Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
If Muppet Babies is making a comeback, why not Mulder and Scully rebooted as kids? In this picture book riff on The X-Files, Fox and Dana are best buddies having a backyard campout, fulfilling the same roles they did in the cult TV series: Fox thinks aliens are everywhere, and Dana's quick to debunk (a "terrifying shadow" is actually the family dog, etc.). Smith, who previously adapted Home Alone into a picture book, gives her pictures the energy and framings of TV animation, and she believably evokes actors David Duchovny and Gillian Anderson as children, particularly where their characters' distinctive hairstyle are concerned. In Fox's defense, aliens do turn up-sharp readers will note the UFO hovering in the sky on the book's title spread. But adult X-Files fans hoping to get their offspring hooked may be disappointed: the dialogue is standard issue, and the big closing twist is little more than the narrative equivalent of "Boo!" If there is indeed a version of The X-Files for kids that captures the spirit of the show, it's still out there. Ages 4-8. (Aug.) © Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Horn Book Review
Elliott and siblings hide their new extraterrestrial friend until he can find a way home(E.T.). A young Dana Scully and scaredy-cat friend Fox Mulder encounter aliens while backyard camping (X-Files). Nostalgic parents will most enjoy these bland pop-culture picture books, a retelling of the classic eighties film and a takeoff on characters from the nineties sci-fi show. Smith's slick art cartoonishly depicts the iconic characters. [Review covers these Pop Classics titles: E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial and The X-Files.] (c) Copyright 2018. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
The truth is out therebut will Dana and Fox find it?Young Dana and Fox are camping out in the backyard. Just as Dana finishes reading from a book called The X-Files, there's a blinding light outside their tent. The kids investigate, but it's only the floodlight. Fox sees a terrifying alien-shaped shadowbut it's just Buster the dog trying to get a squirrel. Giant footprint? Dana explains it's the start of a new swimming pool. A horrifying sound from beyond the fence? The duo investigates the dark woods with Buster and discover it's just an old tire swing and an owl. Dana assures Fox that UFO talk is "crazy" talk, but neither sees the crashed flying saucer in the shadows or the giant, reptilian ET following them down the path. Back at the tent, they unzip the flap and find two tiny green ETs reading their books! The two white, human kids scream and run inside, while the two green extraterrestrial kids scream and run for the woods. Dana and Fox run up the stairs past parents watching TVbut are those really Dana's parents? Rekulak's envisioned sleepover between the two future paranormal investigators is impossible in the mythos of The X-Files, as Mulder and Scully didn't meet until adulthood, a liberty that may well drive the adult fans who are the natural audience for this book up the wall. Smith's digitally created, enticingly spooky cartoon illustrations help to tell the story, the text of which is set entirely in speech bubbles (the ET script is an amusing touch). Kids won't know the characters' back story (front story?) and fans may balk, but the tale, familiar in its broad outlines, may still entertain. Even the branding may not be enough to entice readers. (Picture book. 4-8) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
