Review by New York Times Review
SOMETIMES, ONE MAGNIFICENT season can define an era. At least, that's the view in trade publishing of late, where "year" books have become something of a mania: "19 : The Year Our World Changed/ Began/Ended/Learned to Love the Macarena." But it's not hard to argue that the apogee of the wild ride America took in the 1920s came in the summer of 1927. It was the summer - if one allows "summer" to occasionally include parts of both spring and fall - that Babe Ruth hit 60 home runs, much of the country was engulfed by a catastrophic flood, Jack Dempsey lost the famous "long count" fight to Gene Tunney, Calvin Coolidge announced he wouldn't run for another term, the world's leading bankers made the policy adjustment that would do so much to bring down Wall Street in 1929, "The Jazz Singer" was released, radio and tabloid culture came into their own, an American audience got its first public demonstration of television, work started on Mount Rushmore, Sacco and Vanzetti were executed, and Henry Ford stopped making Model T's. And oh, yes, most of the world went mad over a 25-year-old prodigy named Charles Lindbergh, who flew a flimsy plane to Paris from New York. This isn't to mention all the other fascinating characters Bill Bryson brings splendidly to life in "One Summer" - people like Al Capone and Dorothy Parker; Philo T. Farnsworth, the young man who played a critical role in inventing the television; and the New York Times reporter Richards Vidmer, who married a rajah's daughter and was "also perhaps the most memorably dreadful sportswriter ever." The author of more than a dozen previous books, including "A Short History of Nearly Everything," Bryson writes in a style as effervescent as the time itself. Lindbergh's plane, the Spirit of St. Louis, was "little more than a flying gas tank," and piloting it for his landmark flight "would have been rather like crossing the ocean in a tent." Before 1920, pitchers might apply spit or "at least two dozen other globulous additives" to a baseball, and the habit of drying out ball fields by lighting gasoline fires on them was "hardly conducive to a fine, delicate tilth." No one is immune to Bryson's irreverence. Ty Cobb was "only a degree or two removed from clinical psychopathy." When the wife of the Chicago Tribune publisher Robert McCormick died, "he had her buried with full military honors, a distinction to which she was not remotely entitled (or very probably desirous)." And "there was almost nothing Henry Ford did that didn't have some bad in it somewhere." Warren Harding "fell considerably short of mediocre" and, when it came to women, "truly was a bit of a dog." Coolidge's sense of humor "was that of a slightly backward schoolboy," while Herbert Hoover proved "there was no matter too small to escape his numbing pomposity." Inanimate objects are sent up just as delightfully. We meet a railroad that "wandered confusedly around the upper Midwest, as if looking for a lost item," while in a Chicago movie palace, "the marbled lobby was said to be an almost exact copy of the king's chapel at Versailles except presumably for the smell of popcorn." This makes for a wonderful romp, though the hyperbole of the age frequently runs away with Bryson. Great as Babe Ruth was, he does not still hold the record for shutouts by a left-handed pitcher in a season, and he did not hit three home runs in his last game, or compile 26 outfield assists in 1919 (the correct number is 14). The cartoonist Tad Dorgan did not invent the name "hot dog"; someone in Al Capone's "camp" did not coin the phrase "Vote early and vote often" ; and it was not true that Lindbergh "would no longer be anybody's hero" by "the time America was ready to take to the air properly." The advent of the talking picture in 1927 was not the "last hurrah" for Broadway, and Hoover did not win the presidency in 1928 with "nearly two-thirds of the popular vote." A little more seriously, Bryson makes the wild charge that Hoover "illegally bought chemicals from Germany" during World War I "as part of his business operations," thus engaging in "an act that could have led to his being taken outside, stood against a wall and shot." I'm unaware that Hoover was engaged in any business during the war beyond feeding starving Belgian and French citizens, and working as the United States Food Administrator. A few, histrionic accusations of this sort were flung at him by a disgruntled employee and a couple of political opponents - and thoroughly discredited by a British court of inquiry at the time. Bryson is best at deflating our nostalgia for the era, even as he upholds its importance. The America of the 1920s, with its laissez-faire economics, rugged individualism, and relentless public piety and patriotism, was a Tea Party utopia. I find the period's allure understandable. The country was rich and loaded