A slap in the face Why insults hurt and why they shouldn't

William Braxton Irvine, 1952-

Book - 2013

William Irvine undertakes a wide-ranging investigation of insults, their history, the role they play in social relationships, and the science behind them, examining not just memorable zingers, such as Elizabeth Bowen's description of Aldous Huxley as "The stupid person's idea of a clever person," but subtle insults as well, such as when someone insults us by reporting the insulting things others have said about us: "I never read bad reviews about myself," wrote entertainer Oscar Levant, "because my best friends invariably tell me about them." Irvine also considers the role insults play in our society: they can be used to cement relations, as when a woman playfully teases her husband, or to enforce a s...ocial hierarchy, as when a boss publicly berates an employee. He goes on to investigate the many ways society has tried to deal with insults-by adopting codes of politeness, for example, and outlawing hate speech-but concludes that the best way to deal with insults is to immunize ourselves against them: We need to transform ourselves in the manner recommended by Stoic philosophers. We should, more precisely, become insult pacifists, trying hard not to insult others and laughing off their attempts to insult us.

Saved in:

2nd Floor Show me where

155.232/Irvine
1 / 1 copies available
Location Call Number   Status
2nd Floor 155.232/Irvine Checked In
Subjects
Published
New York : Oxford University Press [2013]
Language
English
Main Author
William Braxton Irvine, 1952- (-)
Physical Description
253 pages ; 19 cm
Bibliography
Includes bibliographical references and index.
ISBN
9780199934454
  • 1. Introduction
  • Part 1. The Insult Arsenal
  • 2. Words like Daggers
  • 3. Subtle Digs
  • 4. Bludgeoned with Praise
  • 5. Benign Insults
  • Part 2. Insult Psychology
  • 6. A World of Hurt
  • 7. Who Gets Hurt?
  • 8. Why We Insult
  • Part 3. Dealing With Insults
  • 9. Personal Responses to Insults
  • 10. Societal Responses to Insults
  • 11. Insults-The Inner Game
  • 12. Insights
  • Notes
  • Works Cited
Review by Booklist Review

Philosophy professor Irvine begins this intriguing book with an examination of the various types of insult: verbal and physical, of course, but also practical jokes, the silent treatment, backbiting, insults by omission, insults by implication, accidental insults, sarcasm, and so on. Readers looking to add to their stock of insults will find much good material here, but they'll also find an insightful analysis of the way we insult each other, why we do it, how we react, and how we can adjust our notion of insults and modify our reactions to them. Do we tend to overreact to insults? Do we see an insult where none is intended? Especially interesting is the author's look at the ways we, as a society, have attempted to deal with insults and his analysis of whether these approaches are successful, or even necessary (perhaps the best way to deal with insults is simply to laugh them off). Written in a lively, entertaining style, the book is intended for a general audience, and anyone who picks it up should find something of interest.--Pitt, David Copyright 2010 Booklist

From Booklist, Copyright (c) American Library Association. Used with permission.
Review by Publisher's Weekly Review

We may not like to admit it, but the impulse to wound with words has long been a part of human history, Irvine (A Guide to the Good Life: The Ancient Art of Stoic Joy) contends in this melange of philosophy, psychology, and cultural study. Insults may range from barbs meant as flirtatious bait to the famously eloquent gibes of Shakespeare, but Irvine pragmatically argues that regardless of intention or context, we must understand insults in order to deal with them: "Sticks and stones can break your bones," he concedes, "but you should develop a strategy to minimize the pain you experience when people call you names." To that end, Irvine, a philosophy professor at Wayne State University, investigates the history of abuse, as well as the rhetoric of insult delivery and the science behind feeling affronted. He posits that the power of insults derives from our profoundly social nature, and that we wouldn't feel hurt if we weren't simultaneously invested in others and worried about how they see us. Irvine ultimately opines that a return to the pacifism and equanimity of the ancient Stoics is our best bet for dealing with insult, and while such a stance may be off-putting to some readers, Irvine adds a welcome dose of insight to injury. Agent: Byrd Leavell, Waxman Leavell Literary Agency. (Mar.) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.

(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved