Review by New York Times Review
SNEAKING LESSONS AND MORALS into children's stories might seem like trying to con a picky eater by discreetly tucking spinach into a meatball, but it's a tradition as old as fairy tales themselves. Back in the day, the Brothers Grimm used their stories to warn us against going into the woods alone, talking to strangers and eating at random people's houses - at least two of which were legitimate dangers at the time. So it's no surprise that, beneath the magic, monsters and miracles, today's kid lit authors seem to have something to say about discrimination, tribalism and fear of the "other." Eliot Schrefer's new Lost Rainforest series casts sunset as nature's own MasonDixon line, dividing animal kind into daywalkers and nightwalkers - two factions with a xenophobic fear of one another. It's a prejudice that, like many in the real world, is born of ignorance, since the two groups never cross paths. And Mez, the young panther protagonist of "Mez's Magic," is not immune to it. She professes her pride in being a denizen of the darkness - "the time for the proper creatures of the world to thrive" - and shudders at the thought of the "monsters" that walk by day. And she does so even while harboring a secret: She goes both ways. Mez is a shadowwalker - an animal that stalks under both sun and moon. And like many closeted children, she fears losing her tradition-minded family if she is ever outed. Because the one thing nightwalkers and daywalkers agree on is that shadowwalkers are an abomination of nature. But being a shadowwalker means more than just glitchy circadian rhythms; it also means magical powers. Things change for Mez when she meets Auriei the boa constrictor, a sort of serpentine Professor X who recruits her for his anthropomorphic superteam. These "gifted" animals from both the nocturnal and diurnal worlds must learn to trust one another and work together to prevent the resurrection of the legendarily dangerous Ant Queen. But like the X-Men, they must battle not only the villains, but a hateful and distrustful populace as well. "Mez's Magic" is packed with as many jokes as fast-paced fight scenes (some of which can get a bit graphic - claws and fangs are brutal weapons, after all). And Schrefer ("Rescued," "Endangered") has created a stock of memorable characters - including Gogi, a monkey with self-esteem issues; Rumi, a delightfully urbane tree frog; and a manic, pixiedream bat named Lima - that bodes well for a series in which each consecutive volume will be told from the perspective of a different animal. Kamilla Benko's debut, "The Unicorn Quest," another first-in-series novel, sneaks a tribalism parable into a Narniaesque story structure. The book begins with two sisters, Claire and Sophie, exploring the eerie old mansion of their recently deceased great-aunt, so you know it's only a matter of time before they discover a portal to another world. The fantasy kingdom of Arden is a place where magic is intrinsically tied to art, but rather than its citizens finding unity in their shared abilities, they have segregated themselves, geographically and culturally, into four different mini-nations: Forgers (who sculpt mystical metals), Spinners (who can weave threads into man-eating carpets and such), Tillers (who would all score an A+ on a Hogwarts herbology exam) and Gemmers (who have power over rocks and jewels). And it's more extreme than just Blue State-Red State rancor. The Ardenites are hard core about these divisions: One young character's father was executed because of her parents' mixed marriage. Some of the groups will grudgingly do business with one another, but for the most part, Arden is isolationism run amok. And no group is more universally reviled than the Gemmers, the former ruling class who infamously committed atrocities against their own people. When one character discovers ancestors in the Gemmer bloodline, the reaction has the horror of a progressive activist who learns there are slave owners in his family tree. It's the appearance of Claire and Sophie that serves as a catalyst for change in Arden. When the girls uncover a dangerous conspiracy, it will once again take members from different magical guilds to unite as a team and prevent the resurrection of a legendary queen. (Different queen, this time - no ants.) Benko does a stellar job of painting Arden for the reader (the battlements on a castle are "cut like jack-o'lantern teeth," for instance) and clearly delineates the distinct cultural elements of the different guilds, like the smoke-scented streets of a Forger town and the vinecoated walls of a Tiller home. Also clear is how much more wonderful this world would be if these cultures were ever allowed to mingle. The true heart of this book, though, is the relationship between Sophie and Claire. Sophie, the older and bolder of the two sisters, has recently recovered from a mysterious illness and lengthy hospital stay, leaving Claire to both hero-worship her older sibling and fret about her like a helicopter parent. And when the sisters find themselves separated, it is Claire's dedication to and need for her older sibling that drives her on her quest. Rather than pitting groups against one another, Catherine Gilbert Murdock ("Dairy Queen," "Princess Ben") presents an anti-discrimination tale with a much more individual focus in her Dark Ages fable, "The Book of Boy." The central character, known only as Boy, lives a life harder than most, which is saying a lot, since the story is set during the Black Death. In addition to all the standard hardships you'd expect for an impoverished medieval orphan, Boy must also endure being the constant target of rage, ridicule and fear. Terms like "thing," "fiend," "monster" and "hunchback" are thrown at him regularly. Saddest of all, Boy takes these insults to heart. Despite the sweetness and selflessness that is so obvious to the reader, Boy thinks of himself as a mistake - something made "wrong" - and wishes for nothing more than to be a "real boy." Then along comes Secundus, an ersatz pilgrim with a mysterious past who recruits the naive and overly trusting Boy to assist him in liberating (i.e., "stealing") holy relics so he can use them as a bargaining chip to get into heaven. (The book is firmly rooted in Christian lore.) Secundus is the first person to recognize that there's more to Boy than the hump between his shoulders - like preternatural agility and the apparent ability to communicate with animals. The adventure the two embark on features thrilling chases, many comic observations from Boy (a sheep, for instance, described as a "wet, smelly cloud"), and more fart references than one might expect in a religious allegory. And the climactic revelation of Boy's true nature is a genuinely surprising twist. But "The Book of Boy" runs into pitfalls. Readers who feel bullied or excluded for being "different" may heavily invest in Boy's internal debate over whether to hide his true self. This goes double for kids with disabilities or those who are gender nonconforming, as those are two specific points about which Boy is taunted. Unfortunately, the artistically ambiguous ending gives no explicit answer to the question. While Boy ultimately learns to love himself for who he is, we never quite get the assurance that anyone else in his cruel world will. Will Boy have to be content with a future in which he can be his real self only in private? It's open to interpretation. Yet surely many kids could benefit from having this answer spelled out for them. Perhaps the main lesson here is to remember that one person's uplifting finale can be a major downer to someone else. CHRISTOPHER HEALY is the author of the "Hero's Guide to Saving Your Kingdom," its sequels and the upcoming middle grade series Perilous Journey.