with miraculous new things: the car, the radio, the refrigerator. Every big city had its proud new skyscraper, and we had just pioneered the mall and the planned suburb. We added more phones every year than Britain had in toto, and Kansas had more automobiles than France. We held half the world's gold and made almost half its goods, and seemed to churn out a similarly abundant supply of heroic young daredevils. We were, at the same time, a curiously dysfunctional nation, one where twothirds of the murders went unsolved, and the average homicide rate was exponentially higher than it is now in much of the country. We were barely able to build a road or a functional airfield, or to efficiently coordinate our extensive rail system. When the Mississippi overflowed in the worst flood in its history - inundating 16.5 million acres, costing over 1,000 fives ("and perhaps several times that," Bryson writes; the human tallies "weren't more scrupulous because, alas, so many of the victims were poor and black") and resulting in up to $1 billion in losses - Coolidge, anointed earlier this year in a biography by Amity Shlaes as the model of a modern right-wing president, refused to provide even an autographed picture to be auctioned off for flood relief. Aid was provided largely by the private sector and charitable organizations, which managed all of $20 per victim in loans. "There may never have been another time in the nation's history when more people disliked more other people from more directions and for less reason," Bryson writes, referring to the era as "the Age of Loathing." He has a point. Americans in the 1920s flocked to join the Ku Klux Klan and rushed to embrace the new pseudoscience of eugenics. The Supreme Court backed these extremists, upholding the "right" of states to forcibly sterilize tens of thousands of supposed "imbeciles," who were in fact often just poor, black or unmarried women. There seemed, everywhere, to be an undercurrent of malicious madness that could be glimpsed in the hysteria surrounding celebrities and scandalous murder cases. Having created the modern mobster, we then refused to prosecute him, turning state power instead on dissidents and unions, while enforcing Prohibition by lacing alcohol with poisons. There was even a school massacre in 1927, perpetrated by an anti-tax maniac. Disappointed in the world, we had refused to join the League of Nations and slammed the golden door shut to immigrants. Nonetheless, we reached out despite ourselves, with our ideas and our culture, riding the air and the airwaves. Every time you turned around, it seemed, Americans were starting another magazine, newspaper or bold new publishing house, or developing a musical form. The capper was the moving picture. We produced 80 percent of the world's movies by 1927, and the rise of the "talkies" would popularize, as Bryson notes, not only American speech but "American thoughts, American attitudes, American humor and sensibilities. Peacefully, by accident, and almost unnoticed, America had just taken over the world." KEVIN BAKER'S new novel is "The Big Crowd."
Copyright (c) The New York Times Company [November 24, 2013]
Review by Booklist Review
*Starred Review* On May 21, 1927, when Charles Lindbergh set off to be the first man to cross the Atlantic alone in an airplane, he profoundly changed the culture and commerce of America and its image abroad. Add to that Babe Ruth's efforts to break the home-run record he set, Henry Ford's retooling of the Model T into the Model A, the execution of accused anarchists Sacco and Vanzetti, and Al Jolson appearing in the first talkie, and 1927 became the pivot point when the U.S. began to dominate the world in virtually everything military, culture, commerce, and technology. Bryson's inimitable wit and exuberance are on full display in this wide-ranging look at the major events in an exciting summer in America. Bryson makes fascinating interconnections: a quirky Chicago judge and Prohibition defender leaves the bench to become baseball commissioner following the White Sox scandal, likely leaving Chicago open for gangster Al Capone; the thrill-hungry tabloids and a growing cult of celebrity watchers dog Lindbergh's every move and chronicle Ruth's every peccadillo. Among the other events in a frenzied summer: record flooding of the Mississippi River and the ominous beginnings of the Great Depression. Bryson offers delicious detail and breathtaking suspense about events whose outcomes are already known. A glorious look at one summer in America. HIGH-DEMAND BACKSTORY: Bryson is the author of such best-selling books as A Walk in the Woods (1998) and A Short History of Nearly Everything (2008) and is sure to make a repeat appearance on the best-seller lists with his newest work.--Bush, Vanessa Copyright 2010 Booklist
From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review
