Review by New York Times Review
ON JULY 4, 2011, the British-born historian Simon Winchester took an oath to become an American citizen. It was a startling decision for someone Queen Elizabeth herself had made an officer of the Order of the British Empire not so long ago. Why the move? Winchester, it seems, was in love. But it wasn't a woman who captured his heart. No, Winchester had fallen for an entire nation. Winchester's self-described "love affair" with America began when he hitchhiked across the country as a footloose kid. When he finally got his passport he felt moved to write a history of the quality that most entranced him: America's improbable, at times incomprehensible, unity. How was it, he asked, that people of such wildly different backgrounds share a "near-mystical concord" - how can such an eclectic assortment of peoples "enjoy the same rights and aspirations, encapsulated in their shared ability to declare so simply, I am an American?" When people are smitten, they are blind to flaws in their beloved. Winchester is no exception, and this book is less a history than a love letter. In today's toxic political climate, the idea that Americans are united may seem laughable. But this misses Winchester's bigger and otherwise valid point: The United States endures despite its conflicts. The country remains, for all its diversity and differences of opinion, united under a common government. Why? Winchester acknowledges the "adhesive nature" of ideas, but believes the "ties that bind are most definitely, in their essence, practical and physical things." For Winchester, land surveys, maps, canals, railroads, interstate highways and now the Internet are the "strands of connective tissue" that have allowed the country "to achieve all it has, and yet to keep itself together while doing so." That's debatable, but Winchester is sufficiently entertaining that it's easy to forget the holes in his argument and enjoy the ride. His tour mixes popular history with a contemporary travelogue. This frustrates attempts to tell the story as a conventional history, as do the many eclectic stories he narrates. Winchester solves the problem by dividing his book into five sections that correspond to the five "classical elements" in the Chinese philosophical tradition known as the wu hsing: wood, earth, water, fire and metal. Each corresponds to a different unifying force: early land surveys (wood), geological surveys (earth), canals and waterways (water), and so forth. Chinese cosmology aside, much of what Winchester covers in these sections is familiar, particularly in the early chapters. Thomas Jefferson's Land Ordinance of 1785 - which effectively laid down a system by which unsettled territory might be surveyed, settled and united with the rest of the country - gets prominent treatment, as does Lewis and Clark's voyage of exploration. But other, less famous figures make lengthy appearances, like Thomas Hutchins, the first Geographer of the United States, who implemented Jefferson's vision. Winchester's eye for detail makes these vignettes a pleasure. Thanks to these surveys, Americans could visualize the country's borders and boundaries; the next step was to map the details of the land itself. But maps were not in themselves sufficient. "For an American in Maine to feel true kinship with a brother American in Arizona," Winchester claims, "people and the things they made needed to be able to move with speed and ease from one corner of the nation to another." That meant canals and railroads promoted by memorable characters like John Stevens, who devised and operated the nation's first steam locomotive on a small circle of track in Hoboken, N. J. Winchester believes that while a modern transportation infrastructure was essential to forging an enduring union, so, too, was the communications revolution that began with Samuel Morse's telegraph. "The moment instant communication was within the grasp of all," he writes, "America was bonded and annealed into an almost unbreakable and indivisible one." Perhaps, but this ignores the fact that the telegraph - never mind the adoption of steamboats, canals and railroads - coincided with the disintegration of the country over the issue of slavery. Improvements in infrastructure didn't prevent the outbreak of war; in fact, they may have accelerated it. From the steamboats and trains that carried pro- and antislavery settlers to "Bleeding Kansas" to the telegraph lines that reported every angry exchange in Congress, the nation's infrastructure intensified the conflict. Moreover, the very westward expansion Winchester celebrates was a catalyst for conflict, as new territories applied for admission to the union, threatening the balance between free and slave states. In the end, unity was maintained at a staggering cost of over half a million dead, and the physical integration of the country continued apace into the 20th