Review by New York Times Review
SHADRACH VOLES, UPCHUCK GNOMES, Rockhard Scones and Blowback Foams: None of these great made-up detectives appear in Otto Penzler's giant compendium of fake Sherlock Holmes stories, or Sherlock-Holmes-stories-written-by-persons-other-than-Sir-Arthur-Conan-Doyle. You will, however, be able to find stories about Sherlaw Kombs, and Solar Pons, and Picklock Holes, and Shamrock Jolnes, and Warlock Bones and (my own pick of the pseudo-Holmeses) Hemlock Jones, who in Bret Harte's "The Stolen Cigar-Case" almost destroys the ardently worshipful Watson-like narrator with the sheer puissance of his intellect. On Hemlock Jones's shelves are glass jars containing "pavement and road sweepings" and "fluff from omnibus and road-car seats." When he thinks, his head shrinks, "so much reduced in size by his mental compression that his hat tipped back from his forehead and literally hung on his massive ears." Jones's diamond-encrusted cigar case, a present from the Turkish ambassador, has gone missing. There can be only one culprit: the narrator himself! Jones lays out the case, deduction by damning deduction. "So overpowering was his penetration," declares the narrator in a fit of purest proto-Kafka, "that although I knew myself innocent, I licked my lips with avidity to hear the further details of this lucid exposition of my crime." We in 2015, we the entertained, who live in a fun house of Sherlocks - Cumberbatch Sherlock, Downey Jr. Sherlock, Jonny Lee Miller Sherlock, etc. - need no convincing of the imaginative vitality of Sherlock Holmes. But the fact that Bret Harte, revered and shaggy forebear, of whose stories Conan Doyle felt his own early efforts to be but "feeble echoes," could come out in 1900 with such a spot-on and beautifully modern satire of a Sherlock Holmes story tells us something of the immediacy with which Holmes franchised himself into popular consciousness. He quickly overcame his creator, of course: Having plunged Holmes - for good, it seemed - into the Reichenbach Falls in the fatal embrace of his shadow-self, Moriarty, in 1893's "The Final Problem," Conan Doyle found himself, 10 years later, rewriting his own story. "We tottered together upon the brink of the fall," Holmes explains to a not unreasonably astonished Watson in 1903's "The Adventure of the Empty House." "I have some knowledge, however, of baritsu, or the Japanese system of wrestling, which has more than once been very useful to me. I slipped through his grip." Slippery, unkillable Holmes! What's his secret? In a sense Holmes is the perfect literary creation: a caricature with depth. A few quick strokes - pipe, brain, violin, Watson - call him into being, while beyond these scant markings an abyss of personality instantly suggests itself. Dimensions open up, speculation is invited, and what Tolkien called "subcreation" occurs: People begin to tell their own stories about him. There's his tragic side, the paradoxically romantic ennui that arises from his being such a brilliant micro-materialist, knowing everything about train timetables and typography and trousers but finding himself lonely, so lonely, in this suddenly atomic and demystified universe. He reaches for his drugs, he scrapes at his violin; he shoots holes in the walls of his apartment. Around him, invisibly, a vast cerebral plexus shimmers and twangs. Then there's his fantastic and inexhaustible yin-yang buddy-movie Quixote-Panza double act with John H. Watson, M.D., whose awe-struck narrations keep Holmes at one remove from us, the human race. A pastiche is a form of literary criticism, as a tribute band is a form of rock criticism. There were things I didn't understand about Bon Jovi, for example, until I saw, in a bar in Boston, a band called