Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
In this immersive history, Wolman (contributing editor at Outside magazine) and Smith (Crossing the Heart of Africa) aim to "overturn simplistic notions of cowboys and Indians" and "explore questions of identity, imperialism, and race" by telling the story of Hawaiian cowboy culture. Drawing on oral histories and other primary sources, the authors recount how, in the 1830s, King Kamehameha I invited vaqueros to teach Hawaiians how to rope and herd cattle; "Hawai'ian cowboys called themselves paniolo, a local twist on the word espanol." The book flips between Hawaii's ranches and Cheyenne Frontier Days, a rodeo show devoted to showcasing "life and sport in the West," featuring such well-known characters as Buffalo Bill and Annie Oakley. In 1907, paniolo (and ranching empire scion) Eben Low visited Frontier Days and offered American cowboys a trip to Hawaii to compete against him and his riders; the competition was a success, and Low and his riders were invited in turn to compete in Cheyenne, Wyo. In Wyoming newspapers, the Hawaiians were depicted as foreigners despite the annexation of Hawaii 10 years earlier, but they won "the rodeo equivalent of Olympic Gold." This thoughtful look at Hawaii's place in the Wild West will appeal to readers interested in underexplored elements of American history. Agent: Byrd Leavell, United Talent Agency. (May)
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Library Journal Review
The image of the American cowboy brings to mind locations such as Texas, Oklahoma, and Wyoming, but that list doesn't generally include Hawaii. Wolman (Outside magazine) and Smith (Crossing the Heart of Africa) here set the record straight. The book's first part provides a history of Hawaiian cowboys (paniolo), tracing it back to the introduction of cattle to the islands in the late 1700s that, by the mid-1800s, had given birth to a thriving cattle ranching culture. Parallel to this development, the authors describe the changing reputation of Cheyenne, WY, from outlaw outpost to rodeo capital, attracting fans from across the country to its annual Frontier Days. Later chapters continue these two narratives, following the increasing popularity of rodeo events in Hawaii and across the American West. The two worlds gradually come together, culminating with the 1908 Cheyenne Frontier Days debut and triumph of three legendary paniolo: Ikua Purdy, Jack Low, and Archie Ka'au'a. VERDICT Part history lesson, part rodeo diary, this will find appeal across a broad audience and be of particular interest to fans of rodeo culture, Hawaiian history, and the early American West. [See Prepub Alert, 11/12/18.]--Sara Holder, Univ. of Illinois Libs., Champaign
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.