century. Winchester is at his strongest here, profiling Theodore Dehone Judah, the eccentric promoter of the transcontinental railroad, and reprising the early career of Dwight Eisenhower, whose experience accompanying the Army's Transcontinental Motor Convoy left him impressed with the need for a national road system. Most fascinating of all is his account of Thomas MacDonald, known as Chief, the humorless but brutally effective head of the Bureau of Public Roads from 1919 to 1953. MacDonald, who gave the country its first modern road system, also paved the way - literally - for the Interstate highways. Yet he remains "forgotten, overlooked and dismissed in just about all the places he managed to bring together." The same cannot be said for many of those who connected the United States via metal wires, fiber optic cables and wireless broadcasting, including Alexander Graham Bell and Thomas Edison. But Winchester's real passion is for the unsung architects of electromagnetic unity: Morris Llewellyn Cooke, the engineer behind the New Deal's Rural Electrification Administration; Joseph Licklider, who first conceived of the Arpanet, forerunner of the Internet; and William Siemering, the driving force behind the creation of National Public Radio. All of this is fascinating. But is the "connective tissue" of the United States really a matter of building highways, whether traveled by cars or electrons? Putting people in touch with one another doesn't magically yield unity. As citizens from one part of the country communicate and mingle with people different from themselves, they do not automatically feel a kinship. These encounters can confirm existing prejudices and intensify half-formed hatreds. So why doesn't the United States fly apart at the seams? James Madison may have had it right when he argued that a large, decentralized republic spread over a vast territory was more likely to survive than one confined to a much smaller landmass. A sprawling, diverse nation like the United States would necessarily encompass so vast a variety of people that no single group could consistently impose its will on the others. In Madison's pragmatic if paradoxical vision, our very differences would keep us together. The nation would remain united because no bloc or faction can command sufficient political power to divide it and destroy the union. Of course, Madison couldn't foresee the conflict over slavery, when two distinct sections of the country went to war over their differences. But this has been the exception, not the rule. Today, the nation is rarely, if ever, united on any single political issue. Our loyalties are too divided, too fractured and too unpredictable. Our diversity divides us, but in the process, guarantees that the larger union endures. Winchester is America in miniature: many talents, many loyalties and numerous, often contradictory opinions. He's a bundle of contradictions. Little wonder he finally feels at home. STEPHEN MIHM teaches history at the University of Georgia. He is the author of "A Nation of Counterfeiters: Capitalists, Con Men, and the Making of the United States."
Copyright (c) The New York Times Company [November 10, 2013]
Review by Booklist Review
*Starred Review* The ratification of the U.S. Constitution in 1788 provided a common legal and political framework to bind 13 supposedly sovereign states to a stronger federal government. But the U.S. was still more of a theoretical nation than an actual one. The War of 1812 and the Mexican War engendered surges of nationalism, but it required a Civil War to administer the death blow to the most extreme forms of sectionalism. Winchester, the widely acclaimed author, is a native of Great Britain who recently became an American citizen. His focus here is on the more subtle aspects of nation building. He examines the accomplishments of a variety of characters, some famous and some obscure, whose visions and mastery of emerging technologies drew Americans closer together as our geographic size expanded. Thomas Jefferson's vision of an empire of liberty led to the acquisition of the Louisiana Territory and the Lewis and Clark expedition. William Maclure, a hyperactive Scottish immigrant, provided a geological survey of vast areas of the eastern U.S. and then promoted the value of a practical education for ordinary citizens. Winchester provides a fascinating portrayal of Samuel Morse, the man who tamed the lightning, and the vital role of the telegraph in bridging distances. This is a finely crafted and valuable reminder that the evolution of our united nation was a process often accelerated by unlikely, sometimes eccentric men who operated outside the political sphere. HIGH-DEMAND BACKSTORY: A 10-city author tour, e-book promotions, academic marketing, and an online publicity campaign round out the publisher's push behind this celebrated author's new book.--Freeman, Jay Copyright 2010 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