Jovi. (I just Googled them, incidentally. Now they're called Bon Jersey.) So in Penzler's Big Book we find the various parodists and imitators zooming in on key elements : Stephen Leacock, in 1916, lampooning the "inexorable chain of logic" that leads Holmes to an absurd conclusion, and John Lutz, in 1987, describing a Holmes who in the absence of a good case "becomes zombielike in his withdrawal into boredom." It's all, properly defined, fan fiction, some of the fans (Stephen King, H.R.F. Keating) being quite distinguished, others less so - long-forgotten bookmen lowering themselves into the Holmesian atmosphere as into a hot bath, with many a grunt and sigh of luxury. Kingsley Amis puts on a good performance in "The Darkwater Hall Mystery" - although because he's writing for Playboy he has Watson go to bed with a servant called Dolores, "raven hair, creamy skin and deep brown eyes." I loved Neil Gaiman's elegiac and dreamlike "The Case of Death and Honey," which really breaks up the mood. Anthony Burgess's contribution to the genre, "Murder to Music," is rather too elaborate in its formalities, but it does give us a Holmes of thrilling and merciless aestheticism: "If Sarasate, before my eyes and in this very room, strangled you to death, Watson, for your musical insensitivity,... I should be constrained to close my eyes to the act,... deposit your body in the gutter of Baker Street and remain silent while the police pursued their investigations. So much is the great artist above the moral principles that oppress lesser men." Grinding our Holmesian gears slightly, let's turn now to "Mycroft Holmes," by Kareem Abdul-Jabbar and Anna Waterhouse. For outsize polymathic energy and accomplishment, Abdul-Jabbar - N.B.A. champion, cultural ambassador, author - rivals Conan Doyle himself. Of his many triumphs I will always chiefly prize the line from "Airplane!" - "We have clearance, Clarence!" - that he delivered while playing the co-pilot Roger Murdock, but that's because I know nothing about basketball. At any rate, here's his novel about Sherlock's older, fatter, cleverer brother, Mycroft - tantalizingly alluded to in the canon - who works for the British government. The idiom of "Mycroft Holmes" is genially chaotic sub-Victorian with 21st-century lapses - someone over here is "assailed" by a coughing fit, while someone over there "splurges" on a new overcoat - but the plot is a solid romp. Young Mycroft, early in his career, is dispatched to Trinidad to investigate certain grisly goings-on: missing persons, children turning up on the beach with their bodies drained of blood, that kind of thing. Mycroft is additionally in love (with the ravishing and enigmatic Georgiana) and watching with interest the development of his faintly inhuman younger brother, Sherlock, whom he tutors in deductive reasoning while administering boxing lessons. Their mother is insane. Given that Mycroft is, legendarily, a kind of database on legs, I might have made him a bit more cyber, a bit more "Terminator"-like - but Abdul-Jabbar and Waterhouse have gone another way, and the mood is very expressive. "'Whatever is the matter?' Holmes bleated. 'You must keep me apprised as we go along,' Douglas blurted out." Bleats, blurts - not quite the Holmesian vibe. But the narrative rattles along, and the plot ramifies impressively, and it's by (with Anna Waterhouse) Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, for God's sake, an extraordinary man, a novel in himself, about whose fictionalized post-C.I.A. older brother - 15 feet tall, with purring Spock-like mind - there will one day, for certain, be a book. A few quick strokes - pipe, brain, violin, Watson - call Holmes into being. JAMES PARKER is a contributing editor at The Atlantic.
