicinity (usually one of the many husbands she's had) end up dead, it always is, truly, completely by chance. Yet after each such incident, Anneline and Odette take to the roads seeking safety. In Nevers, Odette scrubs and gardens, cooks and schemes, crossing her fingers that maybe this time they'll find stability. Though she keeps to herself, Odette's drawn to the fascinating sights of Nevers, and readers will be as well. There's M. Mains, a former scholar who smells people's hands to learn about them, Mme. Genevieve the inventor, and M. Gustave, their landlord, who secretly wishes he were a chicken. There's a piglet and a new-hatched chick who are BFFs and a donkey who brays in Latin that only Odette hears. And best of all, there's Nicois, who rapidly becomes like the brother she's never had. Together, dark-skinned Nicois and light-skinned Odette try to solve a puzzle that might connect Odette's history to secrets here in Nevers. Gay and intersex representation fits smoothly into the historical setting, meshing neatly and naturally with these charmingly odd characters living their everyday lives in the aftermath of massive social upheaval.This brief sojourn in an alternative 18th-century France is an unexpectedly rich one. (historical note) (Historical fantasy. 9-12) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
