Review by Booklist Review
Obreht, whose award-winning debut, The Tiger's Wife (2011), became an international bestseller, brings her extraordinarily intricate worldview, psychological and social acuity, descriptive artistry, and shrewd, witty, and zestful storytelling to another provocative inquiry into the mysteries of place, nature, and human complexities. In this audacious tale in sync with those of Rick Bass, Hannah Tinti, and Karen Russell, we're privy to the thoughts of two haunted characters running on separate, ultimately colliding tracks. Lurie is a young fugitive roaming the Southwest, communing with ghosts, and puzzling over his distant origins. Nora's escalating struggle takes place on a drought-stricken homestead in the Arizona Territory in 1893. Even though she converses with her dead first child, she blames clairvoyant Josie for Nora's youngest son's claim that he's seen a frightful winged beast. While Nora's newspaper-owner husband is off searching for water and their older sons are responsible for the paper, a vicious controversy whips up like a dust devil and Nora's already precarious situation worsens. Smart, funny, and ruthless, Nora is a marvel of shocking contradictions. Kind Lurie stumbles into a surreal bit of little-known actual history involving the U.S. army. As her protagonists' lives converge, Obreht inventively and scathingly dramatizes the delirium of the West its myths, hardships, greed, racism, sexism, and violence in a tornadic novel of stoicism, anguish, and wonder.--Donna Seaman Copyright 2019 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
The unrelenting harshness of existence in the unsettled American West sharply focuses what Obreht (The Tiger's Wife) refers to as "the uncertain and frightening textures of the world" in this mesmerizing historical novel spun from two primary narrative threads. In one, homesteader Nora Lark waits with her son and niece for the return of her newspaperman husband with a supply of badly needed water for their house in Amargo, in the Arizona Territory in 1893. In the other, outlaw Lurie Mattie flees a warrant for murder by taking refuge in the Camel Corps, an all-but-forgotten experiment in history to import camels as beasts of burden in the 19th-century American Southwest. As Nora's and Lurie's paths gradually converge, Obreht paints a colorful portrait of the Western landscape, populated by a rogue's gallery of memorable characters and saturated with spirits of the countless dead who attain a tangible presence, if only through the conversations they conduct in the minds of the characters whom they haunt. The novel's unforgettable finale, evocative and grimly symbolic, crystallizes its underlying themes of how inconsolable grief and unforgivable betrayal shape the circumstances that bind its characters to their fates. Obreht knocks it out of the park in her second novel. Agent: Seth Fishman, the Gernert Company. (Aug.)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Library Journal Review
At 37, Nora Lark feels she's become a hard woman from the impossible challenges over the last 20 years with husband Emmett, who has pursued numerous failed adventures. The year 1893 finds them barely holding their ranch together in the Arizona Territory during a prolonged drought. In search of their water delivery, Emmett is now three days overdue, and their two older sons take charge of Emmett's newspaper while Nora runs the ranch with youngest son Toby; Josie, Emmett's teenage cousin; and Missus Harriet, Emmett's frail, elderly mother. No wonder Nora has intense conversations with her long-dead daughter, Evelyn. Over a day and a half, Nora struggles with Toby's visions of a beast stalking their land, Josie's séances, Rob and Dolan's unknown fate following a violent confrontation, and a crooked landowner who claims to know Emmett's fate. Running parallel to Nora's story is one of the Balkans-born outlaw Lurie Mattie, who has been making his way west for the past 40 years. How he ends up in Nora's yard roped to a camel is a most unusual, absorbing tale. VERDICT National Book Award finalist Obreht (The Tiger's Wife) suspensefully reimagines an extraordinary American West filled with larger-than-life characters, imaginary marauding beasts, and ghosts who commune with the living. [See Prepub Alert, 2/4/19.]--Donna Bettencourt, Mesa Cty. P.L., Grand Junction, CO
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
A frontier tale dazzles with camels and wolves and two characters who never quite meet.Eight years after Obreht's sensational debut, The Tiger's Wife (2011), she returns with a novel saturated in enough realism and magic to make the ghost of Gabriel Garca Mrquez grin. She keeps her penchant for animals and the dead but switches up centuries and continents. Having won an Orange Prize for The Tiger's Wife, a mesmerizing 20th-century Balkan folktale, Obreht cuts her new story from a mythmaking swatch of the Arizona Territory in 1893. The book alternates between the narratives of two complex, beset protagonists: Lurie, an orphan and outcast who killed a boy, and Nora, a prickly frontierswoman with her own guilty conscience. Both speak to the dead. Lurie sees ghosts from early childhood and acquires their "wants," while Nora keeps up a running conversation with her daughter, Evelyn, dead of heatstroke as a baby but aging into a fine young woman in her mother's mind. Obreht throws readers into the swift river of her imaginationit takes a while to realize that Lurie is addressing all his remarks to a camel. The land is gripped by terrible drought. As Nora's homestead desiccates, her husband leaves in search of water, and her older sons bolt after an explosive dispute. An indignant local drunk wonders whether "anybody else in this town [had] read an almanac or history in their lives? What were they all doing here, watching the sky, farming rock and dust?" Still, a deep stoicism, flinty humor, and awe at the natural world pervade these characters. They are both treacherous and good company. Here is Nora, hyperaware of a man who's not her husband: "Foremost on her mind: the flimsiness of her unlaundered shirt and the weight of her boots." Lurie, hiding among the U.S. Army's camel cavaliers (you can look them up), is dogged down the years by Arkansas Marshal John Berger. Their encounters mystify both men. Meanwhile, there are head lice, marvelous, dueling newspaper editorials, and a mute granny with her part to play.The final, luminous chapter is six pages that will take your breath away. Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.