"People in 1920s America were unusually drawn to spectacle," states Bryson (A Short History of Nearly Everything) in his prologue-an unusual claim that his latest, a sprawling account of a brief period in a singular year in that decade, seems to want to substantiate. Whether or not the claim is objectively true, Bryson himself is captivated by the events of summer, 1927. And why not? They included Charles Lindbergh's solo flight over the Atlantic, Sacco and Vanzetti's execution, Gutzon Borglum's start on the sculpting of Mt. Rushmore, the Dempsey-Carpentier fight, and Babe Ruth's 60 home runs-all of which Bryson covers in characteristically sparkling prose. These notable happenings are worth relating and recalling, but others have done so, and more authoritatively and fully. Here, there's not much connection between them; a string of coincidents (and there are many of those each day) hardly justify a book. So this isn't history, nor is it really a story with a start, finish, and thematic spine. No analysis, only narrative-it's diverting but slight. (Oct.) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Review by Library Journal Review
In Bryson's (At Home) prismatic look at America's coming of age during five pivotal months in 1927, emphasis is placed on the meteoric rise of Charles Lindbergh, who quickly became a victim of his fame after his solo Atlantic crossing. The author also touches upon many other historical events, however. Party boy Babe Ruth and mama's boy Lou Gehrig are presented as avatars for America's love affair with baseball. The Snyder-Grey murder trial is depicted as an early tabloid sensation. Bryson suggests that anarchists Sacco and Vanzetti might not have been as guilty as accused but were not as innocent as they claimed. The Mississippi flood and the handling of it by publicity-mad Secretary of Commerce Herbert Hoover get pages, along with factoids about Big Bill Tilden, Mount Rushmore, negative eugenics, libidinous Zane Grey, Prohibition and denatured alcohol, Secretary of the Treasury Andrew Mellon's machinations with the IRS, talking motion pictures, Jack Dempsey and big boxing, David Sarnoff's ruthless domination of radio, and more. The author's excellent narration adds nuance to this recording. Resources at the end of the print book were not recorded. VERDICT Recommend to lovers of American studies and those who enjoyed David Traxel's 1898 and Frederick Lewis Allen's Only Yesterday. ["The book's strength is in showing the overlap of significant events and the interaction of personalities. But the author's approach keeps the reader from gaining a real sense of the landscape; this is more a spatter painting," read the review of the Doubleday hc, LJ 9/1/13.-Ed.]-David -Faucheux, Louisiana Audio Information & Reading Svc., Lafayette (c) Copyright 2014. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Review by Kirkus Book Review
A popular chronicler of life and lore vividly charts a particularly pivotal season in American history. Bryson (At Home: A Short History of Private Life, 2010, etc.) reanimates the events and principal players across five key months in 1927. He establishes an early-20th-century, trial-and-error chronology of aviation evolution cresting with Charles Lindbergh, a lean man with a dream, natural-born skills and the unparalleled motivation to design an aircraft capable of traversing the Atlantic. Braided into Lindbergh's saga are profiles of cultural icons like ambitious "colossus" Herbert Hoover, famed gangster Al Capone, and baseball players Lou Gehrig and Babe Ruth, whose domination of America's "National Game" captured the country's attention. Recounted with brio and diligent detailing yet perhaps lacking the author's better-known witty dynamism, Bryson honorably captures the spirit of the era, a golden age of newspapers, skyscrapers, patriotism, Broadway plays and baseball. The author enthusiastically draws on the heroic lives of tight-lipped President Calvin Coolidge and boxing great Jack Dempsey and artfully interweaves into Lindbergh's meteoric rise the pitfalls of Prohibition, the splendor of Henry Ford's Model T (and the horrors of constructing "Fordlandia" in the Amazon rain forest), the demise of anarchists Sacco and Vanzetti, and a noteworthy comparison between popular long-standing authors Zane Grey and Edgar Rice Burroughs. Collectively, what Bryson offers is a creatively written regeneration of historical facts; the revelations, while few, appear in the form of eccentric personal factoids (i.e., Coolidge liked his head rubbed with Vaseline, Grey was excessively libidinous) demarcating that scrutinized summer of dreamers and innovators. While he may be an expatriate residing in England, Bryson's American pride saturates this rewarding book. A distinctively drawn time capsule from a definitive epoch.]] Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.