Review by New York Times Review
DECEMBER IS, OF COURSE, the holiday season, but for gardeners it's also the reading season. In the garden, we play out fantasies, desires and longings, and the ensuing tussle with nature - sometimes gentle, sometimes violent - is for a beauty we can make. Like sex, quite a lot of gardening happens in the mind. This season, a few books that look back to the past may well stir your imagination. Marta McDowell's Beatrix potter's GARDENING LIFE: The Plants and Places That Inspired the Classic Children's Tales (Timber, $24.95) is a biography written through plants. Potter, as we know from her charming illustrated children's books, invented enormously lovable characters, from cheeky mice to naughty bunnies, all of whom inhabit a pastoral paradise that seems as vibrant as the creatures themselves. Throughout her life, Potter found not only solace but literary inspiration in Britain's fields, pastures and country gardens. During bouts of loneliness in her youth, McDowell tells us, Potter found solace "with her paintbrush and her pen." While her art was wonderfully mature even then, her life wasn't really her own until middle age. Less than two months after the death of her fiancé and just past her 39 th birthday, she bought her first house, Hill Top Farm, in the Lake District, and made her first garden. In time she found a new and lasting love. As the years passed, she became an estate farmer and an early land conservationist. In creating her country life, Potter finally inhabited the world of her children's books, a world largely free of status and class. For herself, she chose not the grand sort of garden she knew from childhood holidays but a modest cottage garden, a sentimental, neighborly sort of place where flowers sprout up among the vegetables and between the paving stones, and plants are often gifts from neighbors or "pinched" on walks. McDowell suggests that even mean Mr. McGregor, the nemesis of the veg-pilfering Peter Rabbit, isn't the owner of the kitchen garden in Potter's book. He's just a laborer struggling to do his job, wearing humble clothes as he kneels down to plant cabbage seedlings - on a footing equal to Peter's own. Beatrix Potter's studious dedication to the natural world is matched by Queen Marie-Antoinette's fantasy attachment to the same realm. The Petit Trianon, the neoclassical chateau given to his teenage wife by Louis XVI, was the ultimate richgirl fantasy: a pleasure house in which to escape the golden chains of court life. In FROM MARIE-ANTOINETTE'S GARDEN: An Eighteenth-Century Horticultural Album (Flammarion, $49.95), by Élisabeth de Feydeau, we are told that Louis was "a noted connoisseur of female flesh" who while "preferring the delights of hunting and fine food ... was a man besotted with his young wife, nonetheless." Either because he was besotted or because he wanted her out of the palace, he set her up in this house to spend her days in a milk maid's fantasy among her flowers. De Feydeau's book is organized like a herbarium, a collection of botanical paintings of the specimens found in the queen's gardens, even though Marie-Antoinette never commissioned such a project. The result is a hodgepodge of illustrations along with a grab bag of accompanying information, some of it useful, much of it not. De Feydeau is a well-known expert in the field of perfume who has previously written a book on the Versailles court perfumer. It's no surprise, then, that the most interesting tidbits are olfactory rather than horticultural: his noting, for example, that the crushed dust from iris rhizomes was used to color and scent the hair of the court's ladies. We also learn that Marie-Antoinette had bearded irises planted on the thatched roofs of the Hamlet, her faux French village built on the grounds of the chateau, an early and very attractive form of green roofing. The sleeper hit of the season is the story OF KEW GARDENS IN PHOTOGRAPHS (Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew/Arcturus/University of Chicago, $25), by Lynn Parker and Kiri Ross-Jones. The development of photography and that of the Royal Botanic Gardens happened at roughly the same time, making it possible to use this new technology to document the process by which Kew passed from royal hands to public ones, beginning in the 1840s, eventually becoming one of the most important scientific institutes and pleasure grounds in the world. Instead of presenting Kew merely as an obligatory stop on the English tourist itinerary, these photographs reveal the importance of the plants within the gardens and the global importance of Kew itself - through the prism of colonialism, trade, industry, medicine, warfare and even the values of Victorian England. Kew is a wonderful collection of, well, collections : an idiosyncratic array of buildings and follies, of characters both human and animal, of books and art and photography - and, of course, plants. It even houses a collection of opium balls, boxes to store opium and pipes with which to smoke opium, but perhaps no opium itself. Among the architectural treasures at Kew are the largest surviving Victorian glasshouse in the world as well as Sir William Chambers's chinoiserie pagoda and a rustic country-house folly that once housed exotic animals like kangaroos. In a pseudocolonial Indian red brick house are more than 800 paintings by the intrepid Victorian plant hunter Marianne North. One fascinating chapter shows how Britain's colonizing efforts opened routes for the dissemination, importation, study and cultivation of plants to and from locations as distant as Australia, Africa and India. One Kew emissary collected cinchona plants and seed in Ecuador, which were then sent to India, where they were planted and used to make quinine to treat malaria. The botanists and plant hunters of Kew were involved in the production of hemp in Africa, rubber in Singapore, coffee in Jamaica and tea in South Africa. (A remarkable illustration presents Chinese laborers carrying 300 pounds of tea bricks on their backs en route to Tibet.) AND THERE IS A FREAK SHOW of fabulous plants, like the 26-foot-high agave that had to be cut lest it damage the ceiling, and the giant coco de mer seed, which can push the scale upward of 66 pounds, collected in 1852 but not successfully germinated until the 1990s. And the gargantuan water lily species, named for the large queen herself, Victoria amazonica. Parker and RossJones give us a wonderful photograph of a young girl floating apprehensively on an eight-foot lily pad. Established at a time when leisure and nature were thought to be good influences on the working classes, the garden was seen as a useful venue for furthering the social good. Yet its director tried to keep out "pleasure or recreational seekers ... whose motives are rude rompings and games" by not permitting public facilities on the premises. Fortunately, he lost this battle. England (and the world) is the richer for it. DEBORAH NEEDLEMAN is the editor in chief of T: The New York Times Style Magazine.
Copyright (c) The New York Times Company [December 8, 2013]
Review by Booklist Review
Part of the charm and eye-delighting intricacy of Beatrix Potter's beloved children's books about such endearing and enduring characters as Peter Rabbit and Jemima Puddle-Duck are the precisely and vitally rendered illustrations of the English gardens, farms, and landscapes her characters so actively occupy. In this sumptuously illustrated gardening biography, horticultural consultant McDowell, who is fascinated by writers who garden (her first book was Emily Dickinson's Gardens, 2004), fully illuminates Potter's deep botanical knowledge and joy in cultivation. When publishers rejected her first attempt at a children's book, Potter self-published The Tale of Peter Rabbit in 1902, launching a brilliant career. When she purchased Hill Top Farm in the fabled Lake District, she set out on the path that led to her becoming an intrepid gardener, savvy landowner, sheep breeder, and conservationist, ultimately leaving thousands of pristine acres to the National Trust. With wit and expertise, McDowell highlights the stamp of Potter's horticultural know-how on her indelible books and chronicles a year in her exuberant gardens to create a visually exciting, pleasurably informative appreciation of Potter's devotion to art and nature.--Seaman, Donna Copyright 2010 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.