Review by Booklist Review
With swirling, artful visuals and a thoughtful approach to middle-school emotions, this tender, quiet graphic novel follows Charlie and her friends as they work on a music class project and, more deeply, consider their own friendships and identities. When her music teacher, Mr. K, asks his students to find one song that speaks to who they are, Charlie is stumped until she hears an aria performed by Maria Callas. As she listens to more opera, she finds an outlet for the feelings she's tried to keep stifled worry about a classmate who stopped coming to school, a crush on a quiet boy others don't seem to understand, pride in herself, and empathy and compassion for those around her. It's a revelation beautifully depicted in Eggenschwiler's thick-lined artwork with warm, jewel-toned accent colors, which does an excellent job of capturing the emotional tenor of each scene; for instance, a cloud of butterflies engulfing Charlie's crush. In addition to the gorgeous visual lexicon, the story beautifully touches on the powerful emergence of strong feelings that happens in middle school and the various ways tweens either embrace those emotions or project their discomfort in cruelty. Opera is an unusual but pitch-perfect match for that swell of overwhelming feeling, and Maclear and Eggenschwiler fold it into the story perfectly. A poignant, pithy, and arrestingly illustrated story.--Sarah Hunter Copyright 2019 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Taking on friendships, crushes, cliques, and music culture, Maclear offers an honest, deeply respectful look at what is at the core of belonging and isolation for teenagers. Charlie Noguchi narrates her middle-school existence through the lens of her music teacher's assignment to "choose a song for this moment in your life and write about it." She pines for Emile, a quiet aspiring entomologist, and wonders about the mysterious prolonged absence of Luka, a femme boy who sings like an angel and once disturbed kids and adults at school with his unapologetic fabulousness ("All the boys who acted like they didn't care about anything saw him singing like he cared about everything," Charlie observes). Lush illustrations by Eggenschwiler (Coyote Tales) are color coded-yellow for Charlie, blue for Luka, and red for Maria Callas, the singer Charlie claims for her own and whose biography is threaded through the present-day story. When Charlie, Emile, Luka, and friends find the courage to express themselves together, their music creates a rainbow. With poetic words and pictures, Maclear and Eggenschwiler create a synesthetic experience that captures all the high and low notes of youth. Ages 10-14. (Apr.) © Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
Review by School Library Journal Review
Gr 5-8-Two months before middle school graduation, Charlotte (Charlie) Noguchi and the rest of class 8C have one final assignment-to find the soundtrack of their lives, a song that has meaning for them. Their music teacher Mr. K introduces them to different styles, including metal, pop, rap, jazz, emo, and opera. Yellow tones dominate these sections of the book with realistic, detailed, eye-catching art and cross hatching that adds dimension. Breaking up the main plot, Charlie shares her story from behind the empty desk in her class. Yellow switches dramatically to blue for flashback scenes. A lone desk is shown in the middle of the panel framed by Charlie's hair, giving it the appearance of theater curtains parting. Luka, with his long shiny hair and beautiful singing voice, left school after singing a song to Emile. Charlie seems to like Emile but is also worried about Luka and hopes he'll come back to school. Colored in red, Charlie also discusses famed opera singer and diva Maria Callas. Drawn to her music and life story, Charlie researches -Callas for her final project. A bibliography with further reading about the singer is included at the end of the graphic novel. -VERDICT -Brimming with raw emotion, music references, and gorgeous art, this memorable and relatable graphic novel will linger with -readers.-Marissa -Lieberman, East Orange Public Library, NJ © Copyright 2019. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Horn Book Review
When Mr. Kerner challenges his music class to choose a song for this moment in your life and write about it, Charlotte Noguchi (a.k.a. Charlie) is stuck. Truth be told, she is more interested in parsing her crush on classmate Emile than she is in music, until the day Mr. K puts Maria Callas on the turntable (Mr. K is very old-school; his own song-for-life is A-has Take On Me). Thats about it for a through-line; this graphic novel is more interested in the middle-school dynamics of crushes, cliques, and bullying, all drawn within the rich context of Charlies interior life and her burgeoning passion for opera. School life is colored in ochres, the poignant story of a nonconformist classmate in blue, Charlies mini-biography of La Divina bringswhat else?blood red to the page; throughout, small panels play well with drama supplied by full-page pictures in just the right spots. The quiet revelation that Charlies crush on Emile cant go anywhere romantic is bittersweet (she may have lost a crush, but shes gained a great friend)a quality that extends to the story as a whole, a boon to the Charlies among and within us. roger Sutton (c) Copyright 2019. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
The rules: "Do not draw too much attention." And "always look bored."Using spare, well-chosen words and muted primary colors, Maclear and Eggenschwiler cleverly weave together story, visual art, and music. Charlotte "Charlie" Noguchi, one of three Asian girls in her school, navigates the everyday, hormonal-driven drama of middle school by these rules until a new, white transfer student, Luka, joins their music class and she is introduced to the opera diva Mara Callas. As she observes and learns more about these individuals, Charlie is forced to question if it is better to be a nobody or to face criticism and rejection for standing out. The primary colors not only deliberately separate storylines (yellow for spring, blue for the previous fall, and red for Mara Callas' time), but also serve as visual cues to highlight things left unsaid in text, such as an empty blue desk or a choice of red lipstick. Quite a bit of music history is explored here as well, as the students learn about different music genres while gearing up for the year-end performance showcase. Other than explicitly pointing out Charlie and her friends as Asian, race and ethnicity are not central to this story. Casual homophobia, however, is touched upon as Luka boldly draws attention and slurs with his long hair, outr fashion, and unselfconscious singing.Clever and contemplative, with music history readers might find unexpectedly fun. (bibliography) (Graphic fiction. 10-14) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