Copyright (c) The New York Times Company [February 11, 2018]
Review by Booklist Review
*Starred Review* The first book in an exciting new series, this takes readers into the world of Arden, where, once upon a time, magic thrived, people of all trades mixed and worked together, and unicorns roamed. Then war between the various magical guilds raged, and all the unicorns were lost, save one, which was turned to stone (according to legend, anyway). Hundreds of years later, enter Claire and Sophie Martinson, who, like Lucy and her siblings in Lewis' classic, find their way to this magical, Narnia-like world through an old house full of unusual artifacts, and are quickly drawn into conflicts within Arden. When older, bolder Sophie disappears, it's up to shy and careful 11-year-old Claire to find her sister and bring her back home. Benko's debut ends in an excellent cliff-hanger bridging directly into the plot of the forthcoming second book in the series. The vivid world building and memorable characters add to the fantasy allure, while some truly touching moments of friendship and sisterhood give this story a great deal of heart. Fans of magic and fantasy, especially those who love Madeleine L'Engle's A Wrinkle in Time (1962) or the darker, creepy atmosphere in Neil Gaiman's Coraline (2002), can't miss this debut.--Pino, Kristina Copyright 2017 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by School Library Journal Review
Gr 5-8-A magical story of two sisters, Claire and Sophie, who enter a fantastic land named Arden. While exploring their new home in Windemere Manor, Claire and Sophie discover a land in the heat of battle. The people in charge of magic are fighting and the revered unicorns are missing, all while terrifying creatures called wraiths haunt the land. The sisters sense danger and decide to return home. The true adventure begins when Sophie disappears one night and Claire must return to Arden to find her. Benko crafts fully developed characters and a detailed fantastical world. Though the plot is reminiscent of many of magical fantasy adventure, the suspense and sisterly bonds will keep readers hooked. VERDICT A solid start to a new -series. Hand to readers who love Narnia.-April Sanders, Spring Hill College, Mobile, AL © Copyright 2017. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Horn Book Review
When Claire follows her sister Sophie up a ladder into a chimney, she emerges in the fantasy domain of Arden; there, a harp made of unicorn mane is missing, and Sophie is suspected of the theft--or is someone using the harp to resurrect the last unicorn? Despite derivative world-building and unclear stakes, Claire is an earnest heroine whose transformation by books end is well earned. (c) Copyright 2018. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Unity in Arden died with the queen and the unicorns. As a new war threatens to fracture the land, a girl races to rescue her sister and return home.Eleven-year-old white girl Claire Martinson doesn't trust the mysterious ladder in the fireplace of Great-Aunt Diana's mansion, but when her older sister, Sophie (also white), disappears, Claire chases after her into the magical land up the chimney. However, Claire isn't the only one searching for her willful sister. Anvil Malchain, a dangerous treasure hunter, seeks Sophie tooand the unicorn artifact she might have stolen. The four guilds of ArdenTillers, Forgers, Spinners, and Gemmersall covet the unicorn artifacts that strengthen their magic. With the help of Nett, a Tiller with light brown skin, and Sena, a white Forger exile, Claire must rescue Sophie before a new war begins. In this debut, Benko constructs a world with a complex history and no clear divides between good and evil; Claire discovers that the legends of Arden's last war don't tell the whole truth. Despite Claire's envy of Sophie's bravery (and easy-to-ponytail straight hair), she rises to overcome her insecurities and unlock her own power to save the people she loves in a satisfying hero's journey. Readers will be pleased to know more adventures in Arden are planned.Rich worldbuilding and high stakes make this a quest worth taking with a protagonist who grows by facing her fears. (Fantasy. 8-12) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
