The not-so great outdoors

Gr 1--3--On a camping trip with her family, a confirmed city girl wonders why her parents are so keen to go experience "the great outdoors." There is nothing good out there--no power, no buildings, and no playgrounds. There are no pretty lights to look at or buildings for shelter. On the trip, they see caves, bears, and songbirds, but it is not as appealing as the city. However, catching a fish is awesome, and the animals do clever things to get what they need from the environment. The sunsets are beautiful and eating food they catch and cook over an open fire is delicious. The night sky is so amazing that the girl does not mind missing her favorite show. This story quaintly shows how a young girl goes from an indifference to nature to appreciating it and capturing loads of photos to bring back to her urban home. The illustrations are intricate and beautifully done. This book will appeal to a niche group who appreciate detailed drawings to help tell the story. VERDICT A lovely addition, but one that will probably appeal more to the older range of students.--Nicole Detter-Smith, Homestead High School, IN

A school-age kid is grumpy about going on a family camping trip but eventually comes to appreciate what the outdoors has to offer.Standing on the street in a very cool town, with its artsy soap and pottery stands and street musician, our protagonist, arms folded, tells the other kids, "I have no idea why we have to venture into the great outdoors' this summer," but off they go, leaving the city behind and driving straight into the mountains. "It's not like there's anything out here," the narrator continues, as the landscape turns thick with wildlife. "There's no electricity," is the next complaint, as the protagonist sits glumly, ignoring the campfire. The narrator misses the "city lights" even as mom points up at the aurora borealis. The others seem oblivious to this disgruntlement as they frolic, take pictures, and explore. After they spot bears (from the safety of the car), the narrator comes around. "Well, I guess I could get by with songbirds instead of street performers." Fishing, biking, and incredible views are none too shabby either. The mixed-media illustrations use short strokes and deep color to render the fullness of the land with a calm energy. The narrator has brown skin and straight, black hair, as do baby sib and mom; dad presents white.Watching this protagonist's reluctant change of heart won't get old; neither will the beckoning scenes of the great outdoors. (Picture book. 5-9) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.