Copyright (c) The New York Times Company [October 11, 2015]
Review by Booklist Review
*Starred Review* Abdul-Jabbar, a Holmesian since his college days, joins forces with Waterhouse, his cowriter on the documentary On the Shoulders of Giants, to offer a rousing mystery starring Sherlock's older (and smarter) brother, Mycroft, a rising star in the British government. The action begins in 1870 London but quickly moves to Trinidad, where Mycroft's closest friend, Cyrus Douglas, a native of the island, must travel to investigate what some believe is an infestation of douen tiny supernatural characters who lead children into the clutches of werewolf-like lougarou. Mycroft joins his friend for the trip, and what the two find on arrival after a near-fatal ocean crossing isn't supernatural but far more harrowing: an elaborate scheme to bring slavery back to the Caribbean. The authors hit all the right notes here, combining fascinating historical detail (on Trinidadian culture and folklore, on tobacco importation in London, even on the development of the Gatling gun) with rousing adventure, including some cleverly choreographed fight scenes and a pair of protagonists whose rich biracial friendship, while presented realistically, given the era (Douglas must sometimes pose as a butler), is the highlight of the book. Yes, Douglas is a sort-of Watson, but a much brighter, more physical, more bantering version, an equal not a foil. Mystery fans will be eager to hear more from this terrific duo, who may well develop into a gaslit version of Robert B. Parker's Spenser and Hawk.--Ott, Bill Copyright 2015 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Basketball legend Abdul-Jabbar (On the Shoulders of Giants) makes his triumphant adult fiction debut with an action yarn that fills in the backstory of Sherlock Holmes's older and smarter brother, Mycroft. In 1870, the 23-year-old Mycroft, who has a reputation as a daredevil, is serving as a secretary at the War Office when word reaches London of a series of unusual deaths in Trinidad. Someone, or some thing, has been killing children and draining their blood. The locals believe the culprits are supernatural beings known as lougarou, who drain children of their blood, and douen, who leave highly unusual footprints near their victims. The tragic news stuns Mycroft's fiancée, Georgiana Sutton, who immediately sails home to Trinidad. Disobeying her request to stay behind, Mycroft follows Georgiana to Trinidad, where he must exercise his intellect and his innate diplomatic skills to solve the crimes and remain alive. Sherlockians who relish the screen adventures of Cumberbatch and Downey will be particularly entertained. Agent: Deborah Morales, Iconomy. (Sept.) © Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Library Journal Review
When rumors of missing persons and mysterious footprints in the sand travel from the shores of Trinidad to the heart of London, there's only one man for the job: Mycroft Holmes. Sherlock's older brother is cutting his teeth in diplomacy and espionage as assistant to the British secretary of state for war when he and his closest friend, Trinidadian Cyrus Douglas, first hear of the eerie happenings. The men are concerned but skeptical until Holmes's fiancée, -Georgiana, a Trinidadian herself, rushes home to investigate. Douglas and Holmes quickly set a course for the island and a harrowing adventure that will forever change and define them. VERDICT Clear space on your new fiction shelf for this slam-dunk of a debut novel. Cowritten by NBA all-star and author Abdul-Jabbar (What Color Is My World?) and screenwriter and producer -Waterhouse, the team behind the NAACP and Telly Award-winning documentary On the Shoulders of Giants, this latest collaboration brings a fresh voice and broadened scope to the Holmes canon. Historical fiction and mystery fans will be the first to demand this title, but its mass appeal is undeniable. [See Prepub Alert, 5/4/15.]-Liv Hanson, Chicago © Copyright 2015. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
That's right: nonpareil basketball player Abdul-Jabbar, who's already written memoirs, nonfiction titles, and children's books (Stealing the Game, 2015, etc.), partners with screenwriter Waterhouse to introduce a prequel to the adventures of Sherlock Holmes' smarter brother. Back in 1870, when Sherlock is still an indifferent student at the Royal College of St. Peter, his older brother, a little wet behind the ears at 23, serves as secretary to Edward Cardwell, the Secretary of State for War, and looks forward to his marriage to Georgiana Sutton, a perfect English rose born in Port of Spain. His plans are knocked sideways by the hushed news from his Trinidadian friend and associate Cyrus Douglas that a lougarou, as the islanders call werewolves, has been draining the blood of young children and causing mass disappearances of their elders. Booking passage aboard the Sultana for Trinidad, the two men swiftly find themselves immersed in an unholy scheme by a ring of freelance entrepreneurs to revive a horror recently and traumatically abolished in the Americas. Even more disturbingly, every new development in the adventure, which eventually leads the visitors to the Sacred Order of the Harmonious Fists, seems to point unerringly to well-placed government functionaries and protectors and implicate someone close to Mycroft himself as a conspirator. The central conceit is audacious; Mycroft's sense of moral outrage is nicely reflective of the era; the historical detail is solid; and the period decorum is well-maintained throughout. Only the characters and their cumbersome individual interactions are muffled by all the grade-A trappings. Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
