Review by New York Times Review
IN HER DEBUT NOVEL, "The Yonahlossee Riding Camp for Girls," Anton DiSclafani explored the constraints of female sexuality and social class at the dawn of the Great Depression, through the experiences of Southern debutantes at an equestrian boarding school. Her sophomore effort, "The After Party," revisits these themes as they play out in the lives of 1950s Houston socialites. Materially speaking, the young, pampered housewives of River Oaks want for nothing. Dresses are flown in from New York. Chauffeurs and champagne are ever at the ready. The story centers on the lifelong friendship between two members of this privileged set. Joan Fortier, the unmarried daughter of a wealthy oilman, is promiscuous, untamable, a fixture of the local gossip columns. She drinks too much and refuses to settle down, pay attention to the latest styles or shower before going out for the evening. The book's narrator, Cece Buchanan, is more conventional - essentially orphaned as a teenager when her mother died (they were abandoned by her father), she is now married with a son who, at age 3, doesn't yet speak. Cece is deeply invested in her wardrobe and home décor. Her name calls to mind Daisy Buchanan, that epitome of a woman adrift in a sea of American excess. DiSclafani excels at building suspense and has a gift for revealing private worlds through unexpected, telling details. Joan's father "believed in divine providence, the way that lucky men often do." Joan's mother advises her to sit up straight: "Spines are very suggestible." Cece describes herself as "a girl with a forgettable face, a forgettable name. But I was saved from this fate because I was Joan's best friend." Later, she says, "Without Joan, I would have been just another girl, with none of Joan's radiance to claim as my own. Because I wasn't radiant. I wasn't anything, without Joan." To a degree, her devotion feels misplaced and one-sided. Joan doesn't confide in Cece about the many mysteries of her life (a yearlong disappearance after high school, the shadowy stranger she's been spending time with), even as Cece obsessively tries to figure them out. Their relationship jeopardizes Cece's marriage and consumes Cece's thoughts far more than her son's condition does. Everything in her world is viewed through the lens of Joan. One flashback to their teenage years goes a ways toward explaining why. It's a great dramatic moment that had me holding my breath, but it strains to account for the odd dynamic that plays out between them for the next decade. Cece is particularly preoccupied with policing Joan's sex life. Once, driven to a point of near madness by a desire to save Joan from her own bad choices, Cece follows her into a hotel room, saying, "Sid and Joan might have been in there together, having sex, but I didn't care." Joan, though, doesn't appear to want or need saving. As things progress, Cece seems more like an infatuated stalker than a devoted friend. Perhaps that's the point, but we never get enough of Cece's inner life to fully understand it. DiSclafani dangles suggestions about the sexual undertone of Cece's compulsion and the notion that within a friendship "one woman always needs the other woman less." A deeper exploration of these intriguing motivations would have made the book all the richer. Instead, there are only hints about why Cece would rather focus on Joan's life than her own: her complicated relationship with Joan's parents after her mother dies; the anxiety of dealing with a sick child ; the monotony and emptiness of her days, or as Betty Friedan described it in "The Feminine Mystique," "the problem that has no name." One wonders what Cece might make of that call to arms, published a few short years after the story ends. Within a friendship 'one woman always needs the other woman less.' J. COURTNEY SULLIVAN is the author of the novels "Commencement," "Maine" and "The Engagements."
Copyright (c) The New York Times Company [June 5, 2016]
Review by Booklist Review
*Starred Review* DiScalafani (The Yonahlossee Riding Camp for Girls, 2013) follows up her debut best-seller with another spellbinding historical novel, this time set in 1950s Texas. Cece and Joan have been best friends since kindergarten, growing up in the tony Houston neighborhood of River Oaks, saturated with oil money, marching toward the inevitable: debutante balls, women's college, Junior League, suitable marriages, and lives of respectable luxury. Narrated by Cece from an unspecified present day, The After Party is a lushly written novel of a symbiotic friendship. Cece's recollections of her relationship with the beautiful, rebellious socialite Joan over the years reveal the depths of her obsession. Cece has defined her own life in terms of her proximity to Joan, to the detriment of her own once happy marriage, fixed in place by a dark secret from their shared girlhood. The thick and clingy atmosphere, peppered with meticulously detailed descriptions of the day-to-day concerns of the midcentury moneyed class in Texas, paints an alluring portrait of the alcohol-soaked, seedy reality of high society, roiling just beneath the placid veneer of mannered respectability. Deliberate pacing and the hypnotic quality of DiScalafani's writing will entrance readers as the novel slowly burns toward a series of shocking revelations. Literary fans as well as those who enjoy historical and women's fiction will be delighted.--Szwarek, Magan Copyright 2016 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
DiSclafani's second novel, following The Yonahlossee Riding Camp for Girls, is an intriguing story about the complexities of female friendship and the intricate social hierarchy of Houston's oil elite in the 1950s. In a world focused on glamor and status, Joan Fortier has always been the center of attention, but no one loves her as much as her best friend, Cece. Friends since age five, Joan and Cece share a complicated past. Told from Cece's perspective, the narrative cuts back and forth between 1957, when they're in their mid-20s, and their adolescence, when Joan seems set up for the kind of privileged existence that Cece once assumed they both wanted-marriage, a family, and fancy parties. However, Joan seems to want more. To Cece, Joan seems vibrant and free, but it's not until later that she realizes no woman in this particular society, not even Joan, can completely escape the social limitations imposed by gender. The narrative sometimes succumbs to stereotypes, but the social milieu-and the attitudes that these women alternately embrace and rebel against-is vivid, and the relationship between Joan and Cece becomes increasingly compelling as the story progresses, resulting in a most memorable read. Agent: Dorian Karchmar, WME Entertainment. (May) © Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Library Journal Review
Houston socialites and BFFs Cece -Buchanan and Joan Fortier have been the toast of River Oaks since their preschool days. With the 1950s in full swing and the girls in high school, Cece comes to live with the Fortiers after her mother dies. She acts as defender and constant companion for the willful, hard-partying Joan. When Joan abruptly skips the debutante ball to seek stardom in Hollywood, Cece is devastated but forges new friendships and begins dating her future husband, Ray. When Joan blows back into Houston, mysterious beau in tow and ready to step back into the Shamrock Hotel party scene, Cece senses that Joan is carrying secrets. As she adopts a predictable upper-class life of marriage, motherhood, and garden-club luncheons, can Cece balance Joan's burdens with her own? Best-selling author DiSclafani (The Yonahlossee Riding Camp for Girls) paints a compelling picture of the ups and downs of longstanding female friendship set against the excesses and restraints of the Mad Men era. -VERDICT Readers' opinions will vary on whether the revelation of Joan's dark secret is satisfying, but such strongly wrought characters and attention to period setting and mores should enthrall most fan of novels of intricate relationships and society such as those by Mary McCarthy, -Rebecca Wells, Fannie Flagg, and Jill Connor Brown. [See Prepub Alert, 11/2/15.]- Jennifer B. -Stidham, Houston Community Coll. © Copyright 2016. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.