Parenting without borders Surprising lessons parents around the world can teach us

Christine Gross-Loh

Book - 2013

"Research reveals American kids today lag well behind the rest of the world in terms of academic achievement, happiness, and wellness. Meanwhile the battle over whether parents are to blame for fostering a generation of helpless kids rages on. Christine Gross-Loh (who raised her young children in Japan for five years) exposes the hidden, culturally-determined norms we have about good parenting, and asks, are there parenting strategies that other countries are getting right that we are not?"--Amazon.com

Saved in:

2nd Floor Show me where

649.1/Gross-Loh
1 / 1 copies available
Location Call Number   Status
2nd Floor 649.1/Gross-Loh Checked In
Subjects
Published
New York : Avery c2013.
Language
English
Main Author
Christine Gross-Loh (-)
Physical Description
308 p. ; 24 cm
Bibliography
Includes bibliographical references and index.
ISBN
9781583334553
  • Introduction
  • Part 1. The Care and Feeding of Children
  • 1. Sleep Time: Keep Our Babies Close or Give Them Space?
  • 2. Buy, Buy, Baby: Why Are We Drowning in Stuff?
  • 3. Global Food Rules: How Parents Around the World Teach Their Kids to Eat
  • Part 2. The Raising of Children
  • 4. Feeling Good: Can Self-Esteem Be Harmful?
  • 5. Hoverparenting: How Can We Foster Self-Control?
  • 6. Quality Time: The Value of Unstructured Play
  • Part 3. The Teaching of Children
  • 7. High Pressure? What Asian Learning Looks Like
  • 8. Every Child Counts: High Achieving, the Finnish Way
  • Part 4. The Character of Children
  • 9. Raising Kindness: Cultural Notions About Raising Kids Who Care
  • 10. Raising Responsibility: Avoiding the Helplessness Trap
  • Conclusion: It Takes a Village
  • Acknowledgments
  • Notes
  • Index
Review by Kirkus Book Review

An intriguing look at parenting paradigms in countries where children are deemed to be the best adjusted. Gross-Loh (The Diaper-Free Baby, 2007, etc.), a first generation Korean-American with a doctorate from Harvard, spent five years raising four kids in Japan. This experience challenged her assumptions about child-rearing and inspired her to investigate whether or not the ideas about parenting held by Americans--or at least, those who are middle class to affluent, raising college-bound children--are empirically based realities or cultural norms. Most readers can guess the answer, as well as the conclusion that there is a lot wrong with how American youth are prepared for adulthood, especially as compared to their Scandinavian, Western European and East Asian counterparts. But Gross-Loh's patient, grounded explication and engaging personal anecdotes make this a much more positive, culturally expansive contribution to the discussion than most parenting books. This is not to say that readers won't occasionally become frustrated by the repetitive idealization of certain overseas child-rearing practices. Gross-Loh acknowledges and identifies with the challenge of modeling approaches like France's two-hour, fresh, multicourse school lunch; Japan's first-graders running family errands as a means of developing self-reliance and judgment; or Finland's individualized education plan for each student, executed by highly qualified teachers and trained professional specialists. The book would be stronger if the author delved further into practical strategies that frazzled American families in isolated suburbs could use immediately, short of enrolling their children in a Swedish forest school. Nonetheless, this is a strong survey of such well-chosen topics as where babies sleep, materialism, eating habits, self-esteem, unstructured time, kindness, chores, education and independence. Gross-Loh's recurring theme is that American parents, who experience more angst and judgment than those abroad, inculcate their children with plenty of individualism and tolerance but not enough empathy or autonomy. Current alarm over U.S. student global rankings will help give this persuasive book the consideration it deserves.]] Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.

Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.

INTRODUCTION We all want the best for our children, but what does that mean? Robert LeVine, an eminent Harvard anthropologist, determined that parents around the world universally share three goals in raising their children. The first goal is survival and health: Parents want their children to stay alive. For those who live in societies where they can be reasonably sure of being able to meet children's most basic survival needs past infancy, though, the second universal goal is to raise children who will have the basic skills they'll need to sustain themselves economically once they grow up. And finally, there's the goal of self-maximization-of raising a socially competent child who possesses the cultural values that are considered important, and who will succeed in that society: a child who will thrive . I didn't know if I would ever have a child. Pregnancy didn't come easily to me, and my husband, David, and I experienced the heartache of infertility before conceiving our first baby. But I always loved children and longed for the day I might become a mother. When I finally became pregnant, survival was a question: I hemorrhaged so severely in my seventh month that doctors told us the pregnancy was in danger. It wasn't until tiny Benjamin was born and safely in my arms, when I looked at his face with his wide brown eyes, mop of black hair, and the puzzled expression that elicited such fierce protectiveness inside me, that I started to think about what kind of parent I would be and how I could best raise a child who would not only survive but also thrive. My parents immigrated to the United States from South Korea shortly before I was born in 1968. Growing up in the 1970s in small-town Pennsylvania, I straddled two cultures every day of my childhood. In some ways my parents were very Korean in how they raised us: We used chopsticks at the dinner table; kimchi, seaweed, and rice were staples in our home; I was taught not to call adults by their first names and to behave respectfully toward older relatives. Education was highly valued in our house and we were expected to complete our homework on time and get good grades. Sometimes this felt like a lot of pressure. At the same time, my parents had a broad perspective and were enthusiastic and relaxed about the things my brothers and I wanted to do, whether it was make our own Halloween costumes, pretend to pan for gold in a creek, watch movies for hours with our friends, or eat or read whatever we wanted. When I look back on my childhood, I am actually astounded by how little my parents questioned the things we were doing with our time and where our lives were going, especially since our American small-town childhood was so different from their own. They had their worries, as many immigrant families who strongly want their children to thrive in their new society often do. I remember hushed conversations between my mom and dad about whether we were really getting a good education, and get-togethers with other Korean immigrant families where parents exchanged questions about the schools their children were attending as they tried to navigate an alien school system. Sometimes our differences really compounded my self- consciousness about being one of the few Asian-American students in school. But like many American parents of my generation, I find myself looking back with amazement at a degree of freedom and acceptance that seems virtually lost today. Even though my parents always conveyed the value of holding high expectations, they gave us so much time and space to experiment, play, and just be. They were always trying to do their best for us. They believed in our potential to flourish. But they weren't always trying to mold and change us. During my twenties I lived in Japan several times, first to study Japanese and then to do research for a doctorate in East Asian history. In a remote village nestled in the mountainous countryside, I met David, who, like me, was a student who had come to Japan to learn the language. When David and I returned to the United States and decided to get married, we also knew that we might eventually be going back to Japan one day and maybe even raising children there. No matter where our children would grow up, though, I knew I loved America. And I knew there were many things from my own Korean-American upbringing and my Jewish-American husband's that would shape our family's life. Excerpted from Parenting Without Borders: Surprising Lessons Parents Around the World Can Teach Us by Christine Gross-Loh All rights reserved by the original copyright owners. Excerpts are provided for display purposes only and may not be reproduced, reprinted or distributed without the written permission of the publisher.