Winchester's latest history profiles a huge cast of eclectic characters who helped transform America from a cluster of colonies to a unified nation through the taming of the wilderness and the expansion of the country's infrastructure. The sweeping narrative is cleverly organized into five sections-each corresponds to one of the classical elements (wood, earth, water, fire, metal) and focuses on a different phase of American exploration or development. Winchester (The Alice Behind Wonderland) masterfully evokes the excitement of the nation's early days-when opportunity and possibility were manifest in uncharted mountains and new technologies-while bringing each of his subjects to life. Some, like Lewis and Clark, are familiar, while others-like the many topographers who set down the Mexican and Canadian boundaries-are more obscure, but no less interesting. Winchester, a Brit who recently became an American citizen, also incorporates personal travel anecdotes to comment on pivotal locations. This bold decision is the key to the book's greatest achievement: conveying the large-scale narrative of unification via the small-scale experience of the individual-the creation of a people by the agglomeration of persons. Illus. and maps. (Oct.) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Library Journal Review
Popular historian and prolific author Winchester (The Professor and the Madman) focuses on the history of his adopted country and the individuals who contributed to its functioning as a cohesive whole. He organizes what are for the most part biographical sketches thematically, yet chronologically, in five sections named for elements: "Wood," "Earth," "Water," "Fire," and "Metal." Under this scheme, the immense Eastern Woodlands forest offers the first unifying context, as Winchester writes about the trip across the continent by Lewis and Clark and their Shoshone guide Sacagawea. Next, "Earth" includes efforts of pioneering geologist William Maclure, his 1809 geologic map of the Appalachian Mountains, and its unifying scientific impact. "Water" transportation routes include the creation of the Erie Canal and those who championed its economic importance to local businessmen, such as flour merchant Jesse Hawley. Robert Fulton's steam engine used "Fire" to make railroads practical and efficient. "Metal" stitched together the country through Samuel Morse's use of telegraph wires to increase the speed of communication; FDR brought electricity to rural America over the objections of power companies. VERDICT Along the way, Winchester provides surprising insights into our social history, further enriching his narrative with accounts of his personal odysseys around the country. The results are highly recommended for public and school libraries and all readers looking for new and stimulating perspectives on the history of America. [See Prepub Alert 4/1/13.]--Nathan Bender, Albany Cty. P.L., -Laramie, WY (c) Copyright 2013. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
Using a nifty structure around the five classic elements of wood, earth, water, fire and metal, Winchester (Atlantic: Great Sea Battles, Heroic Discoveries, Titanic Storms, and a Vast Ocean of a Million Stories, 2010, etc.) celebrates the brains and brawn that forged America's Manifest Destiny. The author tells the story of the tremendous movement East to West of pioneers, explorers, miners, mappers and inventors whose collective labors made the U.S. truly e pluribus unum. Men take most of the spotlight here. Lewis and Clark's Native American guide Sacagawea is one of the only females singled out by the author, who writes that she was "the key that opened the gates of the West and allowed the white men through." Nonetheless, Winchester can tell a good yarn with evident relish, enlisting the element in question to aid in delineating his big themes: Thomas Hutchins' visionary survey system of 1785 became the model for parceling up the vast expanse of the American West, township by township; William Maclure made the first truly detailed geological map of the U.S. in 1809; the discovery of the "fall line" in many American rivers suddenly rendering them impassable prompted the brilliant use of the canal system as employed by Loammi Baldwin; the building of the interstate road system, beginning with the very first in Cumberland, Md., constructed by John McAdam's new crushed-rock method in 1812; and finally, the advent of the ubiquitous telegraph wires across the country by 1860, carrying information and spelling the beginning of the new age and the end of the old. In between these milestones are a myriad other stories of American ingenuity, which Winchester recounts with enormous gusto and verve. Another winning book from a historian whose passion for his subjects saturates his works.]] Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
