Behind the curve Science and the politics of global warming

Joshua P. Howe

Book - 2014

"In 1958, Charles David Keeling began measuring the concentration of carbon dioxide in the earth's atmosphere at the Mauna Loa Observatory in Hawaii. His project kicked off a half century of research that has expanded our knowledge of climate change. Despite more than fifty years of research, however, our global society has yet to find real solutions to the problem of global warming. Why? In Behind the Curve, Joshua Howe attempts to answer this question. He explores the history of global warming from its roots as a scientific curiosity to its place at the center of international environmental politics. The book follows the story of rising CO2--illustrated by the now famous Keeling Curve--through a number of historical contexts, hi...ghlighting the relationships among scientists, environmentalists, and politicians as those relationships changed over time. The nature of the problem itself, Howe explains, has privileged scientists as the primary spokespeople for the global climate. But while the "science first" forms of advocacy they developed to fight global warming produced more and better science, the primacy of science in global warming politics has failed to produce meaningful results. In fact, an often exclusive focus on science has left advocates for change vulnerable to political opposition and has limited much of the discussion to debates about the science itself. As a result, while we know much more about global warming than we did fifty years ago, CO2 continues to rise. In 1958, Keeling first measured CO2 at around 315 parts per million; by 2013, global CO2 had soared to 400 ppm. The problem is not getting better - it's getting worse. Behind the Curve offers a critical and levelheaded look at how we got here.Joshua P. Howe teaches history and environmental studies at Reed College."Scientists have proven to be right about the causes of a warming planet, but they have failed to stop the warming. Stopping it involves politics and economics more than science, and in this important book Joshua Howe examines how scientists and environmentalists--although both live in intensely political worlds--have managed to get the science right and the politics wrong. This is not the usual story of heroes and villains. Howe tells a more nuanced story-- a tragedy--in which a somewhat naive faith in science rendered scientists politically impotent in a complicated world. Few books published this year will tell a more important story." - Richard White, Margaret Byrne Professor of American History, Stanford"How shall we deal with climate change? That is not just an important topic but, from the standpoint of future generations, arguably the most important of all topics. Thorough and wide-ranging, this book puts the history of global warming policy in its full political and cultural context." - Spencer Weart, author of The Discovery of Global Warming"Behind the Curve is a much-needed book on the history of climate science and politics stretching back to the immediate post-World War II period." - Mark Carey, author of In the Shadow of Melting Glaciers"--

Saved in:

2nd Floor Show me where

363.73874/Howe
1 / 1 copies available
Location Call Number   Status
2nd Floor 363.73874/Howe Checked In
Subjects
Published
Seattle : University of Washington Press [2014]
Language
English
Main Author
Joshua P. Howe (author)
Physical Description
xviii, 290 pages, 12 unnumbered pages of plates : illustrations, maps ; 24 cm
Bibliography
Includes bibliographical references and index.
ISBN
9780295993683
  • Foreword
  • Acknowledgments
  • List of Abbreviations
  • Introduction: Telling Stories about CO 2
  • 1. The Cold War Roots of Global Warming
  • 2. Scientists, Environmentalists, and the Global Atmosphere
  • 3. Making the Global Environment
  • 4. Climate, the Environment, and Scientific Activism
  • 5. The Politics of Dissent
  • 6. The IPCC and the Primacy of Science
  • 7. The Gospel of the Market
  • Epilogue: Climbing Out from Behind the Curve
  • Notes
  • Selected Bibliography
  • Index
  • Illustrations follow page
Review by Choice Review

Behind the Curve provides a historical perspective on the relationship between climate change science and politics. The title is a reference to the Keeling curve, a graphical representation of the time series of the atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration measured at the Mauna Loa Observatory in Hawaii since 1958. While the Keeling curve presents a simple scientific data set, it masks the complexity of climate change and raises questions regarding political inaction in the context of strong scientific consensus. Howe (Reed College) contends that the primacy of science in the climate change arena has hampered movement toward mitigation, mainly because the types of social and political change needed to address climate change rely little on scientific knowledge. Instead, he argues that the focus should be shifted toward economic and political considerations that will ultimately underlie any agreements to curb emissions at the scales necessary to reduce atmospheric carbon dioxide concentrations. While Mike Hulme's Why We Disagree about Climate Change (CH, Nov'09, 47-1431) similarly examines the reasons for inaction on this important issue, this book offers a great historical view of its political aspects. --Justin T. Schoof, Southern Illinois University

Copyright American Library Association, used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review

Howe, who teaches history and environmental studies at Reed College, analyzes our continually evolving "understanding of the dynamics of the global atmosphere." Since Charles David Keeling's first measurements of atmospheric CO2 at Mauna Loa in 1958, the political and practical response to his research has been slow, contentious, and complex. Despite the clear science, the primacy of science-first advocacy and its belief in the "forcing function of knowledge" has not yielded a successful response to this intractable problem, and manufactured doubt returns the question to endless cycles of research. Howe traces early disinterest in the CO2 issue by grassroots environmentalists, who felt it was nonlocal and diffuse, while pro-technology atmospheric science was tied to large government institutions and a Cold War agenda, relying on "high-tech tools of big-government science to do their jobs." Decades-long U.N. efforts to prompt a global response brought the agendas of developed and developing nations into conflict over where the responsibility to prioritize, address, and pay for changes in industrialization lay. Howe's strong insight into how individuals, institutions, and governments interact produces a fascinating yet distressing story, proving that despite its aspirations towards objectivity, applied science historically is a flawed, human tale approaching a classical tragedy. B&w illus. (Apr.) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.

(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved