Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
This second collaboration between Stine and Brown, after The Little Shop of Monsters, turns on one of the oldest jokes: boys hate being kissed by girls. Mary McScary, who "has fun scaring dogs" and "likes to scare goldfish, too," is primed to frighten her Cousin Harry. But sweet-natured Harry-he's essentially Brown's Arthur without the self-doubt-is so at home in the world that when Mary unleashes an angry gorilla, an asphyxiating snake, and a hungry hippo on him, he instantly establishes a relationship with all three creatures. It takes Mary's weaponized kiss-proffered with the girliest of puckers-to send Harry fleeing in horror. Brown's generous sense of scale plays up his pictures' lush textures and bold palette, and few artists are his match when it comes to making good-heartedness a compelling character trait. But there's no real tension: Mary is a one-dimensional brat (her last words are "I told you I was scary!"), and seeing the game-for-anything Harry bolt, even if a not-unreasonable reaction, feels stale. Ages 4-8. (Aug.) © Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review
PreS-Gr 2-In this their second picture book collaboration, Stine and Brown introduce Mary McScary. Mary delights in scaring everyone but can't find a way to frighten her cousin Harry, so she pulls out all the stops when he comes to visit. Giant spiders, a ferocious gorilla, slimy snakes, a hungry hippo-Mary moans in despair as each dastardly deed backfires. Harry cuddles with the spiders, rides the gorilla, hugs the snakes, and tickles the hippo. Just when it seems like the red-haired fiend will give up, Mary concocts her most devious scheme yet: a kiss! With a long scream, Harry flees, and Mary reminds readers why she is truly scary. Brown's collage illustrations are the real showstopper in this cute, if slightly predictable, story. Mary's expressive close-ups, especially her evil mastermind realization that leads to Harry's downfall, perfectly capture her terrifying charm without plunging the story into depths too spooky. Bright, bold colors stretch across the pages, and Brown's inclusion of famous artwork on the walls, such as Edvard Munch's The Scream, is a subtle nod to the macabre. Stine's use of repetition and patterning makes this an ideal choice for sharing aloud with children, and Harry's humorous responses to Mary's scares allows it to be a gentle choice for younger audiences. VERDICT A first purchase holiday selection for school and public libraries.-Rachel Zuffa, Racine Public Library, WI © Copyright 2017. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Horn Book Review
Mary McScary can scare everyone around--except her cousin Harry. Mary throws increasingly large (and dangerous) animals at Harry, but he befriends every creature instead. There's nothing left to do but kiss him ("EEEEEEEEK!"). Stine shows his horror-humor skills, though the repetition grows a bit wearying. Brown's illustrations humorously balance the everyday elements with the creature-feature details. (c) Copyright 2018. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Mary McScary takes her name very seriously, but will she manage to scare her unscarable cousin Harry? The cover illustration embodies Mary's personality: flaming red hair in braided pigtails, an obviously unique sense of style, and quirked mouth and slanted eyebrows signaling her determination. Even the white girl's stance speaks volumes: arms flung out to open a set of double doors, legs widely spaced. The thought of tangling with Mary might bring to adult readers' minds the boy from O. Henry's "Ransom of Red Chief." Indeed, Mary lives to scare, and she practices her art on her family members and pets at every opportunity. But she has yet to scare Harry, who has come for a visit. Will her hairiest monster costume work? A gorilla or jarful of spiders? What about snakes or a hippo? All fail. But just when Harry believes Mary's pronouncement that she's quit, she turns to him to admit defeat and puckers up. That sends him running away screaming! Brown's illustrations just may be the bane of parents everywhere, as they are a trove of ideas for mischief-making young readers. Mary's cat is especially expressive, and adults will chuckle at some of the artwork on the wall. Readers should indeed heed Stine's repeated refrain and "Beware of Mary McScary!" (Picture book. 3-7) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
