Review by Booklist Review
Some readers may find themselves wishing that Pötzsch would wrap things up for Princess Agnes and pauper Mathis sooner rather than later or maybe, contrary to history, let the peasants win the war for brevity's sake. While there's some hearty action in this nearly 700-page historical epic fleeing in the woods, evil men raping and pillaging, and a sweet romance winding throughout there's also repetition, a lagging pace, and credulity-stretching coincidences. The main story of Trifels Castle and the German Peasants' War (1524-25), with appearances by a few historical figures and accurate details of medieval life and weaponry, is quite fascinating. What doesn't work as well is the combination of historical fiction and classic folktale, with its quest, endangered princess, hero testing, magic objects and visions, and evil villain (Count Friedrich von Löwenstein-Scharfeneck). Surprisingly, the author omits the gallows humor and easy affection between characters that make his Hangman's Daughter series uniquely engaging. The story reads like Princess Bride with serious pirates, or The Count of Monte Cristo meets Snow White. Not Pötzsch's best but entertaining nonetheless.--Baker, Jen Copyright 2016 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
It's 1524 in what is now Germany, and 16-year-old countess Lady Agnes, daughter of the castellan of Trifels Castle, loves nothing more than eschewing dresses and spending time with her falcon, Percival. Meanwhile, her dear friend, 17-year-old Mathis Weilenbach, is fascinated by the possibilities presented by gunpowder, and he's not afraid to experiment. When Agnes finds a ring attached to Percival's foot, she's mystified and determined to find out where it came from. Her confidant, Father Tristan, seems to know something relevant but is hesitant to share it. Soon, Mathis is caught up in a rebellion that's fueled by peasants tired of struggling when nobles and the clergy drape themselves in finery. He's horrified by the bloodshed and, along with Agnes, goes on the run. Pötzsch (The Hangman's Daughter) packs a dizzying amount into this hefty novel, which spans two years: battles, romance, rebellion, jailbreaks, robber knights, treasure hunts, and above all, a heroine who is not afraid to defy her station or the constraints of her gender. Historical fans will find much to love in the immersive worldbuilding and fully realized characters. (July) © Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
As the early-16th-century Peasants' War tears Palatinate Germany apart, Ptzsch (The Werewolf of Bamber, 2015, etc.) follows a young noblewoman's epic quest, sparked by a signet ring once owned by the legendary BarbarossaFrederick I, Holy Roman Emperor.Agnes, preferring falconry to needlepoint, is the teenage daughter of Philipp von Erfenstein, Trifels Castle's knight castellan. Her best friend is Mathis, son of Trifels' blacksmith. Adventures begin when Agnes' falcon, Parcival, returns from hunting, Barbarossa's ring tied to his talons. Simultaneously, the countryside is beset by bandits led by Black Hans, a rogue knight. Since Mathis is fascinated with firearms and can work alchemy with gunpowder, von Erfenstein charges him with building a cannon to destroy Black Hans' fortress. Ptzsch's tale thereafter spins off in multiple directions. As Barbarossa's ring sparks visions of past lives, Agnes is forced to marry a dastardly count, then she's captured by camp-following white slavers and forced to loot battlefield corpses. Mathis is shanghaied into gunsmithing for peasant rebels led by a diabolical hunchback. After battles, imprisonment, and wounds, the pair reunites, learning that Barbarossa's ring is linked to secrets hidden at a monastery. Central casting provides a wise old priest; a minstrel knight with surprisingly wicked sword skills; a merciless assassin dressed all in black; and dozens of distinctive bit players. The dialogue is offered in modern syntax, sometimes slipping into anachronisms, but Ptzsch paints picturesque landscapes, whether it's damp, dark castles, the stink of a medieval tannery, or whirlpool-plagued Rhine River rapids, and offers esoteric information about arquebuses, falconets, landsknecht mercenaries, the Holy Lance, and a synopsis of the Hohenstaufen and Habsburg aristocracies.Combine Princess Bride with Germanic history circa 1500, add a dash of Lord of the Rings, and there's a week of good fun in this 600-page-plus tome. Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.