Review by New York Times Review
Lockhart, whose last novel was the smash "We Were Liars," says there were "many, many" inspirations for this thriller, but the one that shouts the loudest is Patricia Highsmith's "The Talented Mr. Ripley." "Genuine Lraud" changes that book's game in significant ways. It flips the genders of its characters - striving, turbulent Tom Ripley is now striving, turbulent 18-year-old Jule West Williams - and it unspools the plot backward, which becomes unexpectedly poignant when, after a horrific moment, Lockhart writes of Jule: "She wished it could be undone." Still, "Genuine Lraud" reads like a "Ripley" retelling, not just in the broad strokes (a delusional con artist looking for a way to feel loved, wanted and wealthy) but in many particulars (an oar used as a club). Your reaction to it will depend largely on how you feel about the fact that Jule is a psychopath - and that she's targeting the bratty rich. "Genuine Lraud" is a disquieting book, one built craftily enough to reward repeat readings. But your longing for an interesting sympathetic character may get desperate as the story speeds back to its beginning. In its fascination with dark corners, "Genuine Lraud" also evokes Gillian Llynn's "Gone Girl." That novel was about someone monstrous victimizing someone awful, yet the heroine's murderousness came with a riveting, blazingly articulated rage. Lockhart's Jule is unnerving, but she's not quite unforgettable.
Copyright (c) The New York Times Company [October 15, 2017]
Review by Booklist Review
*Starred Review* It's difficult to describe Lockhart's latest psychological thriller without dipping into spoilers, but here are the pertinent details: Jule, a peripatetic, athletic, superhero-obsessed teen girl is best friends with rich, restless Imogen, who recently committed suicide. When readers meet Jule, she's lounging at a tony resort in Mexico, eating junk food, and enjoying the sun. It's clear she's on the run, though from whom or why isn't clear, and Lockhart strings readers along with a clever narrative gambit. In a clipped, detached tone, Lockhart tells Jule's story in reverse, and with each step backward, she peels away juicy layers of intrigue. As the relationship between Jule and Imogen comes into focus, Lockhart explores themes of jealousy, loyalty, privilege, and origins. Imogen, who was adopted, is fixated on the idea of feeling a strong sense of identity, while Jule constantly relies on an unlikely story to explain her childhood. But can they really know each other at all? It's a captivating, suspenseful story made all the more bewitching by Lockhart's twisty narrative, and she constantly keeps readers guessing with unpredictable turns and eye-opening reveals. This quietly unsettling, cinematic novel is deliciously suspenseful, and while it's slim, it packs a real punch. Teens who love to hate antiheroes will be enraptured. HIGH-DEMAND BACKSTORY: Best-selling Lockhart's getting a top-shelf marketing campaign, so be prepared for an onslaught of fans eager to get their hands on her latest.--Hunter, Sarah Copyright 2017 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Lockhart blends the privileged glamour of We Were Liars with a twisty, backward-running plot that's slick with cinematic violence. Calling to mind her own The Disreputable History of Frankie Landau-Banks, she offers a shrewd critique of the roles traditionally available to female characters in literature and film. This striking exploration of the nature of identity revolves around the relationship between Jule and Immie, two similar-looking orphans. Jule-a fierce physical fighter and self-taught expert at disguise-will do whatever it takes to escape her bleak past. Wealthy and charismatic Immie, by contrast, wafts pleasantly through life, living on Martha's Vineyard while taking time off from college. Pushed into Immie's privileged inner circle via a case of mistaken identity, Jule is swept into an intense friendship-and a series of events that play intentional tribute to Patricia Highsmith's The Talented Mr. Ripley, among other literary precedents. A bracing pace, a slew of far-flung locations, and a storyline that runs mostly in reverse will keep readers on their toes, never entirely sure of what these girls are responsible for or capable of. Ages 12-up. Agent: Elizabeth Kaplan, Elizabeth Kaplan Agency. (Sept.) © Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review
Gr 9 Up-Jule West Williams is "the kind of woman it would be a great mistake to underestimate." Her background might be imagined, but the self-assessment is exact. Her invented 10-year "highly unusual education"-not unlike the epic journeys of white hetero heroes, which she both disdains and aspires to-allows her to go anywhere, do anything, even be anyone. Identity drives Lockhart's latest as she reveals the unlikely best friendship of two (sort of) orphans: untethered Jule and wealthy Immie, whose adoptive parents have bestowed her millions. Now Immie is dead by suicide, and only Jule seems to know what happened. Although this title is intended for YA readers, grown-ups-especially fans of unreliable narrators such as Margaret Atwood's The Robber Bride, Patricia Highsmith's "Mr. Ripley" series, and Gillian Flynn's Gone Girl-will relish this international chase. One notable annoyance: Culebra is part of Puerto Rico, which means "American dollars" is the expected currency. VERDICT For reliable gratification, choose the page and avoid Rebecca Soler's clumsy attempts at Jule's multiple accents. That Jule's chameleonic abilities are fundamental to the plot distracts from the rest of Soler's otherwise capable narration.-Terry Hong, Smithsonian BookDragon, Washington, DC © Copyright 2017. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Can Jule recognize her own true self within the tangled story of the past year? Jule West Williams is 18, white, and an orphan, all of which she has in common with her best friend, heiress Imogen Sokoloffor does she? Jule, an impulsive, complicated protagonist like no other, tells her story as though she were living in an adventure movie. She imagines herself a heroine in contrast to the "great white hetero hero on his fucking epic journey." She's proud of her strength and fighting ability, her talents for disguises and imitating accents. Outside of her fantasy life, she feels inferior to practically everyoneImmie and her boyfriend, Forrest, as well as Immie's parents and friends from college. Starting the book with Chapter 18 and the instruction "Begin here," Jule traces a year backward, revealing startling secrets along the way. The fast-paced plot moves among New York, London, California, and Mexico as Jule stays one step ahead of those who've underestimated her skills. Jule's intense narrative frequently includes clipped snatches of dialogue with herself: "No, she had. / No, she hadn't. / She wished she had not. / She wished it could be undone." Her unsettling storytelling, filled with energy and a fair amount of violence, comes from deep inside her own mysterious background. This thriller from the author of We Were Liars (2014) will challenge preconceptions about identity and keep readers guessing. (Suspense. 12-adult) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.