Review by Booklist Review
*Starred Review* Watching a relative change as a result of dementia or Alzheimer's is difficult for anyone but especially for a child, and Levine gracefully captures such a childhood experience here. Noah loves visiting his grandparents. His grandfather wakes up singing and makes the whole day special for Noah. One year, however, Noah can see that Grandpa is different. He can't remember how to cut his toast, and even worse, one day he does not remember Noah. Evocative watercolor-and-ink illustrations make the shift evident. Fun-loving Grandpa is depicted in exuberant, cheerful colors. Targeted spots in the illustrations are rendered in gray to show small changes. Then a dramatic, two-page spread is completely black, white, and gray when Noah can no longer hope that nothing is wrong. Happily, however, there are sunny spots, when Grandpa lights up at the sounds of their songs. When Noah plays the piano or sings, Grandpa remembers and joins in. Grandma steps up to do more things with Noah and helps him understand that he must appreciate what Grandpa still has, not focus on what he's lost. Though he's missing something, he's still Grandpa. The message is beautifully and sensitively communicated in these gentle pages. A comforting, honest resource, ideal for little ones confronted with aging relatives.--Whitehurst, Lucinda Copyright 2016 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Noah's grandfather has always been boisterous and full of song, launching each day with a signature catchphrase-"What's on the docket?"-that promises nonstop fun. But this summer, Grandpa's memory is failing him, and he doesn't always recognize Noah; Kath's (More Than Enough) watercolors depict the older man with the radiance literally drained from his face. While never mentioning a specific medical condition, Grandma tells a devastated Noah that "we have to appreciate what he still has, not focus on what he's lost." As Noah comes to terms with his new relationship with Grandpa, including learning that singing can still connect them to each other, his sense of the world widens: he can have "his own docket" (acting independently in the world), as well as a docket with Grandma, who, one senses, has always been a willing second banana to her lively husband. It's a lovely, bittersweet story, and Levine (Monday Is One Day) carefully modulates a challenging emotional arc, offering readers just the right measure of hope. Ages 4-8. Author's agent: Susan Cohen, Writers House. Illustrator's agent: Justin Rucker, Shannon Associates. (Aug.) © Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by School Library Journal Review
PreS-Gr 2-Noah loves visiting his grandparents and especially spending time with Grandpa. Summer days there always begin with a "booming song" about a beautiful morning. Grandma is no morning up-and-at-'em person, so Noah and Grandpa bring her a nice cup of coffee to help her day get started. Then they go for a walk with the dog, rain or shine, singing all the way. Back home for breakfast, they make their plans and check "what's on the docket" for the day. This particular summer, however, things are different. Grandpa forgets to ask about the docket, and one morning he can't even remember how to cut his French toast. Even worse, one day Grandpa fails to recognize Noah when he wakes up from a nap. These changes are scary and make Noah very sad. Grandma tries to explain and helps Noah focus on appreciating "what [Grandpa] still has...not on what he's lost," even though that means some days Noah completes his docket all by himself. One day when Noah is playing the piano and singing loudly, Grandpa joins in, just like old times. Lunch goes pretty well, too, as Noah sings Grandpa's favorite Tuna Fish Sandwich Song. But it's not really the same anymore. So Grandma and Noah come up with a docket plan themselves while Grandpa naps. Some days for Noah and Grandpa seem like old times, and some don't, but they'll go on their walks together still, singing "as long as the song would last." Kath's charming illustrations are done in watercolor and ink. She hints at Grandpa's state of mind by changing the color of his shirt and scenery from full color to grays as the dementia takes over. The layout is easy on the eye, and the book remains child focused and upbeat. VERDICT This sweet and tender story about dealing with change and loss is suitable for sharing in a group or one-on-one. No happy ending here, but a satisfyingly realistic one all the same.-Roxanne Burg, Orange County Public Library, CA © Copyright 2016. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Horn Book Review
During Noah's visits to his grandparents' house, Grandpa is ready with a song for every occasion. But then, to Noah's dismay, Grandpa starts having episodes of forgetfulness and confusion, which are portrayed in the evocative illustrations as a gray wash stealing color from the cheerful scene. The poignant story balances sadness with courage, as Grandma helps them both make the best of the situation. (c) Copyright 2017. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
When old age takes its toll on Grandpa's memory, Noah learns to value every moment with him.Noah's summer days with Grandpa are full of fun activities. They boom out a loud song together as they make morning coffee. More songs fill the air as they walk the dog before breakfast; when they return home, they get to eat Grandma's special cinnamon French toast. One morning, Grandpa forgets how to cut his French toast and can't remember who Noah is. Noah runs out of the house, a painful lump in his throat. Fortunately, Grandma is able to explain that Grandpa gets confused sometimes. "We have to appreciate what he still has." Noah goes ahead, walking the dog by himself, feeding the birds, and plunking out one of Grandpa's favorite tunes on the piano. Grandpa suddenly appears, his bright old self, singing the song at the top of his lungs. Levine treats his sensitive subject with simple pathos. Kath depicts a loving white trio; Noah's parents are not in evidence, letting readers imagine either that he is a regular overnight visitor or that he lives with his grandparents. She uses color subtly, graying her movement-filled line-and-watercolor paintings for those moments when Grandpa forgets and filling them with color when he remembers. Readers who also find themselves with cognitively failing loved ones would do well to heed Noah's wisdom as he plans "to go for as long as the song would last."Both lovely and deeply empathetic. (Picture book. 5-7) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
